TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
a16z Founders In-Depth Interview: Why Do We Need the CLARITY Act?

a16z Founders In-Depth Interview: Why Do We Need the CLARITY Act?

2026.08.03
Share
The absence of regulation is the greatest risk.

Source: a16z

Compiled by: Chopper, Foresight News

In the recent "a16z crypto Interview Program," a16z founder Marc Andreessen and a16z crypto founder Chris Dixon appeared on the show, engaging in a dialogue with host Robert Hackett centered around the "CLARITY Act." This market structure bill is currently advancing through deliberation in the Senate. Whether the bill passes or stalls will have profound implications. The following is a transcript of the conversation, edited for length and clarity. You can watch the full program to listen to the entire discussion.

Robert: The U.S. Congress is deliberating on a once-in-a-century market structure legislation, which may determine where the future financial system and internet technology will land and develop. The bill passed with bipartisan support in the House of Representatives last year and has since continued to advance through the Senate.

Currently, there are many debates and obstacles surrounding this technology, which we will discuss in detail later. But before that, let's start from a macro perspective and talk about why regulatory clarity is so important, what costs maintaining the status quo entails, and what this bill means for the United States and for everyone who might use this technology in the future.

Marc, let's hear your thoughts first. In January 2014, you published a column article in The New York Times titled "Why Bitcoin Matters." The environment then was completely different from now; it was a highly controversial viewpoint at the time. The so-called crypto industry then looked entirely different compared to today. What changes have occurred in the industry from then until now?

Marc: No problem. 2014 is very far away from now. The New York Times even published reports with a positive attitude towards the crypto industry back then, seeming like centuries ago. I am still proud of that article today; many points still hold true. That article was born five years into the start of this macro technology wave. At that time, believing that this technology had long-term value was itself a quite disruptive thing.

A large number of people needed to understand, accept, and participate, which still holds true today. Looking back, the only place in the article that needs adjustment is: everywhere it mentioned "Bitcoin," it can now be replaced with "cryptocurrency." The assumption back then was that Bitcoin would develop further, while also realizing applications like real-world asset tokenization and NFTs. Of course, this route did not land as expected. Subsequently, the market gave birth to multiple brand new blockchains and crypto platforms, and eventually Ethereum and a host of public chains emerged. A single initial technology gradually grew into a complete industry. Bitcoin itself has achieved huge success over these years, but what is more noteworthy is the comprehensive explosion of innovation across the entire sector.

Robert: I have to admit, many points in that article still hold up today. One prediction impressed me deeply: "In the coming years, there will be many magnificent stories surrounding this new technology." I have to say, you accurately predicted subsequent developments.

Chris, you have also witnessed the industry walk from its early stages to now. Compared to the startup phase, what changes have occurred today?

Chris: Early industry participants were mostly enthusiasts and fervent supporters, belonging to a niche subculture. At that time, the only mainstream technology was Bitcoin. As Marc mentioned, early emerging blockchains generally had a series of problems such as performance and scaling. Fast forward to today, almost every day we see large banks and fintech companies announcing platforms built on stablecoins, tokenized stocks, and various digital assets.

Simply explain stablecoins: they are very similar to the Bitcoin concept Marc described back then; essentially, they are数字化 dollars on-chain. Today, the trading volume of stablecoins can already rival the Visa network, with quarterly trading volumes reaching trillions of dollars. With stablecoins, you can open WhatsApp and transfer money to any region globally at almost zero cost, with an user experience like sending a text message. This is what capital circulation should look like. Marc, as an internet pioneer, you should deeply understand this: early internet pioneers originally expected such scenarios to arrive sooner. Constrained by multiple factors, the vision was delayed, but now, the dream of capital flowing as freely as information bits has finally become reality. The entire industry is moving towards maturity, and underlying infrastructure technology has also improved significantly. Just three years ago, completing a transfer like this might require several dollars or even tens of dollars in fees. Today, on mainstream public chains like Solana and Ethereum, transaction confirmation takes less than a second, and transfer costs are less than one cent.

