TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
ZAMA, the privacy layer of the Ethereum ecosystem: How far is it from true value capture?

ZAMA, the privacy layer of the Ethereum ecosystem: How far is it from true value capture?

2026.09.20
Share
ZAMA has hit a new high, but its current valuation remains primarily driven by the FHE privacy narrative, with real demand yet to be verified.

By Xiao Bing

ZAMA rose approximately 42% over the past 24 hours to $0.085, hitting an all-time high. Its market capitalization surpassed $210 million, with a 24-hour trading volume of $112 million.

The catalyst stems from the combination of two product moves: On September 15, Zama expanded Morpho’s Confidential Vaults on Ethereum from five to twenty-one. On September 17, Zama partnered with Merkl to launch “Confidential Incentives,” enabling cTokens (confidential tokens) to seamlessly integrate into Merkl’s DeFi incentive infrastructure. On the same day, the Zama Swap Protocol went live, supporting swaps between encrypted assets.

According to the project team, Shielded TVL has broken through $75 million. DefiLlama currently tracks approximately $78.28 million.

Falling from its TGE issue price of $0.05 in February to a low of $0.017, and now reaching an all-time high of $0.085, ZAMA has completed a full V-shaped reversal within seven and a half months.

The question is: How much of the right half of this V is supported by genuine demand?

What Zama Did: Turning DeFi into a “Sealed Envelope”?

First, let’s understand what problem Zama is solving.

All data on public blockchains is transparent. Your balance, your transactions, your DeFi positions can be viewed by anyone on Etherscan. This matters little to most retail users, but it is fatal for institutions; no asset management firm would want competitors to see their positions and trading strategies in real time.

Zama addresses this with Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE). FHE allows smart contracts to perform computations while data remains fully encrypted: inputs are encrypted, the computation process is encrypted, and outputs are encrypted. No one can see the underlying data at any stage.

To put it bluntly: traditional DeFi counts money in an open plaza, while Zama’s FHE completes all calculations inside a sealed envelope—you only see the result when you open it, not the process.

Zama operates as a cross-chain confidential layer, sitting atop L1s and L2s like Ethereum via an fhEVM co-processor. Developers do not require permission or payment to deploy confidential applications; Zama’s monetization comes directly from the encryption and decryption operations themselves, costing approximately $0.13 per on-chain encryption operation.

Token Economics: The Tug-of-War Between Burn and Mint

ZAMA’s token design revolves around a “burn-and-mint” model:

Fee side: 100% of all protocol fees (encryption and decryption fees) are burned. Every time someone uses Zama’s FHE functionality, ZAMA is permanently removed from circulation.

Emission side: Staking rewards are paid out through new token emissions at an annualized rate of approximately 5%. These emission rewards are distributed to operators running FHE co-processor nodes and delegators who stake ZAMA.

The core question boils down to simple arithmetic: Can the amount of ZAMA burned annually exceed the amount emitted annually?

If yes, ZAMA becomes deflationary: as usage grows, circulating supply continuously shrinks, tightening the token’s supply. If no, ZAMA is inflationary: the emission rate for staking rewards outpaces the burn rate of usage fees, diluting the value for token holders.

Current data does not support an optimistic conclusion. With a total supply of 11 billion and current circulating supply around 2.56 billion, a 5% annualized emission means roughly 550 million new tokens are minted each year. To cover emissions with burns, assuming a fee of $0.13 per encryption operation, approximately 4.2 billion encryption operations would be needed annually.

Based on the current Shielded TVL (approximately $78.28 million) and transaction frequency, this number is far from being reached. ZAMA currently remains in a phase where “emissions far exceed burns.”

The Quality of the $78.28 Million TVL

The growth speed of Shielded TVL is indeed staggering. The first vault launched in June hit $40 million within seven weeks. After expanding to 21 vaults on September 15, TVL broke through $75 million and reached $78.28 million two days later.

However, this growth needs to be dissected into three layers:

Layer 1: Subsidy-driven deposits. The “Confidential Incentives” mechanism, launched in partnership with Merkl, allows protocols to provide liquidity incentives for confidential vaults. This means part of the TVL consists of “hot money” attracted by subsidized rates, following the exact same logic as traditional DeFi “yield farming subsidies.” When the subsidies end, this portion of the TVL will leave.

Layer 2: Double-counting of wrapped assets. Twelve of the 21 vaults are “hybrid vaults,” which wrap an existing Morpho strategy in a confidentiality layer. Users deposit USDC, which is first wrapped into cUSDC (confidential USDC) before being deposited into the vault. If DefiLlama counts both the underlying Morpho vault TVL and the outer confidential vault TVL simultaneously during TVL calculations, double-counting may occur.

Layer 3: Genuine paid privacy demand. Only four vaults are “standalone vaults” with no public counterparts. The TVL backing these vaults more likely reflects true privacy demand; users choose them over standard Morpho specifically because they require confidentiality.

Currently, there is no public data to precisely split the proportions of these three layers. But a key benchmark will be how much TVL remains after the subsidy campaign ends. If it holds above 50%, it indicates genuine demand exists; if it drops significantly, it shows the current TVL is primarily incentive-driven.

Competitive Landscape: How Significant is Zama’s First-Mover Advantage?

The FHE track is not exclusive to Zama; several major competitors exist:

Fhenix: Backed by Offchain Labs (the developer behind Arbitrum), it focuses on CoFHE co-processors and a privacy layer for L2 rollups. It is already live on Base and Arbitrum Sepolia. The difference from Zama is that Fhenix is more L2-specific, whereas Zama offers a cross-chain universal solution.

Inco Network: A modular confidential L1, with March 2026 data showing 25% month-over-month active user growth. Raised $4.5 million in seed funding. Secured approximately $4.7 billion in restaked ETH security through Ethos.

Mind Network: Another FHE infrastructure project focused on the intersection of AI and data privacy.

Zama’s advantages lie in: over $150M in funding, a Series B at a $1B valuation, the largest FHE deployment on the Ethereum mainnet (21 vaults, $78M TVL), and influence over FHE token standards as the proposer of the ERC-7984 specification.

However, the overall FHE track remains in its very early stages. A $78M TVL is almost invisible in the broader DeFi ecosystem (Aave is roughly $12B, Morpho around $2B), meaning Zama’s first-mover advantage is reflected more in its tech stack and ecosystem partnerships than in market scale.

Valuation Anchors

Current data: ZAMA trades at $0.085, with a circulating supply of 2.56 billion and a circulating market cap of approximately $217 million. Total supply stands at 11 billion, pushing FDV to roughly $935 million.

Based on a $78.28 million TVL, the FDV/TVL ratio sits at roughly 12x. For comparison, Morpho’s FDV/TVL is about 3–4x, and Aave is around 2x. This multiple reflects market expectations for an “FHE privacy premium,” but also implies that if TVL growth stalls, the current valuation lacks fundamental support.

A more core valuation variable is fee revenue. At $0.13 per encryption operation, even assuming the entire Shielded TVL is active (generating 0.01 encryption operations per dollar of TVL daily), annualized fee revenue would be approximately $285,000. The FDV/annualized fee ratio sits at roughly 3,280x.

This is a typical asset priced by “narrative rather than cash flow.” Buying ZAMA is equivalent to betting on an assumption: FHE privacy will become the foundational infrastructure layer of DeFi, hundreds of billions of dollars in on-chain assets will require encrypted protection in the future, and Zama will capture the majority of this demand.