
During Bitcoin's sideways consolidation, which DeFi tokens have shown independent price action?
Written by: The DeFi Edge
Translated by: Luffy, Foresight News
Bitcoin has been trading sideways for two months, but many DeFi tokens have not simply ridden along with the broader market.
After surging 21% in August, Bitcoin entered a range-bound consolidation. Since August 22, its daily closing price has consistently oscillated between $75,600 and $86,600. During this period, Bitcoin gained only 5.6% in aggregate, while Ethereum fell by 2.7%.
Among the 19 top DeFi tokens that distribute revenue to holders, which we tracked, 14 outperformed Bitcoin. Raydium surged by 178%. The median gain for this batch of tokens reached 12.9%, more than double Bitcoin's increase.

Why Focus on "Actual Revenue Distributed to Holders"?
Looking solely at total protocol revenue can be misleading. Some protocols generate substantial profits but distribute none to token holders, with earnings ultimately retained by the team.
Therefore, this article tracks "actual revenue distributed to holders": including token buybacks and burns, fee burns, and direct payouts to address holders. This methodology is sourced from DeFiLlama.
To be included, tokens must meet the following criteria:
- Only core DeFi projects are included: DEXs, perpetual swaps, lending, vaults, liquid staking, yield tools, and yield aggregators. Public chains, oracles, and Launchpads are excluded (including Pons, etc.).
- The market cap exceeded $100 million as of August 22.
- A record of distributing revenue to holders over the past year.
Any project meeting the screening criteria is included in the statistics. For example, funds generated from Raydium's Launchpad business used for token buybacks, and Hyperliquid's direct fee burns, both qualify as actual revenue distributed to holding users.
The tracking period is from August 22 to October 20, compared against prior 59-day data. Price sources are CoinGecko, resulting in a final selection of 19 tokens.

The "Market Cap / Holder Annual Yield" in the table refers to the total market cap divided by the total annual revenue distributed to holders at current payout levels. A lower value indicates that investors pay a lower cost per dollar of dividend received.
Which Tokens Performed Best?
Comparing tokens split into two groups: those with increasing dividend distributions saw a median token gain of 18.3%, while the other group posted only 6.9%.
The top three performing tokens all have clear logic behind their revenue growth:
- Raydium: On September 5, tokenized stock issuance platform StonkFun integrated with Raydium's LaunchLab. The buyback volume for RAY tokens skyrocketed from $360,000 in July to $3.94 million in September, an 11-fold increase.
- Uniswap: Its fee-sharing mechanism was already active. Coupled with massive transaction volume from the Robinhood Chain, nearly half of Uniswap's protocol revenue in September came from this chain.
- Aerodrome (AERO): Following the merger of Aerodrome and Velodrome, token holders receive trading fees plus payments from projects seeking to purchase liquidity. This revenue stream hit $14.9 million in September, surpassing the $10.5 million paid to liquidity providers.
Conversely, the same holds true for underperformers: edgeX saw its actual revenue distributed to holders drop by 15%, with its price plummeting 22%, making it the worst-performing project in the sample.
Does a low valuation automatically mean a good opportunity? The data this time tells a different story, yielding surprisingly counterintuitive results. AERO had the lowest valuation multiple at just 8.7x, yet its price surged 77%. edgeX traded at a 15x valuation (the second-lowest in the sample), but delivered the worst returns. Judging solely by valuation multiples makes it impossible to predict future token price movements.
Furthermore, some tokens defy these general patterns.
- Hyperliquid (HYPE): Revenue distributed to holders surged 79%, yet the token price rose only 6%. Valued at a staggering 85x on a fully diluted basis (FDV); approximately $800 million worth of HYPE unlocks monthly, while buybacks amount to merely $75 million per month, forcing the market to absorb significant selling pressure.
- Sky (SKY): Through a governance vote on August 13, 55% of each revenue cycle is allocated to token buybacks and 45% is distributed to staked users. Holder yields nearly quadrupled, but the token price increased only 11%.
- Aave (AAVE): Following the rsETH security incident, Aave paused token buybacks. It provided no dividends to users during the tracking period, yet its price still climbed 24%.
I believe market pricing considers both current dividend levels and future yield expectations. Dividend expectations alone do not dictate token prices.
How to Select DeFi Tokens if Bitcoin Enters Sideways Trading Again?
When researching projects, you must evaluate these three factors simultaneously; omitting any one is detrimental:
- The project's actual revenue share distributed to holders is trending upward.
- Tangible catalysts driving growth: such as new business lines, fee-sharing mechanisms boosting trading volumes, or protocol mergers.
- Closely monitor token unlock schedules and fully diluted valuations (FDV). Hyperliquid serves as a cautionary tale; once large volumes of tokens vest and flood the market, they will suppress price appreciation.
Additional Notes
- This analysis covers only a 19-token sample over a 59-day period; conclusions are not absolute. Adding another month of data could completely reshuffle the rankings of mid-tier tokens.
- Price and dividend revenue are tracked over the identical two-month interval. This methodology serves merely as an observational indicator and does not guarantee that applying these rules on August 22 would precisely pick out winning coins.
- Valuation multiples in this article are calculated using circulating market cap. Many projects have large locked token allocations, making valuations appear cheaper than they are in reality. Hyperliquid trades at a 19.6x multiple based on circulating market cap ($18.1 billion), but skyrockets to 85x when using FDV ($77.8 billion).
- Holder yield data is sourced from DeFiLlama. While not 100% accurate, it remains the highest-quality dataset available in the industry.
- Some projects distribute dividends in batches. For instance, Lido's buybacks require unified execution after DAO votes. A low-yield month does not necessarily indicate a halt in dividend distribution.
- Meteora was excluded from the two-group performance comparison as its dividend feature just launched, leaving insufficient historical data for analysis.
- THORChain's holder yields originate from fee burns of the RUNE token. The burn rate was reduced from 5% to 1% on September 12, meaning its price fluctuations are unrelated to dividend growth logic.
- Supplementary data for outlier samples. Hyperliquid distributed a total of $146.9 million to holders across these 59 days, accounting for 59% of the total sample revenue; the team unlocks approximately 9.9 million HYPE monthly. Sky's valuation multiple dropped from 98x to 28.5x.