Why the Crypto Industry Urgently Needs Regulatory Rules

Robert: You just mentioned that stablecoin trading volume has rivaled the Visa network, with trillions of dollars of capital circulating in this system. BlackRock, JPMorgan Chase, Visa, Fidelity, Mastercard, and a host of large financial institutions have entered the game. The list can continue; major institutions are laying out businesses based on this technology. But as the industry has developed to today, it has long lacked a clear regulatory framework and policy guidance. Why do we urgently need to establish regulatory rules now?

Chris: Multiple reasons have led to the crypto regulatory agenda being split into two major blocks: stablecoins, and the rest of the digital asset market. Last year, the "GENIUS Act" was deliberated and passed by Congress and signed into law by the President, building a complete regulatory framework for stablecoins. Coincidentally, stablecoins are also the sector that has developed the fastest in the past year. With clear regulatory boundaries, builders can have stable expectations.

For ordinary American consumers, if you use USDC or other stablecoins compliant with the "GENIUS Act," you can be sure that behind every stablecoin, there is one dollar of reserves deposited in a bank. This brings confidence and asset protection to consumers. If you are an institution, banks, Stripe, PayPal, and similar enterprises wanting to enter the market inevitably need predictable rules and a sound regulatory framework to ensure that the business built today is not only compliant next year but can continue to operate for the next ten years. Market participants need certainty.

And a major unresolved problem right now is that stablecoins operate on blockchain networks, but the blockchain sector itself, as well as the rest of the digital asset field, still does not have a complete set of federal regulatory regulations. This is exactly why the Senate deliberating the "CLARITY Act" is so significant. We can make an analogy: it's like we issued mobile phone regulatory regulations, but there are no relevant rules for communication base stations. Half of the technology sector has a regulatory system, while the other half remains in uncertainty. Even in a vague environment, entrepreneurs continue to build, trying their best to explore compliance boundaries. There are two paths for policy making. Regulatory agencies such as the SEC and CFTC have already issued some guidelines. But as you cited the history of internet development at the beginning, the long-term development of a mature industry relies on formal legislation. Therefore, we believe legislation is imperative, which is also the reason why the "CLARITY Act" is so critical.

Robert: Currently, it is not completely without rules. As you said, stablecoins have relevant bill regulations, but this only covers a small part of the market; the vast sector remains in a regulatory vacuum. Marc, why does the entire crypto sector need to establish regulatory regulations, and why can the timing not be delayed any longer?

Marc: The U.S. financial system has experienced similar journeys multiple times. The most classic case is the "Securities Act," which spawned the SEC and established a stock market regulatory system. We do not奢望 policy subsidies, trade protection, or special support. We simply hope to have a long-term stable regulatory framework so that market participants can conduct business compliantly. In many respects, this is a reasonable demand.

Chris: For example, currently there is no federal regulatory body for crypto exchanges in the United States. The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are all under the federal regulatory framework. A large part of the "CLARITY Act" is to fill this gap, granting regulatory authority to the SEC and CFTC, building information disclosure systems, anti-fraud rules, and insider trading regulatory regulations, establishing a regulatory system consistent with other traditional financial markets, which is the mature market rule Marc just mentioned. The FTX incident is the best evidence; back then, this exchange lacked standardized audit regulation, ultimately leading to a crisis. Once crypto exchanges complete federal registration, they need to accept standardized audits. The bill grants federal regulatory agencies complete law enforcement authority. Any platform that cannot meet compliance requirements is not allowed to conduct business in the United States. The bill details are complex; this legislation persisted in bipartisan collaboration throughout. Over the past seven years, many of us have continued to promote the landing of the "CLARITY Act"; it has been over a year since the House of Representatives passed the bill text, and the Senate has continued deliberating and adjusting for a whole year. There is precedent for bringing the financial industry under regulation; the bill transplants general regulatory principles of mature industries to the crypto sector. The bill clearly defines applicable subjects; crypto intermediaries need to comply with anti-money laundering and Treasury Department regulatory regulations consistent with traditional financial institutions. The Major Cities Chiefs Association, the largest law enforcement agency in the country, recently publicly expressed support for the "CLARITY Act." Some opponents claim the bill lacks perfect law enforcement supporting clauses, but this is not the case.

