TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
500 Years of Evolution, Prediction Markets Finally Become New Infrastructure for Global Information Pricing

500 Years of Evolution, Prediction Markets Finally Become New Infrastructure for Global Information Pricing

2026.08.07
Share
From a niche experiment to a hundred-billion market.

Author: DWF Labs

Compiled by: Luffy, Foresight News

As early as 1503, betting activities on the selection of the next Pope appeared in Rome. By 1916, converted to 2012 USD value, Americans wagered approximately $211 million solely on the U.S. presidential election, all occurring in the New York betting market. On busy trading days, the volume of election-related betting even exceeded stock trading on Wall Street's OTC exchanges.

Since the Renaissance, people have started pricing uncertain outcomes with money, and such markets have performed quite well in this regard. So why have mature and viable prediction markets been slow to emerge? How did Kalshi and Polymarket finally achieve a breakthrough? This article will review the development history of prediction markets and explore their future direction.

What is a Prediction Market?

Prediction markets allow users to trade shares on the outcomes of future events. Trading prices range between $0-$1, reflecting the market's judgment on the probability of the event occurring in real-time. Unlike sports betting, you do not need to hold positions until event settlement. As the market fluctuates and probabilities change, you can open or close positions at any time.

Theoretically, prediction markets can become all-encompassing information markets: trading the probability of a Fed rate hike, how many Grammys Taylor Swift will win, the temperature in Paris on February 18, etc.

Kalshi's Culture-Themed Prediction Markets

Theoretical Foundations and Early Dilemmas

1988 was the founding year of modern prediction markets. Robin Hanson, recognized as the progenitor of this field, wrote the first academic theories on information markets and idea futures. In the same year, three professors at the University of Iowa built the Iowa Electronic Markets (IEM). Over five election cycles, the probability predictions given by the Iowa Electronic Markets were more accurate than polls in 74% of cases, confirming Friedrich Hayek's 1945 viewpoint: the market is the most efficient way to aggregate collective wisdom.

Iowa Electronic Markets founders George Neumann, Forrest Nelson, Robert Forsythe, Source: NBC News

Although conceptually validated early on, the 2000-2010s were filled with numerous failed projects. In July 2003, the Policy Analysis Market launched by the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) was shut down only one day after launch. Two senators accused this project, designed by Robin Hanson, of equivalent to opening a betting market on assassination events. The U.S. Congress prohibited the Hollywood Stock Exchange from transforming into a real movie futures exchange. Intrade operated in Dublin for over a decade but was sued by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in 2012 for providing unregistered options to U.S. users. The platform collapsed in March 2013.

The crypto industry was once seen as the solution. The launch of the Ethereum mainnet provided developers with programmable underlying infrastructure. Decentralization and censorship resistance seemed to fit the development needs of prediction markets perfectly. But new problems followed. Augur, launched in 2018, required users to bear high Ethereum Gas fees, resulting in a poor product experience. The platform's peak user count was only 265, plummeting to 37 within a month.

Problems Facing Prediction Markets

Before 2024, a large number of projects perished. Common explanations were strict regulatory environments and poor product execution. Teams underestimated regulatory scrutiny while ignoring product interfaces and user experience. But these were not enough to explain the deep structural contradictions of prediction markets. Nick Whitaker and J. Zachary Mazlish proposed a more thorough analysis in a widely circulated "Works in Progress" article in 2024.

A market capable of sustainable operation requires three types of core participants:

  • Savers: Pursuing long-term returns to achieve wealth appreciation
  • Gamblers: Pursuing excitement and pleasure
  • Professional Traders: Relying on deep analysis to arbitrage from mispricing

Basic forms of prediction markets lack appeal to all three groups. Prediction markets are zero-sum games, and even negative-sum games after deducting fees. Savers are therefore completely unwilling to participate; they need positive-sum markets to achieve wealth growth. Most real-world events have long settlement cycles and niche themes, making it hard to attract gamblers, who generally prefer targets with quick results.

