TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
How to understand the CFTC's regulation of prediction markets?

How to understand the CFTC's regulation of prediction markets?

2026.10.13
Share
The CFTC is redefining swap boundaries through targeted inclusions and exclusions, but the decisive factor hinges on whether the Supreme Court will hear the case.

By Huohuo, Rhythm

On October 9, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) released two documents with opposing directions on the same day. One proposal seeks to include event contracts such as sports, politics, culture, and weather from prediction markets within the definition of swaps, while another interim final rule explicitly excludes licensed sports betting and casino games from the swap category.

In plain terms, a swap is simply a contract where payments are determined by outcomes. Under U.S. derivatives law, once a certain type of contract is classified as a swap, it typically falls under unified oversight by the CFTC, outside the reach of state gambling licenses and state taxes—a scenario known as federal preemption.

Thus, the core of the dispute lies in who writes the rules for the same NFL game: bets placed at a Las Vegas counter or through the DraftKings app fall under state-regulated gambling; when structured as event contracts on a federally registered exchange like Kalshi, the CFTC claims they qualify as swaps.

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig is the only sitting member among the five commissioners. His stance is straightforward: Americans use event contracts to hedge, speculate, and gather information; these products belong to commodity derivatives under the exclusive jurisdiction of the CFTC. Casino-style products, however, are not derivatives.

Trading volume provides the backdrop for this latest move. According to self-reported figures from the CFTC, event contracts listed on U.S. designated contract markets (DCMs) reached approximately $1.5 billion in August, with sports accounting for roughly $1.2 billion. Market estimates are significantly higher, with Kalshi and Polymarket reporting combined trading of around $8.56 billion over a single weekend in October, driven primarily by surge activity in sports contracts.

Sports trading volume on DCMs far exceeds that of political and weather contracts

Inclusion and exclusion: The swap definition is being pulled in two directions

The proposal addresses what counts as a swap, while the interim final rule clarifies what does not. The latter draws boundaries using two tests: only wagers offered by licensed state or tribal gambling operators, and not matched on multi-lateral exchanges, are excluded. Both conditions must be met simultaneously for an operation to qualify under the casino exemption.

Combined, these two boundaries effectively split sports betting in half: one half remains under state jurisdiction, the other falls to the federal government. The exact same sports wager constitutes regulated gambling at a Las Vegas counter, but becomes a swap when placed on a federally registered exchange like Kalshi.

The same match faces two distinct regulatory regimes

Similar questions emerged in amicus briefs filed by the American Gaming Association: If sports wagers qualify as swaps, shouldn't bets placed at Las Vegas counters also be subject to DCM regulation?

T.D. Cowen policy analyst Jaret Seiberg offers another interpretation. State governments repeatedly argue in litigation that the CFTC's broad definition of swaps would inadvertently render state and tribal casino bets federally illegal.

The interim final rule's explicit removal of casino operations aims precisely to dismantle this line of attack in court. Seiberg judges that this move is primarily intended to improve the CFTC's legal positioning, though its ultimate success remains uncertain.

If this division fails to hold up in court, states could follow this casino thread to drag event contracts back under state law.

The NFL and 39 States: Who Should Set the Rules for the Same Game

A clear split has already formed within the judiciary. New Jersey has escalated its jurisdictional dispute with Kalshi to the Supreme Court, and the NFL, along with 39 states plus Washington, D.C., filed amicus briefs supporting New Jersey.

The NFL argues that sports event contracts represent gambling that creates new risks rather than hedging existing exposures, and points out that the CFTC has not prohibited manipulable markets, failed to cover injury and referee-related markets, nor enforced a 21-year age threshold. On the first Sunday of the season, prediction markets saw roughly $3.3 billion in trading volume, with $1.8 billion tied to football.

U.S. federal circuit courts are divided by region, meaning different circuits can issue conflicting rulings on identical legal questions. Only after a circuit split emerges does the Supreme Court become more likely to intervene. So far this year, three federal circuit courts have delivered contradictory conclusions:

Third Circuit (April this year): Held that sports contracts on DCMs qualify as swaps and can preempt state law.

Sixth Circuit (September) and Ninth Circuit (August): Reached opposite conclusions, ruling that these contracts do not constitute swaps and that state law may apply.

All three circuits issued completely contradictory classifications for swaps

With each of the three circuits taking a firm stand, the exact same contract could receive diametrically opposite classifications across different jurisdictions—the precise reason New Jersey is seeking Supreme Court review. Kalshi's response deadline falls on November 9, and the Supreme Court has yet to decide whether to grant certiorari.

Rules Not Yet Effective, Key Variables Lie in Courts and Commissioner Seats

To date, neither document has been published in the Federal Register. The comment period for the proposal begins 30 days after publication, and the interim final rule similarly requires publication before taking effect. Labeling them as "already open for comment" or "already in force" would both be inaccurate.

The more critical variable rests with the courts. New Jersey's petition places the split between the Third Circuit and the Sixth and Ninth Circuits before the nine justices, with no update on whether certiorari will be granted. Administrative rules can bolster arguments referencing the Third Circuit's framework, but the ultimate authority to interpret the text rests with the judges.

Selig is the sole sitting commissioner among the five seats. Pushing forward with rules during a vacancy holds legal ground, but checks and balances remain remarkably thin. Once vacancies are filled, or if the courts reject this definitional framework, today's protective measures could easily be overturned.

In this round of contention, the heavily regulated protagonists remain notably quiet, with both Kalshi and Polymarket refraining from issuing public, on-the-record statements to date.