Gray Regulatory Zones Tolerate Illegal Financial Activities

Robert: Let's talk about the core issue currently debated by all parties; illegal financial activities are one of the focal points of discussion.

Chris: The applicable boundaries of current laws and regulations are extremely vague. Based on long-term observation, when regulation exists in a gray zone, the industry is极易 fall into a "race to the bottom."

I served as a Coinbase director for a long time, and Marc is still a Coinbase director. Coinbase is a local enterprise that highly values regulatory compliance. But compliance requires huge cost inputs and slows down product iteration speed. Every year, emerging trading platforms emerge overseas; they save large compliance costs and seize the market by relying on lower fees and faster product updates. Regulatory vagueness ultimately benefits speculators and illegal practitioners. Perfect regulation (the "CLARITY Act" is moving in this direction) can clearly define the regulatory scope.

For example, according to the "CLARITY Act," if you belong to a financial intermediary, similar to Coinbase, or any enterprise custoding user funds, you must comply with regulatory regulations completely identical to enterprises like Stripe and PayPal. The bill text makes clear definitions on this. As I said, multiple law enforcement agencies also publicly support the bill.

Will the "CLARITY Act" Abet Sanctions Evasion? Privacy Does Not Equal Anonymity

Robert: Marc, there is a critical voice believing that this bill will help market participants evade sanctions; how do you view this?

Marc: Most practitioners in the national security field I contact do not agree with this viewpoint. On-chain transactions retain complete trails, which forms a sharp contrast with many current terrorist financing models. Including within the industry, some people claim that cryptocurrency is naturally anonymous and transactions cannot be traced. This viewpoint essentially stems from a lack of understanding of technology.

Chris: Quite the opposite; today many teams invest large R&D resources into creating blockchains with privacy functions, precisely because most public chain transactions are fully public and searchable. We believe privacy functions have reasonable value, but absolutely not for illegal deeds. Imagine if you need to pay for medical or financial related services; you definitely don't want everyone to see this transaction. The traditional financial system also has privacy needs; this is a very reasonable demand.

With the landing of the "GENIUS Act" and the popularization of dollar stablecoins, the Washington policy circle has begun discussing privacy issues. We agree with this. This scene reminds one of the early days of internet development. Marc, didn't your team launch the SSL protocol back then?

Marc: That's correct.

Chris: For those unfamiliar with history, let's briefly popularize this: HTTPS technology was born from Netscape. At that time, many people raised questions, why do ordinary people need encrypted transmission of information? Admittedly, some criminals might utilize encryption technology, but after a long time everyone realized encryption technology is indispensable. 99.9% of usage scenarios are legitimate needs; ordinary people logging into online banks and other daily scenarios all use encryption.

Back then your team also went to Congress to participate in hearings.

Marc: That tug-of-war lasted four years, highly similar to the current situation. When we launched the Netscape browser, it was the first consumer-grade software widely popularized equipped with a public key encryption system. In that era, encryption technology was classified as munitions according to the "International Traffic in Arms Regulations" (ITAR). That is to say, the control standard for encryption technology was the same level as Tomahawk missiles, and the Netscape browser was also categorized into the same control category.

Therefore we could only sell versions equipped with high-strength encryption functions within the United States; versions sold overseas had to deliberately weaken encryption capabilities. It is conceivable that overseas consumers were very dissatisfied with this. Product packaging explicitly marked "Weaker encryption strength, do not trust," and overseas sales naturally suffered heavy blows.

Overseas competitors quickly seized the opportunity, imitating browsers and equipping them with complete encryption solutions. Overseas users abandoned our products and turned to overseas competitors. Back then, our group of young people went to Washington to lobby, attempting to clearly explain viewpoints, but officials' reactions were often full of confusion.