Lacking the counterparty liquidity brought by savers and gamblers, professional traders cannot find liquidity worth entering. The market ends up with only professional traders gaming against each other. This is the real-world version of the No-Trade Theorem: if everyone is sufficiently rational, no one is willing to act as the counterparty.

Apart from market structure, most themes have limited appeal to the general public. Without trading volume, professional traders have no incentive to enter and compete for meager potential returns. Of course, exceptions exist, such as sports and political themes. Whitaker and Mazlish concluded that without external subsidies, the "predict everything" prediction market model cannot scale.

How Prediction Markets Finally Achieved a Breakthrough

Despite the aforementioned realistic defects, prediction markets have grown into a mature product category. They exploded during the 2024 U.S. presidential election, with their probabilities widely cited as a factual reference. The New York Times cited prediction market data, CNBC broadcasted it, and Bloomberg Terminal even built-in relevant data directly. Total financing scale for companies in this sector has exceeded $5 billion, with financing accelerating over the past 18 months.

Even if you haven't followed this sector, you have likely heard of the two platforms driving the industry breakthrough: Polymarket and Kalshi. Together they account for over 90% of industry trading volume, with monthly total industry trading volume exceeding $58 billion.

Polymarket

Polymarket was founded by Shayne Coplan in 2020. He is a NYU dropout, participated in the Ethereum ICO in 2014, and wrote a letter to Robin Hanson in 2019 hoping to make prediction markets a reality. During the COVID-19 pandemic, he launched this product from his apartment in Manhattan's Lower East Side.

Iterations in crypto infrastructure, such as low-cost Layer 2 networks and stablecoins, helped Polymarket avoid the pitfalls of early crypto prediction markets. The platform runs on Polygon (Ethereum Layer 2), compressing Gas fees to a few cents; it uses the platform's own stablecoin PUSD for settlement, where a $1 payout amount is truly $1, with no price volatility risk during the holding period. Trading uses a hybrid order book, off-chain matching ensures speed, on-chain settlement ensures trustworthiness, combining the smooth experience of centralized exchanges with non-custodial settlement characteristics.

Polymarket Founder and CEO Shayne Coplan, Source: Forbes

Polymarket adopted a "launch first, solve regulatory issues later" approach, gaining higher freedom and faster iteration speed compared to competitors at the time. The platform gained early growth during the 2020 U.S. presidential election, with monthly trading volume reaching about $26 million, and subsequently continued to expand relying on pandemic and pop culture-related markets.

The hidden dangers of lacking regulation eventually caught up. In January 2022, the CFTC fined Polymarket $1.4 million and required the platform to block U.S. users. Compliance subsequently became the highest priority matter: the platform geoblocked the U.S. region, hired a former CFTC chairman as an advisor, and continued operating in the rest of the global regions. Platform trading volume in 2023 was about $73 million, negligible compared to current trading volume, but enough to survive the crypto winter.

Next came the 2024 U.S. presidential election, a highlight moment for the industry. Although officially prohibited from accessing U.S. users, Polymarket became the representative platform culturally for this election. Election-related markets accumulated trading volume of about $3.6 billion, with accuracy in judging Trump's victory probability exceeding polls and expert commentary. This explosion pushed prediction markets into the global spotlight.

One week after the election ended, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) raided Coplan's apartment, investigating whether the platform had U.S. users bypassing the 2022 ban to trade on the international version of the website. In July 2025, the U.S. Department of Justice and CFTC concluded the investigation without filing any charges. A few days later, Polymarket spent $112 million to acquire QCEX, an exchange holding a CFTC license. In October of the same year, the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), parent company of the New York Stock Exchange, agreed to invest up to $2 billion in Polymarket, with a pre-investment valuation of $8 billion; ICE simultaneously became the global distributor of Polymarket event data. Relying on the acquisition of QCEX, Polymarket re-entered the U.S. market in December 2025.

