
The crypto bill fails and the Fed raises rates, yet Bitcoin still rises?
By: Cathy
The bill failed, interest rates were hiked, yet Bitcoin still rose 6%. That was the crypto market over the past week.
On September 15, the Clarity Act, which the crypto industry has lobbied for over a year, fell in the Senate with 49 votes in favor and 50 against, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed to advance. Coinbase and Circle both dropped roughly 10% that day, and Bitcoin briefly plunged below $75,000 from near $80,000.
The next day, the Federal Reserve unanimously passed a 25-basis-point rate hike with a 12-0 vote, raising the federal funds rate to 3.75%–4%, marking the first increase since July 2023.
On the third day, the SEC released a five-year "innovation exemption" order allowing tokenized U.S. stocks to be traded on public chains using liquidity pools. On September 18, Bitcoin surged from $76,000 to above $81,000, with CoinGlass reporting approximately $470 million in short positions liquidated within 24 hours.
Three days, two heavy blows, one piece of candy. The market chose the candy.
A week ago, Glassnode called the 1.07 million Bitcoin held in the $83,000–$86,000 range the "visible ceiling seen by everyone" in its weekly report. Over the past week, with both bearish catalysts fully priced in, the price instead drifted back to the foot of this wall.
The question shifted accordingly: Is this the starting point of the "sell-the-news" rally, or a repeat of the pump-then-dump pattern we saw in 2023?
01 Two Heavy Blows, Yet Price Only Dipped to $75,000
The core of the CLARITY Act is to delineate which digital assets fall under the jurisdiction of the SEC versus the CFTC. Bill sponsor and Republican Senator Cynthia Lummis stated before the vote that she had already accommodated more than 120 Democratic requests, warning that if it still failed, "we're done."
What blocked it wasn't the crypto industry itself, but an ethics provision. Democrats insisted that restrictions on officials holding digital assets extend to the President and First Family, deeming the revised text insufficient, resulting in zero affirmative votes and four Republicans joining the opposition.
As a result, regulatory certainty at the federal level is pushed back at least until the next Congress.
On the rate hike front, Fed Chair Walsh said at the press conference, "Inflation is too high and has been too long." In the economic projections, inflation won't return to 2% until 2029, and dot plot data showed 16 of 18 officials expect another hike this year. The two-year Treasury yield climbed to 4.74%.
Yet the market's price reaction was restrained. On the day of the decision, Bitcoin hovered between $75,000 and $76,500, closing at $76,200. The recent accumulation zone Glassnode identified at $76,000–$82,000 was not broken. What actually fled was ETF capital: over September 15 and 16, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs experienced a net outflow of $746 million.
The bad news hit, but the price did not collapse. This is the first signal the market is giving.
02 What Exactly Does the SEC's Exemption Order Allow?
Over the past two years, tokenized U.S. stocks have mostly been issued overseas and sold only to non-U.S. residents, functioning essentially as synthetic price-trackers where holders receive no dividends and hold no voting rights.
This order takes a different approach. From September 17 until September 17, 2031, qualifying platforms can use AMM liquidity pools on permissionless public blockchains to facilitate trading of tokenized U.S. stocks without registering as exchanges; institutions providing liquidity to these pools are also exempt from dealer registration.
The conditions are extensive. Tokens must carry identical rights to the underlying stock, including dividends and voting power, banning synthetics; issuers must receive written notice 30 days prior to listing and retain veto power; access is restricted to vetted U.S. persons only; and chain listings pause simultaneously with circuit breakers on traditional exchanges.
Another missing piece fell into place in June: the SEC proposed repealing Rule 611 of the Regulation National Market System, which requires every stock trade to execute at the national best bid and offer—a standard AMMs cannot meet due to their algorithmic pricing. Without repealing Rule 611, liquidity pools would remain legally noncompliant.
SEC Chair Paul Atkins was direct in his statement: Congress failed to advance the Clarity Act, so today the SEC took a step forward.
SIFMA President Kenneth Bentsen issued a statement that same day, expressing concern that multiple tokenized versions of the same stock trading in parallel could fragment liquidity and confuse investors.
The market voted with its price. Uniswap's UNI surged roughly 30% within 24 hours to a 10-month high; Ondo, which focuses on compliant tokenized Treasuries, rose 7.39%. Currently, tokenized real-world assets on public chains total just over $30 billion, including BlackRock's BUIDL fund at approximately $2.8 billion, which remains restricted to institutional investors.
The 25-basis-point rate hike was digested in a single day. Tokenizing U.S. equities earned a 6% price response.