The debate ultimately fell to the core contradiction: Will encryption technology be abused by bad people? Or, is encryption technology a foundational tool for building trust and supporting legitimate commercial activities, serving law-abiding citizens? The essence of the problem is a trade-off: Do we want to completely eliminate cybercrime risks, or do we want online commercial platforms like Amazon to operate normally? The two things are deeply bound. Lengthy popularization communication lasted four years, and related control rules eventually welcomed adjustments. Facts proved the world did not descend into chaos because of this. First, as Chris said, the vast majority of encryption technology application scenarios are legitimate; more importantly, U.S. enterprises firmly grasped industry leadership because of this. Not just Netscape; the global internet economy has been led by U.S. enterprises for a long time.

Public Official Ethics Standards Should Be Discussed Separately from Market Regulation

Robert: Let's continue talking about other doubts facing the bill. Another major controversy is the issue of public official ethics. There is a viewpoint pointing out that the President and his family hold equity in crypto-related enterprises, and the bill landing will allow bill supporters to profit from it. How do you respond to such doubts?

Chris: This is not my area of expertise, but as an ordinary citizen, I believe public officials should abide by ethical guidelines. But related rules should not only target the crypto industry. Stock trading and other financial asset fields should also establish public official ethical norms; this is a reasonable demand. Second, even putting aside special ethical clauses, the "CLARITY Act" will still add a large number of constraints on crypto market participants: crypto asset risk, mandatory disclosure requirements for holding information, adding lock-up rules. All market participants, including public officials, will face stricter regulation.

Third, from a political perspective, the current status quo is helpless. Under normal circumstances, public official ethical regulations and industry regulatory bills would advance separately. The crypto industry is being applied with a different set of evaluation standards. Even so, the whole society and policymakers can completely rationally discuss public official ethical rules applicable to all financial assets (including cryptocurrency). I hope all parties can reach a consensus and promote the bill landing. Our core goal is to complete crypto industry regulatory legislation.

Marc: By the way, the constraint standards set by the bill for public officials using crypto assets are stricter than stock trading related rules.

Chris: I will add one point; the public's current cognition of cryptocurrency is mostly limited to trading speculation. Many people ignore that relying on applications like stablecoins, crypto technology is transforming into a daily use tool. If the industry continues to develop, related applications will further penetrate ordinary people's financial lives. When making regulatory rules, it is necessary to distinguish two types of scenarios: one is asset speculative trading, and the other is daily technology use. Public officials should have the opportunity to use frontier technology.

Robert: That is to say, the bill already contains public official ethics related clauses, and at the same time, the ethical norms issue and building the crypto market regulatory framework itself should be viewed separately.

Chris: Objectively viewing the current political situation, the current bill draft has already added ethics related clauses. Related content is still in the negotiation stage. I expect all parties to reach a consensus. From our perspective, the most important goal is to end the regulatory gray zone that has persisted for many years — this gray zone continues to spawn industry race to the bottom. The "CLARITY Act" certainly cannot be perfect, but it is far better than maintaining the status quo.

Stablecoin Interest Controversy: The Game Between Banks and the Crypto Industry

Robert: Let's talk about stablecoins again. The stablecoin regulatory plan in the bill is fiercely controversial, and banking lobbying groups have huge opposition voices, with JPMorgan Chase's statement being particularly prominent. Banks oppose stablecoin balances being able to generate interest; they worry that if consumers can obtain interest income from stablecoins, they will withdraw deposits from commercial banks, triggering deposit outflows.

Chris: The final text of the bill basically adopted banking demands, prohibiting stablecoin balances from directly accruing interest. The bill text defines: any product equivalent to bank deposits in function and economic attributes is not allowed to pay interest. Of course, the rules leave some space. Assuming a user completes several transactions using a stablecoin wallet at Walmart every month, a consumption reward mechanism can be set; as long as it does not belong to the balance interest payment mode, it complies with regulations.

Robert: Similar to credit card points, consumption reward mechanisms.

Chris: Correct. If the rules tighten one step further, consumption reward systems like Starbucks points would be impacted. All parties went through a long game to form this compromise plan. For the crypto industry, this compromise was not easy, but we still fully support the entire bill.

Robert: The public confrontation between Brian Armstrong and Jamie Dimon perfectly embodies this game. But JPMorgan Chase internally has a huge blockchain team and has already launched on-chain tokenized deposit business.

