
The SEC Is Cracking Down: Who Can Handle "Compliant ICOs"?
Written by: Meng Yan
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently announced an exemption for tokenized equity trading. For teams developing exchanges, particularly RWA trading platforms, this is undoubtedly a noteworthy development. However, the gap between “operating in this sector” and “qualifying for this exemption” may be far greater than perceived. Does possessing an existing trading system and an RWA business automatically grant eligibility?
For the Chinese-speaking Crypto community, the most significant implication of this move likely lies not in how many teams can directly participate, but in what it signals about the SEC’s stance: with congressional legislation temporarily stalled, the SEC has no intention of sitting idle. This signal also makes the public fundraising rule currently under progress even more noteworthy: its potential acceleration into implementation and the resulting changes it could bring to projects and retail investors deserve close attention.
I. TSV Has Nothing to Do With You
TSV stands for Tokenized Securities Venue. The SEC’s order released on September 17, 2026, provides a temporary exemption from the definition of an “exchange” under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 for qualifying venues of this type, along with an exemption from the definition of a “broker-dealer” for certain liquidity providers, valid for five years. It permits qualified participants to trade tokenized U.S. National Market System stocks (Tokenized NMS Stock) through automated market makers (AMMs) and liquidity pools.
This indeed opens a narrow door for trading platforms, but it does not hand out a passkey to all Crypto exchanges, let alone all RWA platforms. Even if you already have users, a trading system, and on-chain assets, the following hurdles do not disappear because of this exemption.
First, what asset are you actually trading? The core target of TSV is defined tokenized NMS stocks, not all assets labeled as RWA. Products such as real estate shares and private credit cannot simply rely on “real-world assets on-chain” to apply this exemption; even when related to U.S. equities, tokens issued by third parties that only provide synthetic exposure to stock prices do not fall within the definition of Tokenized NMS Stock here. Holders must be granted the same rights as comparable traditional stocks, including dividends, voting, and residual claims upon liquidation. Allowing a token’s price to track U.S. stocks and actually implementing full shareholder rights are two different capabilities. Platforms must verify these rights instead of merely trusting marketing claims of “asset backing.”
Second, possessing a token does not mean you can list it at will. If the stock is tokenized by a third party unrelated to the underlying issuer, the venue must provide prior written notice to the underlying issuer and wait at least thirty calendar days after receiving the notice; if the issuer objects within the specified period, the tokenized stock cannot be listed on that venue. For platforms eager to rapidly expand their offerings, this means product design, rights verification, and communication with underlying issuers must all be handled; the old approach of picking a trending asset, tokenizing it, and listing it immediately will not work.
Third, existing trading systems may not be supported under this exemption. TSVs must adopt AMM liquidity pools to facilitate trading for permitted participants and implement access criteria; relevant smart contracts must be publicly disclosed and auditable, deployed on open, permissionless distributed ledgers. While the public chain itself can be permissionless, the trading gateway is not open to anyone who simply connects a wallet. Platforms must disclose the procedures for permitting participants and wallets, screening methods, and applicable sanctions compliance arrangements. Therefore, legacy order-book trading systems cannot directly replace the AMM model here, nor can an open pool without participant access controls be simply copied over.
Fourth, establishing a U.S. entity is just the beginning; continuous regulatory oversight follows. A TSV must qualify as a U.S. person under the order’s definition; entities established under U.S. law constitute one such scenario, so overseas teams can explore satisfying this condition through a U.S. entity, but holding an offshore entity does not automatically meet the requirement. More importantly, platforms must comply with applicable U.S. sanctions requirements, maintain trading and compliance records in the United States, retain these records for the duration of the exemption plus three years afterward, and consent to SEC staff examinations at any time. If relevant entities or personnel fall under statutory disqualification categories, they must still satisfy the order’s conditional exceptions to rely on the exemption. Registration procedures can be arranged, but the capacity to maintain records, conduct screenings, and continuously respond to regulators must be built into actual operations.
Fifth, exemption from exchange registration does not mean exemption from daily compliance. At least thirty calendar days before commencing operations, the platform must publish the required public notice on its website and formally notify the SEC in writing within one business day of publication, followed by updates as required. Trading data from the preceding thirty days must be freely published in machine-readable, USD-denominated formats, updated within ten minutes of each trade; if an underlying stock is halted on its primary listing exchange, the corresponding tokenized stock must be halted simultaneously. The venue is prohibited from extending credit to participants for purchasing these stocks, or facilitating borrowing, pledging, or arranging pledges of securities and non-securities crypto assets within the venue.
