
Someone Attempts to Claim 3.8 Million Dormant Bitcoins Using "Lost and Found", CLARITY Act Steps In to Plug Loopholes
Author: CryptoSlate
Compiled by: TechFlow
TechFlow Editor's Note: A person named Noah Doe is using New York State "police lost and found" laws to attempt to claim 3.8 million Bitcoins that have never been moved (worth about $200 billion, accounting for 18% of the total Bitcoin supply)—on the grounds that "the wallet has been dormant for years and unclaimed." The U.S. Congress urgently added a clause to the CLARITY Act: as long as you control the private keys yourself, an inactive wallet does not equal abandonment of ownership. This lawsuit is testing a terrifying legal loophole: if you keep your cold wallet for too long, could someone else take it using "lost property laws"?
Section 20216 of the latest draft of the CLARITY Act stipulates: self-custodied digital assets will not become abandoned property, unclaimed property, or confiscated property, nor will ownership or finder's rights be acquired by others due to the wallet being inactive for a long time or the holder not showing continued interest.
This provision overturns state and local laws that use "wallet inactivity for years" as a reason to transfer ownership.
The Senate drafts of May 8 and May 20 only protected the right to hold self-custodied wallets, while the July 22 version expanded the scope into the field of property law, covering whether the holder still owns the coins inside after the wallet has been dormant for years.
This clause defines self-custodied digital assets as: assets where the owner exclusively controls the private keys, without relying on custodians, exchanges, or intermediaries.
This definition draws the line upon which the remaining clauses rely.
From Wallet Access Rights to Property Ownership
Courts must draw a line between two types of digital assets: coins directly controlled by an individual through private keys, and coins held at exchanges, brokers, or custodians. The federal protection of the new CLARITY Act draft applies to the first category.
State unclaimed property rules continue to govern the second category, as the draft explicitly retains these rules for custodied assets. Recent state amendments have treated exchanges, custodians, and custodial wallet providers as a unique category of assets that may belong to missing owners.
A wallet holding its own private keys and an exchange account holding Bitcoin of equivalent USD value will fall on opposite sides of this line.
In the case of an exchange, the custodian controls the private keys, so the state dormancy, reporting, and delivery rules of that custodian continue to apply as usual.
The Case Making This Provision Urgent
New York State's own lost property laws show why this provision now has real bite. Section 7-B of the state's "Personal Property Law" covers property lost by someone and later turned over to the police.
Section 257 allows ownership to be vested in the finder under specific conditions, including for property under $10, after a year of failed search for the owner.
Noah Doe and two companies are using this framework to claim ownership of 39,069 dormant Bitcoin addresses, which hold approximately 3.799 million BTC, close to 18% of the total Bitcoin supply. Their documents point to OP_RETURN notification activities, press releases, and claim windows as evidence that these coins count as unclaimed lost property.
This theory heavily relies on the wallet's silence, the coins remaining unmoved for years, and no owner coming forward to contest the claim, and Section 20216 targets precisely this mechanism. Claimants can no longer use years of inactivity or lack of communication as a basis for acquiring ownership under state abandoned property laws.
The plaintiffs in Noah Doe also cited police reports, OP_RETURN notifications, and their attempts to contact potential owners. This evidence goes beyond pure dormancy, and even if CLARITY becomes law, may allow them to argue their claim is not based solely on silence.
This clause closes the legal loophole their case is testing, but will not conclude the litigation itself, as courts must still weigh whether this additional evidence changes the analysis.
What Happens Next to This Provision
In an optimistic scenario, Section 20216 survives Senate negotiations, its preemption language remains intact, and courts interpret the phrase "solely due to inactivity" narrowly enough to give self-custody real protection.
Theories based on dormancy like those behind Noah Doe become harder to construct, as claimants need evidence beyond years of silence to make progress. Holding one's own private keys gains legal support that self-custody advocates never truly had before.
In a pessimistic scenario, Senate negotiators strip or soften Section 20216 before the final vote, and the surviving language leaves room for courts to weigh inactivity along with other factors when deciding claims.
Experiments with state laws regarding dormant wallets remain possible, and future claimants can still construct theories similar to Noah Doe's around long silence plus notification activities.
Self-custody retains its protection as an activity; holding one's own private keys remains legal, but ownership during years of inactivity remains an unresolved issue that courts must resolve on a case-by-case basis.
Section 20216 removes the simplest argument claimants can make against silent Bitcoin addresses: that nothing happening for years equals abandonment itself. Whether this is sufficient depends on what survives Senate negotiations and what judges ultimately decide silence itself can prove.















