
Predictions of market regulation sparked a political tug-of-war.
By David Yaffe-Bellany and Sharon LaFraniere, The New York Times
Translated by Chopper, Foresight News
In early March, Donald Trump Jr. addressed a group of Republican state attorneys general at The Ritz-Carlton in New Orleans, where they were gathered for a three-day closed-door meeting.
As the president’s eldest son, Donald Trump Jr. has repeatedly pledged to separate his family’s business interests from government work. But during this closed-door event, he intervened in a heated legal battle over which entities should regulate prediction markets: states or federal agencies. It is a booming new industry, and the Trump family has financial stakes in it.
According to four people familiar with his remarks, while engaging in a question-and-answer session on stage with the Montana attorney general, Donald Trump Jr. hinted that state leaders were being misled by “entrenched interests,” namely gambling companies hoping to protect their “monopoly” by attacking prediction markets. He stated that these markets are, in fact, already heavily regulated, describing them as complex financial instruments overseen by federal officials rather than state attorneys general.
Sources say Donald Trump Jr.’s tone was friendly. Yet these previously unreported remarks align with the message his father’s administration has sent to state leaders: stay out of it.
Across the country, red and blue states have united in lawsuits against prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket, setting the stage for a courtroom showdown whose outcome will determine whether Americans can use these platforms to bet on sports, politics, and virtually every other event.
A total of 20 states are embroiled in litigation over whether prediction markets fall under state sports betting laws. Last month, 44 states signed a joint letter condemning these platforms as a “new kind of casino” that is prey on young people.
State officials argue that these markets are evading oversight and failing to pay state taxes. According to the nonpartisan research group Tax Foundation, the resulting loss in tax revenue is at least $2 billion annually.

The lawsuits have sparked an unusual political dynamic pitting the federal government against the states. President Trump has declared that he wants prediction markets to “thrive” under his leadership, free from state regulation. His administration is fighting alongside Kalshi in court, arguing that the industry’s sole regulator is the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)—a small agency responsible for overseeing commodity markets such as those for oil and agricultural products.
The CFTC stated that in its half-century since its establishment in 1974, it had never sued a state over regulatory issues. This year, however, it has sued nine states, all led by Democratic governors. The agency also twice instructed prediction markets to ignore court orders, deploying emergency powers it had not used in decades.
This aggressive intervention aligns the agency with the Trump family’s financial interests. In January last year, Kalshi hired Donald Trump Jr. as a consultant; his compensation included over $300,000 worth of Kalshi stock, the value of which has since multiplied several times over. Last year, the president’s son also became a consultant for Polymarket and acquired a stake in the company through his investment firm, 1789 Capital.
A spokesperson for Donald Trump Jr. stated that he “does not engage with the federal government on behalf of any company he invests in or advises.” A female spokesperson for Kalshi said that Donald Trump Jr. provides marketing advice to the company.
The legal battle has also drawn in a powerful coalition of traditional gambling operators, which view prediction markets as competitive threats and have pressured states to take action. An industry organization representing casino operators is working with former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, who has publicly condemned prediction markets.
“The amount of money at stake is enormous,” said Rob Schwartz, who served as general counsel for the CFTC until last year and has tracked the 17-month wave of litigation. “This will definitely end up at the Supreme Court. It’s only a matter of time.”
At the core of the litigation is a debate over what constitutes gambling.

During the July World Cup, Kalshi ran an advertisement in Times Square
For years, Kalshi and other prediction markets have registered with the CFTC and classified bets on their platforms as “event contracts”—financial instruments that derive value from the outcomes of real-world events. These contracts are typically binary, based on yes-or-no scenarios like whether it will rain on a given day. The companies argue that because these instruments are regulated at the federal level, prediction markets should be free to operate nationwide.
As the largest prediction market in the United States, Kalshi has faced the most legal pressure; most bets on Polymarket occur outside the U.S., although it now also operates a smaller U.S.-based app.
In a statement, Kalshi said it offers consumer safeguards and that its business model gives people a legitimate chance to win money. The company boasts “a national regulatory framework rather than a patchwork of competing state rules,” adding that “states attempting to shut down a federally licensed exchange is too aggressive.”
But state officials argue that Kalshi’s position does not hold up. Attorneys general contend that the products offered by the company are nearly indistinguishable from sports betting without the protective measures required by the states. All but a handful of states mandate that residents under 21 cannot engage in sports betting, yet Kalshi’s app is open to anyone 18 and older.
“You log into a website and place a bet on the outcome of a sporting event,” said Nick Brown, the Democratic attorney general of Washington. Earlier this month, he won an initial court victory in a lawsuit against Kalshi. “That is gambling.”
“Winking and Nodding”