Chris: JPMorgan Chase is huge. Many large banks are laying out blockchain. Once the "CLARITY Act" passes, a large number of bank blockchain projects will land on a large scale. Enterprise exploration of new technology is no longer limited to small-scale experiments. We have long communicated with numerous institutions. Many plans have already entered the trial operation stage; after regulatory certainty lands, they will fully roll out. Institutions generally see huge opportunities.

The existing banking system formation has complex historical causes; it cannot be simply blamed on banks. The whole system is intricate; a large amount of underlying technology is already old. Blockchain happens to provide a unified innovation framework for the financial industry: various institutions can rely on blockchain to jointly promote financial infrastructure into the 21st century. Blockchain not only solves technical problems but also resolves multi-party collaboration obstacles.

When communicating with institutions, one can obviously feel that the banking industry generally favors the sector's prospects; JPMorgan Chase is no exception. I am not the only one making this judgment: Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon publicly expressed support for the "CLARITY Act"; Fidelity, BlackRock, and a host of large financial institutions also publicly support it and are all laying out related business. Head fintech enterprises like Stripe are also deeply involved. As long as supporting regulation lands, this technology will soon be fully popularized.

Open Source Developer Liability: Excessive Accountability Will Severely Damage the Industry

Robert: Let's switch to another core controversy, the issue of software developer responsibility definition. Former White House Cybersecurity Official Carole House raised concerns, advocating that software developers need to bear more legal liability for the code they write. She believes that if no accountability mechanism is set, it will create a dangerous precedent for other technology fields like artificial intelligence. Marc, you have long studied the artificial intelligence sector; how do you view this viewpoint?

Marc: This line of thinking is equivalent to directly sentencing the industry to death. Software developers simply cannot predict how code will be used in the future. Let's step out of the software industry for an example: If a criminal checks into a hotel and uses the hotel to plan a crime, does the hotel operator need to bear conspiracy liability? If an automotive engineer designs a vehicle, and the vehicle is used for robbery, is the engineer an accessory to robbery? If product developers need to bear joint liability for all subsequent user behaviors, the entire sector will completely perish.

Chris: I will add one point: If you develop software and actively induce others to utilize code to commit crimes, this is itself illegal behavior; there is no controversy on this point. The situation we are discussing is completely different: developers develop open source software with positive purposes, creating AI models, building blockchain underlying networks, and open sourcing sharing. Once the law requires open source developers to bear unlimited civil and criminal joint liability, no one will be willing to continue developing open source projects. Open source teams are mostly not capital-rich large enterprises; it is hard to bear huge litigation risks. Garage startup small teams cannot bear unlimited liability. Policy will strangle startups and destroy the open source ecosystem.

Marc: The same contradiction also appears in artificial intelligence regulatory discussions. The day strict accountability rules land is the day open source technology perishes. Open source developers mostly have no revenue sources and are unable to bear huge legal risks. The open source ecosystem collapses, and academic research will also stagnate accordingly. Computer related field research highly relies on the open source system. This will subsequently severely damage the entire computer science field. Risks will continue to传导; risks are high enough to be immeasurable; venture capital firms will no longer invest in related startup companies. Startups and large technology enterprises will all be impacted.

The Actual Impact of the "CLARITY Act" on Securities Law

Robert: The last high-frequency doubt is that some people believe the bill will break through the existing securities law framework. Marc, you just mentioned that over the past 90 years, securities law has supported the booming development of the U.S. capital market. Critics' viewpoint: After the bill lands, enterprises can directly tokenize assets on-chain, thereby evading SEC regulation and securities law constraints. How do you respond?

Chris: The bill text is written very clearly; after stock tokenization, it still belongs to the securities category, accepting SEC securities law regulation, with no exemption space. The only place making a distinction is: the "CLARITY Act" clearly defines that blockchain native tokens like Bitcoin and Ethereum, according to different development stages, are regulated by the SEC or CFTC respectively.