After the election hype faded, sports and international geopolitical events drove continued platform growth. As of July 2026, Polymarket completed a cumulative 707.7 million transactions, with total trading volume exceeding $111.9 billion. In 2024, it was undoubtedly the industry leader, but was later surpassed by Kalshi.

Kalshi

Kalshi made a diametrically opposite choice from the very beginning. Founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara are both MIT graduates (Lara was formerly a professional ballet dancer, performed in "Swan Lake", before switching to the financial market), founding the company in 2018. They bet that: adhering to compliance from the start was more important than development speed.

Kalshi Co-founders Tarek Mansour, Luana Lopes Lara, Source: Forbes

The two founders waited nearly two years to get launch approval. In November 2020, the CFTC approved Kalshi as a Designated Contract Market, the first exchange in the U.S. to receive federal regulatory permission to list event contract derivatives. This license constitutes Kalshi's core legal basis; federal law priority is higher than state gambling-related laws. Kalshi officially launched in July 2021.

But obtaining the license also brought a series of troubles. The process for listing new hot events on the platform was slow, and strict KYC requirements further dragged down growth. The heaviest blow was: the platform applied to open 2024 U.S. presidential election markets, which was rejected by the CFTC. Facing the biggest catalyst in industry history, Kalshi could not participate.

Kalshi filed a lawsuit and won. In September 2024, a federal judge ruled that the CFTC exceeded its authority, election-related contracts were neither illegal nor belonged to gambling. With only 32 days left until the election vote, Kalshi reopened election trading. This delay, coupled with strict KYC leading to a lack of international users, caused it to lose to Polymarket in user mindshare and market share. Kalshi's election-related trading volume was only about $500 million, while Polymarket reached $3.6 billion.

After the election ended, investments in compliance began to pay off. Robinhood collaborated with Kalshi to launch the first prediction market product; Bloomberg Terminal directly accessed Kalshi's data. The basis for these two collaborations was precisely Kalshi's regulatory qualifications.

In 2025-2026, Kalshi vigorously expanded tracks beyond politics. Sports became the largest category, with breakout marketing playing a big role. The slogan "Knicks sweep in four games" appearing in street interviews during the NBA Finals had related clips reaching tens of millions of views. The team leveraged the World Cup for marketing, placing ads featuring Timothée Chalamet, Lionel Messi, and Luka Dončić. During the World Cup, the platform's 3 million users created $27 billion in trading volume.

As of July 2026, Kalshi completed a cumulative 982.6 million transactions, with total trading volume of $155.7 billion, surpassing Polymarket in scale to become the new industry leader.

Channels Fully Rolled Out

The success of the two head platforms drove a large number of exchanges and brokerages to launch their own prediction market businesses. Many companies adopted a fast-launch strategy, testing market demand by integrating existing platforms into their own applications.

Coinbase and Interactive Brokers took a different path, adopting an aggregation model, pooling liquidity and markets from multiple platforms. CME Group built its own products from scratch. Robinhood adopted a systematic path, first routing orders to Kalshi, and after demand was validated, built its own underlying system, launching the CFTC-regulated exchange Rothera in June 2026. This bet quickly paid off; Robinhood's event contract business revenue in Q2 2026 was $156 million, a year-over-year increase of over 10 times, already exceeding the $100 million revenue from crypto trading business.

Have the Structural Problems Been Solved?

Kalshi and Polymarket solved execution-level failures: regulatory strategy, low fees, product experience oriented towards ordinary consumers. But whether they cracked the deep demand problems proposed by Whitaker and Mazlish is another matter.