Kalshi co-founder Tarek Mansour believes the services his company offers are fundamentally different from traditional gambling
On the morning of this year’s Super Bowl, Utah Attorney General Derek Brown received a push notification for a Kalshi ad intended for his college-aged son. The ad invited him to “legally trade on football outcomes.”
Brown was alarmed. In his view, Kalshi is using clever wording to circumvent Utah regulations, where the state constitution bans gambling. “It’s winking and nodding,” he said.
Over the next two weeks, Brown and the governor of Utah—both Republicans—publicly condemned prediction markets, calling them “almost dystopian.” Brown received a text message from a Kalshi lobbyist requesting a meeting, but he ignored it.
In late February, Kalshi sued the state of Utah in federal court, alleging the state “intends to prohibit Kalshi from operating.” This marks one front in a nationwide legal battle involving Kalshi and several of its top competitors, including Polymarket and the crypto trading platform Crypto.com.
Following the U.S. Supreme Court’s overturning of the ban on sports betting in 2018, most states legalized the industry and began taxing it. According to the Tax Foundation, licensed operations generated over $3 billion in tax revenue in the last fiscal year.
Prediction markets took a different path. In 2024, Kalshi won a court ruling allowing it to offer election bets, paving the way for these markets to operate under a CFTC license. This year, Kalshi and Polymarket have become cultural phenomena, attracting tens of billions of dollars in bets monthly. A flood of new entrants has brought the number of registered prediction markets to 13.
Public attention on these markets has largely focused on their novel offerings, such as bets on celebrity drug use or Israeli missile strikes. However, according to data provider The Block, roughly 75% of activity on Kalshi this year stems from sports. Kalshi has also partnered with The Athletic, a sports media website owned by The New York Times Company.
Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour argues that the products his company offers are fundamentally different from traditional gambling. Kalshi does not act as a “house” betting against every wager. Instead, it matches buyers and sellers and generates revenue by charging fees.
“We are regulated exactly like the New York Stock Exchange or Nasdaq,” Mansour said in an interview in January.
Nevertheless, some of Kalshi’s own marketing campaigns undermine this stance. A social media ad cited in state litigation encouraged customers to “bet on the NFL.” Kalshi stated it no longer uses that ad.
Unsurprisingly, the rise of Kalshi and Polymarket has angered gambling companies that pay state taxes and hold state licenses. Some, like DraftKings and FanDuel, quickly launched their own prediction markets. Others fought back, spearheaded by the American Gaming Association, which represents casino operators and other gambling companies.
Kalshi is a “backdoor sports betting operation” flouting state law, said association spokesperson Rob Lockwood in a statement.
Emails obtained by The New York Times show that in December last year, the association’s executive Tres York dined with Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman at Joe『s Seafood restaurant in Washington. Afterwards, York pitched Coleman’s office on the necessity of pushing back against prediction markets and pointed out that a coalition of states was preparing a legal brief.
“I would be happy to connect you with the deputy attorney general in Nevada, who is spearheading efforts to recruit allies to defend states’ rights,” York wrote in an email to one of Coleman’s deputies.
Kentucky did not sign the brief, but Coleman ultimately sued Kalshi and Polymarket in state court. “These multi-billion-dollar companies and their compliance fall apart under scrutiny,” he said in a statement.
Federal Agency Steps In

Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chairman Michael S. Selig has sued nine states opposed to prediction markets
Soon, another party joined the fray.
In December 2025, President Trump’s nominee for CFTC chairman, Michael S. Selig, was sworn in. At 36, Selig is a tech enthusiast who previously worked as corporate counsel for prediction markets and cryptocurrency firms.
After taking charge of the CFTC, Selig filed lawsuits against Kentucky, Illinois, and seven other states hostile to prediction markets. “This is a make-or-break issue for this agency,” he said in an interview. “If states try to undermine our regulations, that is a problem for us.”
In fact, the agency has treated the issue as an emergency in certain states, deeming it necessary to deploy its extraordinary powers.
Selig’s response to an obscure state court ruling in Michigan underscores how far this administration will go to protect the interests of the prediction market industry. In July, a state judge ordered Kalshi to block bets from Michigan residents because the company lacked the proper licensing.
The agency invoked rarely used emergency powers, instructing Kalshi to disregard the court order even though the company had begun cancelling the bets. In filings, the CFTC claimed that Michigan’s order “could undermine public confidence in prediction markets.”
The CFTC last used this power in 1980, when President Carter banned grain sales to the Soviet Union. The agency halted grain futures trading to quell panic in the commodities market.
“This is truly unprecedented and frankly outrageous,” said Aitan Goelman, who directed enforcement at the CFTC during the Obama administration. “How can an inability to bet on sports online constitute a market emergency?”
Earlier this month, after a federal judge declined to block New York’s efforts to shut down Kalshi’s local operations, the agency launched a second emergency intervention. The CFTC instructed Kalshi to continue operating. Within days, the company cited this measure in a Connecticut case.
The federal judge presiding over the litigation remained unmoved. “The CFTC lacks the authority to issue an order conflicting with this court’s ruling,” he wrote.
When asked why the agency was trying to circumvent the judge, CFTC spokesperson Zach Fulton said it needed to “maintain the status quo while the courts are still deciding these issues.”
Like the growing coalition of blue states, Republican-led states including Ohio, Nevada, Montana, and Tennessee have also filed lawsuits or issued cease-and-desist orders forcing prediction markets to comply. However, despite the CFTC suing nine states led by Democratic governors, its strongest legal move against Republican-led states has been filing amicus curiae briefs. Judges are under no obligation to read these arguments.
Fulton stated that politics played no role in the legal strategy, asserting that the agency sued the most aggressive states.
“The CFTC didn’t pick these states; they picked themselves,” he said.
Kalshi Fights Back

North Carolina Representative Pricey Harrison introduced a bill aimed at restricting prediction markets in the state
Last month, North Carolina House Democrat Pricey Harrison carefully reviewed a printed copy of the state’s latest budget draft. She noticed a troubling provision on page 626.
Harrison had recently introduced legislation to restrict prediction markets. But what was included in the budget appeared to her as a “gift” to the industry. The document stated that prediction markets approved by the CFTC “may legally operate in the state due to their registration with the commission.” These markets would pay a 6% revenue tax, lower than the 23% rate imposed on sports betting companies.
“I’m not the most observant person,” Harrison said, “but at the time, I thought, ‘Oh, this doesn’t sound right.’”
The provision would allow prediction markets to operate in North Carolina without fear of state litigation. According to two people familiar with the discussions, a Kalshi lobbyist—former North Carolina legislator Jim Harrell—helped draft this language during conversations with Republican leadership in the state House. Feedback from the company helped ensure the tax rate fell below the level lawmakers had initially considered.
Lawmakers also received input from the White House, another sign of government interference in state-level disputes. A spokesperson for State House Speaker Destin Hall said the Office of Intergovernmental Affairs shared information regarding “the federal government’s position on state regulation of prediction markets.” The budget was signed into law on July 7.
A White House spokesperson stated that President Trump considers it “vital” for the CFTC to maintain exclusive authority over these markets.
Hall’s spokesperson denied that the tax provision was a handout, pointing out that prediction markets were not previously required to pay taxes. Kalshi said the North Carolina arrangement is fair to the industry. The company noted that because many people win money on prediction markets, North Carolina will also tax those winnings.
So far, the litigation results have been mixed. All nine lawsuits filed by the CFTC remain pending in federal courts. Judges in Nevada, Washington, and elsewhere have ruled against Kalshi, ordering it to halt operations. Although the company secured an initial victory in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in New Jersey, other appellate courts are still considering the cases.
Yet policy victories in places like North Carolina still carry significance. Two weeks after the budget was signed, a Kalshi lawyer cited the agreement in filings for one of the appeals, describing it as a compromise model that could apply to other jurisdictions.
The company is pushing for more wins. According to one source familiar with the matter, as of this month, Kalshi has deployed lobbyists in all 50 states.














