TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Wall Street is fiercely divided over SpaceX: bears value shares at just $62, while bulls call for up to $800.

Wall Street is fiercely divided over SpaceX: bears value shares at just $62, while bulls call for up to $800.

2026.10.08
Share
The Goertek contract includes delivery deadlines and termination clauses, while the unlock of up to 1.3 billion shares following the next earnings report represents the most direct short-term supply pressure.

Author: Peter Cohan

Compiled by: TechFlow

TechFlow Summary: Four months after its IPO, SpaceX is valued at roughly $2.2 trillion, yet Morningstar and Aswath Damodaran assign a fundamental valuation of only $62 to $100 per share, while Morgan Stanley’s Adam Jonas outlines an optimistic scenario of $600, and Raymond James even sees it reaching $800. In our view, the core of this divergence hinges on whether Anthropic’s and Google’s two AI compute contracts can be fulfilled—the Google contract includes delivery deadlines and termination clauses—and the release of up to 1.3 billion shares following the next earnings report represents the most direct near-term supply pressure.

Four months into the largest IPO in history, SpaceX remains a highly controversial stock—its price is down 26% from the historic high of $225 set in June 2026. However, this marks a significant rebound compared to the early-August low of $105.

At a $2.2 trillion market capitalization, is the stock cheap? By traditional fundamental measures, the company may be overvalued by 40% to 64%. Yet many bullish analysts—most of whom work at investment banks eager to help SpaceX raise capital—have assigned very high valuations to SpaceX’s AI business.

Since I wrote about SpaceX ahead of its June IPO, the company has delivered a mixed second-quarter earnings report. According to Yahoo Finance, revenue beat expectations, nearly doubling to $7.81 billion, with Starlink users reaching 12 million. However, Starlink is the only profitable business segment, while SpaceX’s AI division logged capital expenditures of up to $15.8 billion.

Wall Street remains divided on the next move for SpaceX’s stock—which, according to Raymond James, could either decline or rally nearly 3.8 times higher to $800.

Why Some Analysts Believe SpaceX Is Overvalued

According to Morningstar, SpaceX boasts a price-to-sales ratio of 79x, placing it among the most expensive mega-cap publicly traded stocks ever. Analyst Nicolas Owens estimates the company’s fair value at $62 per share, implying the current stock price is nearly three times its intrinsic value. In his full report, Owens assigns only a 7% probability to the so-called “Moonshot” scenario—where SpaceX’s AI business captures 20% of the AI compute market in 2024.

New York University professor Aswath Damodaran, known as the “Dean of Valuation,” estimates SpaceX’s equity value at approximately $1.3 trillion, which is roughly 44% lower than its current market cap, or about $100 per share.

Damodaran disputes the $26 trillion total addressable market for AI cited in the prospectus, calling it beyond reasonable bounds. He also cautions that because trading in SpaceX’s stock is predominantly driven by momentum traders, being right on valuation does not necessarily mean the stock price will drop.

Why Bulls Believe SpaceX Still Has Room to Surge

According to TipRanks, the average price target for SpaceX is $235, implying the stock is undervalued by approximately 40%.

Morgan Stanley’s Adam Jonas projects SpaceX’s revenue will grow to $319 billion by 2030, assigning a base-case price target of $300 and an optimistic scenario of $600. He describes SpaceX as a “potential generational compounding stock,” attributing more than half of his price target to the merger between SpaceX and xAI, with the remainder allocated to launch services and Starlink connectivity businesses.

Bullish arguments are built on contracted AI revenues. According to CNBC, Anthropic is expected to pay $1.25 billion monthly through May 2029, while Google has agreed to pay $920 million monthly starting in October 2026.

According to Reuters, SpaceX also secured a $4.16 billion contract with the U.S. Space Force for tracking satellites under the “Golden Dome” initiative, along with a $2.29 billion network contract.

Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and Bank of America have all issued bullish recommendations, and all three firms participated in underwriting SpaceX’s IPO.

Why Bears Question the AI Narrative

These AI contracts are not as rock-solid as they may appear. According to Yahoo Finance, if SpaceX fails to deliver the promised compute capacity by the end of September 2026, Google can terminate the agreement immediately after a one-month grace period, or accept prorated reduced payments. As of October 7, it remains officially unconfirmed whether SpaceX has delivered this portion of compute capacity.

There are further concerns: as disclosed in the prospectus regarding Elon Musk’s control, Musk holds 85.1% of the voting rights, enough to sway shareholder votes.

The NASA Inspector General has raised concerns regarding the progress and safety of the Starship lunar lander. Amazon is building a competitor to Starlink following an exemption from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), putting it in direct competition with SpaceX. Additionally, SpaceX cannot be included in the S&P 500 index before June 2027, and its losses calculated under U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) could prolong its exclusion.

Key Catalysts to Watch

Several short-term indicators worth tracking include:

Starship Flight 15. This test flight is currently scheduled for no earlier than October 19. A successful launch would be a positive catalyst, while a failure or prolonged delay would weigh on the stock.

Third-quarter earnings report. The release date has not been finalized. Investors should monitor AI revenue, Starlink pricing, and capital expenditures.

Lock-up expirations. According to CNBC, the initial wave of restricted shares hitting the market previously pressured the stock. Within two trading days after the next earnings release, up to 1.3 billion shares will become freely tradable, representing 28% of the locked-in pool. Due to a deferred batch of 455.8 million contingent shares whose conditions were never met, an additional maximum of 797.6 million shares will unlock around December 8.

Short positions and volatility. High short interest combined with an exceptionally high beta means that AI sentiment shifts and interest rate changes could both heavily influence SpaceX’s stock price.

The current stock price reflects optimistic market expectations for AI compute revenue. If the contracts with Anthropic and Google convert into sustained, high-margin profitability, the bullish targets on Wall Street appear achievable, and Morgan Stanley’s $300 target makes sense.

If that proves impossible, the fundamental anchor of $62 to $100 per share highlights the potential downside. This gap is what truly matters, signaling that investors should carefully manage their position sizes rather than betting firmly on either side.