  • Gamblers: Partially solved, but far from achieving "predict everything". Sports themes naturally fit prediction markets; the core problem is just whether they can grab trading volume from traditional sports betting, and they have achieved this. Year-to-date, most trading volume comes from sports. Parlay betting is an important growth driver: when launched on Kalshi in September 2025 it accounted for only 3% of total trading volume, by July 2026 it had climbed to 38%. Closely following is cryptocurrency price prediction. Political themes are no longer limited to elections; military and geopolitical conflict market trading volume was $2.76 billion, slightly higher than the U.S. election market's $2.73 billion. Adding overseas elections, the broad political track scale continues to rise. Culture markets (music, film, celebrities) scale continues to grow. Economic themes like Fed rate decisions and inflation also have volume. Trading volume in multiple tracks is rising. Although still far from the grand vision of "all themes can form active markets", substantial progress has been made in the past 12 months.
  • Professional Traders: Partially solved through incentives. Professional traders need sufficient trading volume, and counterparties other than other professional traders. The scale of the sports market at $120 billion and crypto market at $22 billion can already satisfy this. Susquehanna accessed Kalshi as a market maker in 2024; subsequently formed a prediction market joint venture with Robinhood. Jump Trading made equity investments in both platforms in exchange for providing liquidity; Citadel is also evaluating the possibility of entering.
  • Savers: Problem remains unsolved. Prediction markets remain zero-sum games; funds invested in gambling give up returns that could be obtained from investing in Treasury bonds or elsewhere.

The Next Era of Prediction Markets

In the next stage, prediction markets will evolve from niche platforms into infrastructure for pricing global information. New markets will also spawn entirely new mechanisms.

Customized Hedging

Enterprises can hedge special risks not covered by traditional finance and insurance. For example, an ice cream shop can hedge against lower-than-average summer temperatures. Such demand could not be met in the past; traditional insurance companies would not undertake it because niche targets are hard to underwrite profitably.

Breaking the $0-$1 Binary Pricing Model

Perpetual Markets: Continuous trading markets for arbitrary events. Taking inflation as an example: binary markets can only bet on fixed results, e.g., "Will inflation be higher than 3.1%?". Perpetual markets allow going long or short on the inflation rate itself.

Combination Markets and Idea Governance: No longer pricing only single events, but pricing the correlation between two events. For example, "If Elon Musk resigns, what will Tesla's stock price be?", "If the U.S. launches an invasion, where will oil prices go?". Multiple markets price individual variables separately, allowing for more precise asset value assessment. Idea Governance goes further, using conditional markets to assist governance and policy decisions: implementing policies that market predictions indicate will bring better results.

AI Agents Acting as Truth Diggers

Future markets will run a large number of AI agents, completing research and trading around the clock. Such agents can act as automated truth detectors, scanning Telegram communities, social media, digging for factual basis faster than human commentators, trading against mispricing, further improving prediction market accuracy.

Media's Data Underlayer

Deep News Integration: Cooperation with CNN, CNBC heralds a deeper symbiotic relationship with traditional media. Media reporting will no longer focus only on facts that have already happened, simultaneously covering what will happen in the future.

Long-tail Theme Expansion: Markets expand to long-tail fields, pricing community local events, niche culture trends, such as tech industry layoffs, Taylor Swift album performance. But to ignite demand, user habits need to change; users not only read news but also participate in betting on outcomes.

Solving the Problem of Missing Savers

Yield-Bearing Collateral: Traders no longer pledge idle USDC; they can use yield-bearing assets, such as sUSDe, tokenized U.S. Treasuries as margin. Ethena's sUSDe alone achieved annualized yields of 4% to 30% over the past two years by capturing perpetual funding rates, and can already be used as collateral accessing platforms like Aave, Pendle, and Morpho. If prediction markets support similar collateral, savers' capital continues to earn returns while serving as position collateral, instead of being completely idle before event settlement.

Modular Combination of Finance and DeFi: Structured products can be built on top of prediction markets, either packaged with other assets or used as collateral for lending. When event contracts can be packaged with yield-bearing assets, or used for collateralized lending, then zero-sum gaming is no longer the sole return for that capital.