TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
With Grayscale allowing crypto-to-share exchanges, why are crypto OGs no longer holding the coins themselves?

With Grayscale allowing crypto-to-share exchanges, why are crypto OGs no longer holding the coins themselves?

2026.10.22
Share
Why would a crypto-savvy person choose an ETF instead of directly holding coins?

Written by: Xiaobing

The crypto industry spent 15 years building a belief: Be your own bank, hold your own private keys, and trust no intermediaries.

Now, the earliest cohorts to make money in this industry are handing their coins over to Wall Street.

On October 21, Grayscale announced the expansion of in-kind subscriptions across its ten crypto investment products. Qualified investors can directly exchange tokens for fund shares without first selling the coins for cash. The covered products include the Bitcoin Mini Trust ETF, Ethereum Staking Mini ETF, and funds for Avalanche, Chainlink, Dogecoin, Hyperliquid, Solana, Sui, XRP, and Zcash, with minimum subscription amounts ranging from $80,000 to $360,000.

In the announcement, Grayscale Index Head Steve Vanourny remarked something interesting: "With the rise of cybersecurity threats, including vulnerabilities in self-custody and DeFi, institutional-grade custody is becoming increasingly valuable."

The Choice of an Industry OG

To understand this trend, the best example is Huobi founder Li Lin.

Li Lin founded Huobi in 2013 and was among the pioneers who built China's earliest crypto exchanges. He sold Huobi in 2022 and subsequently transformed his personal family office, Avenir Group, into an investment firm.

According to SEC Form 13F filings, Avenir Group began holding BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) starting in Q2 2024, ranking as Asia's largest institutional holder of Bitcoin ETFs for eight consecutive quarters. Its holdings grew from approximately 11.3 million shares in Q4 2024 to around 18.3 million shares in Q3 2025 (valued at roughly $1.19 billion), and held steady at approximately 18.28 million shares in Q1 2026 (valued at roughly $702 million).

Someone who built a crypto exchange, someone who understood Bitcoin earlier and more deeply than most Wall Street fund managers, has chosen to place a billion-dollar BTC exposure in BlackRock's ETF rather than keeping it in a cold wallet.

What Exactly Is Being Exchanged in "Coins for Shares"?

The "in-kind subscription" mechanism expanded by Grayscale this time has been running in the traditional ETF industry for decades, but it's new territory for crypto.

On July 29, 2025, the SEC approved in-kind creation and redemption for crypto ETPs. Prior to this, all US Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs could only be created or redeemed in cash: Authorized Participants (APs) had to hand dollars to the fund, which would then buy coins on the open market. For redemptions, it worked in reverse—the fund sold coins and returned cash to the APs.

The in-kind mechanism changes this workflow. An AP can directly hand over Bitcoin to the fund in exchange for ETF shares. Upon redemption, the fund returns the actual Bitcoin directly to the AP.

This looks like a mere procedural optimization, but it solves a core problem: taxes.

Under the cash model, when the fund sells Bitcoin, it triggers capital gains, and this tax burden is ultimately allocated to all shareholders. Under the in-kind model, transferring Bitcoin directly to the AP does not constitute a "sale" and does not trigger a taxable event. For early holders who bought Bitcoin in 2015 or 2016, paper profits could be ten to fifteen times their cost basis. Selling coins directly to convert to ETF shares would incur a massive capital gains tax bill. Through in-kind subscription, that tax is deferred.

Note: deferral is not exemption. The original cost basis carries over to the ETF shares, and taxes will still be owed upon selling the ETF later. But for someone managing billion-dollar positions, the difference between "paying now" and "not paying now" is enormous.

Grayscale has expanded this mechanism from its flagship Bitcoin and Ethereum products to ten products covering different coins, meaning that not only major BTC holders, but also large holders of SOL, XRP, LINK, or even DOGE, can now "deposit" their coins into the funds using the same method.

The 15-Year Upward Trend of Self-Custody Has Been Interrupted

Li Lin is not an isolated case.

Robbie Mitchnick, Head of Digital Assets at BlackRock, revealed to Bloomberg that IBIT has already processed over $3 billion worth of whale Bitcoin conversions. These early holders moved their on-chain BTC into IBIT, converted them to ETF shares, and placed them into their brokerage accounts or private banking relationships for management.