03 How the 2023 Pump-Then-Dump Unfolded
Drawing the charts back to 2023, the first half of the script was nearly identical.
On June 15, 2023, BlackRock filed for a spot Bitcoin ETF, and Bitcoin started from $25,000. On July 13, a judge ruled that secondary sales of XRP on exchanges do not constitute securities transactions, pushing Bitcoin to $31,800 and a 13-month high. It was another rise fueled by regulatory tailwinds.
On July 26, the Fed hiked rates by 25 basis points to 5.25%–5.5%. Bitcoin closed at $29,400 that day, barely reacting. Over the following 13 days, the price edged higher between $29,000 and $30,000, peaking at $30,200 on August 8—the highest point post-hike.
Then the decline began. On August 17, Bitcoin plummeted intraday 11% from $28,700 to $25,400. CoinGlass reported $1.032 billion in liquidations affecting 175,000 traders within 24 hours; CoinShares data showed perpetual futures open interest dropping by $2.75 billion in a single day, marking the largest deleveraging event since the FTX collapse.
Explanations that day pointed to SpaceX writing down and selling its Bitcoin holdings, plus Evergrande filing for bankruptcy protection in New York, but the broader backdrop was the 10-year Treasury yield hitting its highest since 2007. By September 11, Bitcoin breached $25,000 again.
Rates hiked, followed by a 13-day rally, then a 17% drawdown over five weeks. If calculated from the July 13 peak of $31,800, Bitcoin lost 22% over two months. The euphoria from regulatory good news was gradually eroded by rising interest rates.
The similarities are clear: regulatory tailwinds push it up, macro headwinds push it back down.
The differences are equally clear. There was no spot ETF in 2023; buying pressure came mainly from retail on exchanges and Grayscale's trust. Today, U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs hold roughly $103 billion in assets, with $3.52 billion in net inflows for August alone. Stablecoin market cap stands above $300 billion.
But Glassnode's assessment last week cannot be ignored either: new demand has stalled. On-chain capital inflows halted after 27 consecutive days of growth; corporate treasury purchases dropped from 89,000 BTC in July last year to just 5,900 BTC over the past three months; stablecoin supply sits 4% below its April peak.
Both interpretations have merit. The structure of buying pressure has indeed shifted, but the volume itself is shrinking.
04 Still 6% Away from $86,000
$81,000 merely returns us to the base of the wall. According to early September Glassnode data, approximately 1.07 million BTC from long-term holders are locked in the $83,000–$86,000 range, while the ETF aggregate breakeven level also sits near $86,000, meaning they have been in unrealized loss for 228 consecutive trading days as of early September.
Whether it truly breaks through depends on three indicators.
First, a weekly candle close firmly holding $86,000, indicating the 1.07 million BTC of trapped supply has been absorbed.
Second, U.S. spot ETFs recording consecutive weekly net inflows exceeding $1.5 billion for three straight weeks, signaling sustained fresh capital rather than a one-day spike.
Third, the 30-year U.S. Treasury yield dipping below 5%, showing risk-free rates are no longer weighing on risk assets.
None of the three conditions are met yet; they have simply stopped deteriorating. As of September 19, the price sits near $81,000, still 6% away from $86,000. For the week, ETFs saw outflows of $746 million in the first two days and inflows of $593 million in the latter two, ending roughly flat—hardly a case of sustained inflows. The 30-year Treasury yield closed at 5.33% on September 18, remaining above 5%.
The options market is even more blunt. The max pain level sits at $72,000, with heavy call option sell walls clustered at $85,000 and $90,000. Options sellers are betting the price will fail to escape the $72,000–$85,000 band.
BitMEX co-founder Arthur Hayes posted the day after the rate hike, arguing that raising rates amid such high government debt actually acts as stimulus: bank reserve interest payments and Treasury holder yields rise together, ultimately driving more consumption, particularly spending on financial assets. Total assets held by the Fed and banks continue to grow, money supply increases, only its price rises.
His conclusion: "Asset prices will continue to rise."
Peter Boockvar, Chief Investment Officer at One Point BFG, holds the opposite view. He believes this hike merely unwinds the December cut from last year; the Fed is primarily grappling with an energy supply shock to which it is powerless, and it might be wiser to let bond markets determine the price of money themselves.
Hayes speaks to the quantity of money; Boockvar speaks to its price. In 2023, price won.
Whether this time will be different won't be found in the SEC's order, but in the ETF flow statements over the next two weeks.
The candy has been eaten, but the wall remains standing.















