TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Five weeks after halting redemptions, what’s the catch behind Neutrl’s half-price buybacks?

Five weeks after halting redemptions, what’s the catch behind Neutrl’s half-price buybacks?

2026.09.18
Share
Allocating 27 million in cash to cover a 53.5 million share float, is this discounted payout truly a stop-loss exit route, or an "unfair clause" designed to force retail investors to sign off and accept their losses?

Written by: Sanqing, Foresight News

On September 17, decentralized yield protocol Neutrl announced the opening of the redemption portal for NUSD and sNUSD. Holders can exchange their tokens at a fixed exchange rate into USDC, after which the corresponding tokens will be burned. The redemption window is expected to remain open until November 14. According to on-chain contract data, the `redemptionRate` parameter of the Neutrl redemption contract returns a value of 510000000000000000. Converted using 18 decimal places, this yields 0.51, meaning each 1 NUSD can be redeemed for 0.51 USDC at a fixed ratio.

Five Weeks of Suspension Only Yield a "Half-Price" Redemption in the Contract

The only publicly named co-founder and CEO of Neutrl is South African entrepreneur Behrin Naidoo. He graduated early from the University of Cape Town and London Business School. His career included stints at PwC, JPMorgan Chase's South African equity research department, and RMB/RMI, followed by involvement in building the liquidity management protocol Fyde Treasury.

The operating entity behind the protocol is Caverna Auctus Inc., registered in Panama. In April 2025, Neutrl completed a seed round of approximately $5 million, led by UK-registered lock-up asset OTC platform STIX and US-based Boston VC fund Accomplice. Participating investors include Amber Group, Nascent, Figment Capital, SCB Limited under Susquehanna, among others, along with angel investors such as Ethena founder Guy Young and Arbelos co-founder Joshua Lim.

Among these, lead investor STIX is a core piece of Neutrl's business. STIX is an OTC trading platform specializing in illiquid and locked tokens. Its founder, Taranveer Sabharwal, previously served as an early-stage advisor for Fyde Treasury and has long been connected with Behrin.

In Neutrl's flywheel, STIX serves not only as the seed round lead investor but also as one of the key "supply" channels for underlying discounted locked tokens. Users deposit USDC, USDT, or USDe to mint NUSD, which they can stake to become sNUSD to earn floating yields. The protocol, meanwhile, uses channels like STIX to purchase discounted OTC positions with lock-up periods, and hedges price volatility in the derivatives market using perpetual short positions.

This design deeply binds the protocol to specific OTC distribution networks from its inception. The terms have also clearly stipulated that ownership of the assets belongs to the company after minting; legally, the tokens represent yield-bearing debt claims rather than original proprietary rights to the deposited principal.

Short Positions Cannot Hedge Liquidity Mismatch

However, short positions only smooth out market price fluctuations but cannot resolve payment deadlocks stemming from illiquid OTC lock-ups that cannot be liquidated, or counterparty failure to settle.

The liability side provides the market with immediately payable liabilities recorded at $1, while the asset side traps non-liquid, locked-in positions that cannot be converted to cash. This maturity mismatch was inherent from the protocol's initial design. A Neutrl tweet once noted that the peak AUM during its Season 1 phase was approximately $230 million.

In early 2026, BA Labs, acting as the risk advisor for Summer.fi's high-risk vaults, marked Neutrl as "Higher Risk" in a report evaluating whether sNUSD could qualify for vault inclusion, citing elevated counterparty and operational risks. (Note: This forum proposal was merely a third-party risk assessment; the protocol security incident that Summer.fi later faced in July was an independent code attack unrelated to Neutrl's asset redemption or strategy mechanisms.)

This assessment was subsequently paraphrased and cited in discussions at the Summer.fi governance forum regarding the vault admission proposal for sNUSD. In a subsequent February evaluation, it recorded a then-supply of approximately $226 million and reserves of roughly $233.7 million, with over 87% held in Fireblocks custody. The core exposure directly pointed to liquidity and counterparty risks, noting that direct redemption channels were exclusively limited to KYC/KYB institutional users, while excess withdrawals faced a non-binding 48-hour queue.