On-chain data shows that since the approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024, the growth rate of self-custodied BTC has continued to decline. Analyst Willy Woo observed: "Since the launch of spot ETFs, the growth rate of self-custody users has been consistently falling."

The number of active Bitcoin addresses dropped from nearly 1 million in January 2024 to around 650,000 by the end of June 2025, marking the lowest level since 2019.

As of July 2025, IBIT managed assets exceeding $88 billion, holding over 700,000 BTC. It crossed the $80 billion milestone in just 374 days, compared to 1,814 days for Vanguard's VOO. By Q4 2024, institutional investors accounted for 25.4% of total spot Bitcoin ETF assets, roughly $26.8 billion.

Meanwhile, the number of publicly traded companies holding BTC reached 125 in Q2 2025, an increase of 58% from the previous quarter.

What Are They Actually Buying?

Why would someone who "understands crypto" choose an ETF instead of direct coin holdings? Answering this requires breaking it down.

Tax efficiency is the most direct driver. The tax deferral from in-kind subscriptions is highly attractive for large positions. An early player holding $100 million in BTC with a cost basis under $10 million would face tens of millions in immediate tax liabilities if they sold directly to enter the traditional financial system. Through in-kind subscriptions into ETFs, that money stays temporarily in their pocket.

Custody convenience is the second layer. Self-custody means safeguarding seed phrases, defending against hackers, and planning for inheritance. With relentless security incidents in the crypto industry throughout 2024—DeFi protocol hacks, phishing scams, and so on—even Grayscale itself cited "cybersecurity threats" as a selling point in its announcements. The underlying assets of ETFs are custodied by institutions like Coinbase or BitGo, offering insurance and legal recourse in case of incidents, providing immense peace of mind for those managing substantial wealth.

The third layer is access to financial infrastructure. ETF shares can be placed in retirement accounts (IRAs), used as collateral for loans, leveraged through broker margin accounts, and included in family trust portfolios. Direct ownership of BTC cannot do this, or makes it exceedingly complex. For an ultra-high-net-worth individual who needs to unify global asset management within a private banking relationship, an IBIT ticker is far more practical than a string of hexadecimal addresses.

Another layer involves compliance costs. Tax reporting and anti-money laundering compliance for directly holding large amounts of crypto assets are becoming increasingly complex. ETFs bundle these responsibilities for the fund managers, leaving holders to simply report a single line item of securities holdings.

What Does This Mean?

Mitchnick's exact words were: "These early adopters are much more comfortable managing their exposures within existing financial advisory or private banking relationships."

This doesn't mean self-custody is dead. The core narrative for Bitcoin remains "digital gold" and a "censorship-resistant asset". For those who view BTC as a hedge against systemic risk, placing coins in BlackRock's custodial account clearly contradicts the original ethos.

But for another cohort, BTC has shifted from "faith" to "asset allocation". What they want is to efficiently hold this position within the financial system; fighting the system was never on their priority list. ETFs provide them with a vessel that is tax-friendly, compliance-convenient, securely custodied, and embeddable into existing wealth management frameworks.

Grayscale expanding in-kind subscriptions from two products to ten, and BlackRock processing $3 billion in whale conversions, all point in the same direction: the "ownership" of crypto assets is migrating from on-chain wallets to Wall Street's account systems.

The price exposure to Bitcoin remains, but the spirit of "Not your keys, not your coins" is being replaced by "Not your ETF, not your tax deferral".

Uphold Chief Investment Officer Martin Hiesboeck delivered a piercing remark: "This is yet another nail in the coffin of the original crypto ethos."

However, some have offered a more measured rebuttal: ETFs aren't stealing users from cold wallets; they are unlocking markets that were previously blocked by regulatory walls. Believers in self-custody have never been ETFs' target clientele; the colossal pools of traditional finance capital are.

Both perspectives are valid. But when the group that understands crypto best in this industry starts choosing ETFs, the story is no longer just "Wall Street has arrived," but rather "the crypto industry has walked over itself."