Let's sort out the logic: Bitcoin was born initially, initiated by Satoshi Nakamoto. Any new project starting stage naturally possesses centralized characteristics; the founding team holds control power and possesses non-public information. According to bill rules, new project tokens in the initial stage fall under SEC regulation. New projects need to comply with lock-up rules, mandatory information disclosure, and a full set of securities regulatory requirements. As the project develops, when the degree of decentralization reaches designated standards, evolving into networks like today's Bitcoin and Ethereum where there is no single control subject and no internal information manipulation conditions, the regulatory body switches to the CFTC, implementing regulation according to commodities. The regulatory framework dynamically adjusts with asset attributes. Even entering the commodities regulatory system, related rules will still prevent various illegal behaviors like market dumping and cornering.

Robert: Similar to gold, precious metals, crude oil, wheat, and other commodities.

Chris: Exactly so. The previous administration also stated: Bitcoin and Ethereum decentralization degrees are high enough; they can be regulated according to commodities. Over the past ten years, bipartisan government regulatory agencies and multiple judicial cases have defaulted to this logic.

The "CLARITY Act" just writes long-formed industry consensus into law, clearly defining standards; market participants do not need to confirm regulatory attribution through lengthy litigation again. Currently, anyone issuing new tokens has no unified disclosure rules, lacking insider trading regulation and founder lock-up mechanisms. After the bill lands, risk isolation standards are formally established. Before the project reaches decentralization standards, founding team and venture capital institution tokens strictly execute lock-up rules; this is the reasonable regulatory mode. This regulatory framework built based on risk levels is very perfect. Consumers, investors, and all market participants can build trust and develop business relying on clear rules. A long-term sustainable industry cannot leave without standardized regulation.

If the "CLARITY Act" Deliberation Fails

Robert: We have sorted out all core game issues currently; any single divergence could cause the bill to stall. If the "CLARITY Act" ultimately fails to pass, what consequences will occur?

Chris: We will still continue to promote related legislation. Regulatory agencies like the SEC, CFTC, Treasury Department, etc., can issue some regulatory details within administrative authority. But regulatory rules formulated by administrative agencies have weaker stability than Congressional legislation.

Long-term stable regulations on one hand continue to protect consumer rights, and on the other hand give the industry certainty. Building products often requires consuming several years of time. If regulatory policy continues to sway, entrepreneurs are hard-pressed to make up their minds to invest large amounts of time and capital for long-term layout. Entrepreneurs already have to cope with countless difficulties; a continuously changing regulatory environment will only increase uncertainty. This is the biggest disadvantage of bill failure: continuously extending the industry regulatory vague period. But I am still optimistic; the bill is expected to pass in the near future; if blocked, we will not stop the steps of promoting legislation.

Maintaining America's Global Technology Leadership

Robert: Raise the perspective; let's talk about the significance of the bill for the United States and U.S. technology's global leadership. Why does promoting the "CLARITY Act" landing concern national interests?

Marc: This legislation continues the tradition of the United States leading global technological innovation for a long time; it concerns U.S. technology dominance. There are only two core questions: Do we hope our country continues to lead global technological innovation? First question: After new technology is born, do we choose to embrace it, or choose to deny the technology's value; Second: Once a technology is born, development trends are hard to reverse. Do we hope industry landing occurs in the United States本土, or hand it over to other countries?

We have always firmly believed: Regardless of holding what political stance, all American citizens should support the United States maintaining global technology leadership. Advantages can be converted into tangible economic dividends, raising national wealth levels, supporting various public expenditures. Technology leadership also profoundly affects national security. The crypto industry taking root in the United States is overall more beneficial than harmful for U.S. law enforcement and national security levels. We are already accustomed to the United States leading global technology for a long time, to the extent that explaining this viewpoint even seems redundant; the logic is very obvious. Over the past one hundred years, the United States fully enjoyed the dividends brought by technology leadership. In my opinion, we should work hard to guard advantages and continue to lead for another hundred years.

Robert: Whether policymakers will accept these viewpoints and realize the urgency of time, whoever establishes standards first can harvest long-term dividends; the answer awaits time verification.

Thank you both.