TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
To Whom Should Aave Hand Over Its Brand? The Dispute Over DAO Asset Ownership Behind the Foundation Proposal

To Whom Should Aave Hand Over Its Brand? The Dispute Over DAO Asset Ownership Behind the Foundation Proposal

2026.10.04
Share
Aave Labs has proposed establishing a foundation with no members or shareholders in the Cayman Islands to hold the brand and intellectual property, but the first phase will only involve setting up a shell without transferring trademarks and domain names, and the actual handover of the brand from a private company to DAO governance has not yet begun.

By Xiaobing

On October 2, Aave Labs submitted an apparently straightforward proposal on the governance forum: establish a foundation company registered in the Cayman Islands with no members and no shareholders, intended to hold and protect the Aave brand and related intellectual property.

Titled "Aave Foundation, Phase I", the proposal coincided with an approximately 8% increase in the AAVE token price that day.

But the real reason this proposal warrants careful reading lies in its implication of an uncomfortable truth for many AAVE holders: to this day, neither the Aave brand, trademark, nor core domain names are held by the DAO.

An awkward reality: DAO funds it, others hold the marks

In the database of the United States Patent and Trademark Office, the registered owner of the AAVE trademark is Quantum Swan OÜ, a company registered in Estonia. The trademark was first filed in November 2018 and officially registered in August 2019.

Quantum Swan is affiliated with Aave Labs (the development company founded by Stani Kulechov), meaning that the protocol governed by the Aave DAO operates under a trademark held by a private company.

This arrangement was common in the early days of DeFi, where teams would register trademarks first before gradually opening source code and decentralizing. What sets Aave apart is that the DAO has been operational for years, spending substantial funds to pay developers for coding, risk control models, and frontend construction. The intellectual property generated from these efforts belongs partly to the DAO and partly to the service providers, while the most critical brand assets (trademarks, domains, social media accounts) have never formally belonged to the DAO.

In December 2025, the conflict came to a head.

DAO representatives put forward a radical proposal on the governance forum, demanding that Aave Labs transfer all brand assets, code intellectual property, GitHub repositories, npm packages, and social media accounts to the DAO, while downgrading Aave Labs to a subordinate entity under the DAO. Aave Labs responded that the website and brand belong to Labs, whereas the DAO owns the smart contracts.

The outcome of the negotiation between both parties was the “Aave Will Win” framework announced in early 2026, wherein Labs committed to incorporating brand custody into governance and reaffirmed that the AAVE token is the sole core asset of the ecosystem.

This foundation proposal represents the fulfillment of that commitment.

What exactly does the proposal entail?

The scope of the Phase I proposal is extremely narrow: registering the entity and appointing initial independent directors and supervisors. That is all.

It involves no trademark transfers, no domain name transfers, and no code intellectual property transfers. Any actual transfer of assets will require separate governance proposals and votes later on.

A few key characteristics of the foundation's legal structure are worth noting.

No members, no shareholders. Under the Cayman Islands Foundation Companies Act, such entities can exist independently without any owners, legally holding assets, signing contracts, and litigating. This resolves a fundamental dilemma faced by DAOs: assets require a legal "owner," yet no one should stand above the DAO.

Aave Labs cannot serve as a director or supervisor of the foundation. The proposal explicitly states that Aave Labs, DAO service providers, and their affiliates hold no right to appoint or serve as directors or supervisors. After the initial appointments are complete, any changes to the board must be decided by token holder vote through an AIP (Aave Improvement Proposal).

The DAO retains core control. Through governance, token holders hold the following powers over the foundation: appointing and removing directors; vetoing amendments to the articles of incorporation, disposal of core intellectual property, mergers, and restructuring; and requiring the foundation to publicly report to the governance forum quarterly on held assets, operating expenses, and any trademark enforcement actions.

The brand license is unilateral. The foundation licenses the Aave brand to product developers free of charge, but this does not grant control over protocol governance. The foundation manages the brand, while the DAO manages the protocol.

Phase I does not establish an ongoing budget, requesting only reasonable registration, legal, and personnel costs. Any subsequent funding requirements will need separate governance votes.

What problem does this design solve?

For the DeFi industry, this Aave proposal merits more attention than fluctuations in the AAVE token price.

Almost every major DeFi protocol faces the same issue: code is open source, but brands are not.

Uniswap’s trademarks belong to Uniswap Labs, Compound’s branding is tied to Compound Labs, and MakerDAO’s brand assets formerly belonged to the Maker Ecosystem Growth Foundation, which sparked significant community controversy when transitioning to the Sky ecosystem.

Open-source code means anyone can fork a protocol with identical functionality. Without a brand, however, a forked protocol cannot use the original name, domain, or user trust—these are what truly constitute a protocol’s greatest moat.

When a brand is held by a private company, a hidden power asymmetry exists between the company and the DAO: the DAO controls protocol parameters and treasury funds, but the company controls user access points to the protocol (frontends, domains, brand perception). Both are indispensable, yet only the company holds legal ownership of the brand.

The design of the Aave Foundation attempts to break this asymmetry. By creating a "ownerless" legal entity to hold the brand, and using governance mechanisms to let the DAO control personnel and major decisions within that entity, it establishes a nested structure where "the brand has a legal owner, but that owner is accountable to the DAO through governance."

The Phase I proposal is sufficiently clean: it builds the shell without moving anything, leaving limited room for controversy. The real test lies in subsequent phases.

Will Quantum Swan OÜ transfer the trademark unconditionally? The current proposal makes no mention of compensation or conditions for the transfer. If Quantum Swan demands compensation, who will bear the cost? If legal hurdles arise during the transfer process, does the DAO have a backup plan?

How will the boundaries of code intellectual property be drawn? Aave’s codebase involves contributions from multiple service providers. The proposal mentions "intellectual property transferred by service providers to the foundation per agreement," but determining which code belongs to the DAO (funded by the DAO), which belongs to the providers (written by them), and which belongs to Labs (generated under employment), will inevitably spark discussion in later stages.

This is not an issue that can be resolved with a single vote. It is a phased governance project that may span months. Each phase will return to the forum, and each phase can be vetoed by the community.

What does this mean for the AAVE token?

When launching the proposal, Stani stated: "Bring Aave’s intellectual property under DAO ownership, unifying everything under a single asset: AAVE."

The underlying implication is this: when the brand, trademarks, domains, and code intellectual property all fall under an entity governed by AAVE holders, the governance rights attached to the AAVE token expand from "protocol parameters" to "brands and intellectual property." As the token’s governance boundaries widen, its governance premium should theoretically expand as well.

If trademarks and domains are successfully transferred to the foundation, AAVE holders will truly become "indirect owners" of the Aave brand. If the transfer process encounters obstacles or faces significant dilution, then this phase will have merely built an empty shell.

As DeFi governance has evolved, it is shifting from "voting on interest rate parameters" to "voting on brand ownership." This is a more complex area, closer to traditional corporate governance, and one that DAOs must learn to navigate.

Aave has taken the first step. But this step is only about building a house. The move itself has not yet begun.