On August 13, Neutrl suddenly announced the suspension of minting and redemptions. The announcement merely stated that "reserves were impacted," and subsequent communications emphasized that no hacking incidents or code vulnerabilities had occurred, but failed to clarify whether the issue stemmed from positions, counterparties, or liquidity.

On the same day, the NUSD/USDC pool on Curve was drained of approximately $3.51 million in liquidity and subsequently blacklisted. The official team simultaneously disabled Twitter comments and set community channels to read-only mode. At that time, NUSD's external circulating market cap had already fallen to around $53.5 million.

On August 28, Neutrl released its first verified data, stating that readily available liquid assets totaled approximately $27 million, while the remainder of the assets are "currently unliquidatable," with both recovery timelines and amounts completely unverifiable.

This $27 million in liquid cash represents roughly half of the ~$53.5 million circulating supply at the time of the suspension, aligning closely with the 0.51 redemption ratio set on September 17. This approach resembles distributing the remaining tokens based directly on the transparent cash available at that moment, rather than reflecting a clear settlement result following full penetration valuation.

As for how much value remains in the outstanding unliquidated positions, neither Neutrl, STIX, nor any other third party has issued a statement.

Paying via Signed Acknowledgment of Loss Before Receiving Refunds?

For token holders, the redemption mechanism places all staked and unstaked positions back on the same starting line. sNUSD must first be unstaked into NUSD before being exchanged into USDC at a fixed ratio of 0.51.

Following the discounted redemption comes widespread community skepticism regarding the true nature of the redemption process. Neutrl officially defines this as a standard "Terms & Conditions" requirement, stating that holders must connect their wallets and sign an on-chain message to "verify wallet ownership," without which redemption is impossible. Legally, there is currently no definitive judicial ruling on whether this signature constitutes a waiver of claims against remaining assets.

The shockwaves simultaneously spread to downstream markets. Structured yield protocol Strata had previously established a market worth approximately $1.7 million for Neutrl, splitting sNUSD into senior tranches (srNUSD) and junior tranches (jrNUSD) that absorb first losses.

On September 17, Strata observed the 0.51 redemption exchange rate provided by the Neutrl contract, identifying it as the only observable immediate reference value for conversion. Because the loss magnitude completely breached the junior tranche's protection cushion, Strata wrote down the net value of jrNUSD to zero according to its rules. Approximately 1.5698 million sNUSD tokens held by the strategy were fully allocated to approximately 1.3472 million srNUSD tokens to absorb the losses. After the 48-hour timelock expired, senior tranche holders retrieved their assets, but what was returned to their wallets remained sNUSD. To liquidate, they would still need to visit the Neutrl portal and accept the discounted rate of 0.51.

From Neutrl to other nested protocols, gaps in disclosure have never been bridged.

Historical data from the Neutrl dashboard retrieved by on-chain research firm D2 Finance shows that on June 7, 2026, the protocol's asset-side recorded reserves totaled approximately $137 million. Among these, separately flagged discounted OTC lock-up positions amounted to only about $12.52 million, with the vast majority consisting of three large, undisclosed positions targeting unknown entities and counterparties (amounting to approximately $41.96 million, $35.77 million, and $21.19 million, respectively).

Under Neutrl's accounting logic, discounted spot positions are recorded with conservative liquidity adjustments, while perpetual shorts and liquidity buffers account for the largest portion of the balance sheet. However, with the official team withholding details on specific assets and counterparties, it remains impossible for outsiders to determine which position incurred impairment.

By late August, officials acknowledged that cash available for immediate liquidity stood at only about $27 million, with the vast remainder classified as "currently unliquidatable." Which OTC position encountered problems? How did the asset-side book reserves degrade through discounting and redemption payouts? What exactly was the actual impairment margin?

To date, Neutrl has not published a public ledger or reconciliation report to address these numerous concerns. For synthetic dollars lacking continuous independent verification of asset reserves, adequate collateralization on paper is not equivalent to the ability to honor full redemptions. Furthermore, Neutrl has yet to make any commitment regarding whether a second payout tranche will occur beyond the current 0.51 rate.