If liquidity providers separately rely on the accompanying broker-dealer exemption, their relevant securities business must be limited to prescribed TSV pool trading and conducted on a principal account basis; they may not hold or custody client assets. A team wishing to bundle trading, leverage, client assets, and market-making operations into this single exemption would need to thoroughly restructure its business model.
Sixth, even after clearing the thresholds, platforms cannot be planned for infinite expansion. The order sets two-tier limits based on U.S. market volatility control plans for securities: Tier 1 caps at seventy-five trading symbols, with a volume limit of 0.25% per security; Tier 2 caps at two hundred fifty symbols, with a limit of 2.5%. These percentages compare the average daily number of shares traded for the respective tokenized stock on the venue against the market’s average daily share volume of the underlying stock in the previous month; associated TSV trading volumes and symbol counts must be aggregated. These represent scale ceilings, not minimum capital thresholds, yet they constrain the business capacity a platform can handle. Attempting to bypass these limits by launching multiple affiliated platforms will not work either.
Viewing these requirements collectively, the difficulties are clear: teams must simultaneously address securities rights, underlying issuer communication, AMM and participant access, recordkeeping and operations under U.S. regulation, and business structuring within constrained scales. Having an existing exchange, or even already working on RWA, does not equate to possessing these capabilities.
Considering the industry’s actual preparedness, most overseas Chinese entrepreneurial teams will find it difficult to directly fit existing platforms into this framework right now; genuine participation often requires adjusting asset structures, trading systems, and compliance operations. The challenges stem from the gap between these specific conditions and current businesses, not the founders’ ethnic background. Saying “TSV has nothing to do with you” specifically targets unrealistic expectations of treating a limited exemption as a direct business windfall.
However, being unable to directly utilize it does not mean ignoring it. The policy signal from TSV may well be more important than the number of platforms it can directly benefit.
II. CLARITY Stalled, But SEC Takes Real Action
Just two days before this order was issued, on September 15, the U.S. Senate failed to pass a procedural vote advancing the CLARITY Act for deliberation. Following this, SEC Chair Paul Atkins, in his statement introducing the exemption, directly noted Congress’s failure to advance CLARITY and explained that the SEC will continue acting using existing statutory authority.
Interpreting the setback of the CLARITY Act as a full halt to the entire Crypto regulatory reform agenda clearly fails to explain this recent action. Congress has its legislative timetable, and the SEC possesses authority granted by existing laws; the former’s temporary blockage does not mean the latter must simply sit idle. The significance of TSV lies in the SEC transforming this stance into concrete action.
Therefore, “waiting for CLARITY to pass first,” when applied to other rules currently progressing, may not reflect prudence but rather conflating two distinct processes. Among them, the fundraising proposal, which has already entered the public comment phase, deserves the closest attention. It directly addresses how Crypto projects issue and raise capital, impacting projects and retail participants far more broadly than a mere stock trading arrangement.
III. Is There a Path for a “Compliant ICO”? Does Your Project Qualify?
RCA stands for Regulation Crypto Assets. This is a proposed rule by the SEC, put forward in August 2026, currently under public comment with a deadline of October 20. Though not yet effective, it proposes two types of securities registration exemptions, attempting to provide a compliant path for Crypto project Token fundraising under certain conditions.
Such arrangements are necessary because whether a Token itself constitutes a security is not the same question as whether the fundraising surrounding it is subject to securities laws. For example, if a team sells Tokens while promising network development and product construction, and investors contribute funds expecting returns derived from these efforts, then even if the Token itself is not a security, the overall fundraising arrangement may still constitute an “investment contract.” The two registration exemptions in RCA target precisely such qualifying arrangements: the underlying Token is not itself a security, and the contract does not involve assets other than that Token. Issuers relying on these exemptions for fundraising must still fulfill corresponding disclosure obligations and bear ongoing anti-fraud liabilities.
For the community, the most significant aspect of these two exemptions is that both permit retail investor participation—meaning investors who do not hold accredited investor status under U.S. securities law. Projects can thus raise capital from the public via Token issuance, provided they meet the conditions, without restricting participation solely to institutions and high-net-worth individuals. In this sense, RCA offers a conditional path toward a “compliant ICO.”
If this path materializes, end-users will have the opportunity to fund early project development while bearing investment risks; teams securing these funds must, in turn, disclose information to participants and provide continuous updates on their activities. Projects seeking ordinary users’ money must clearly outline corresponding commitments and responsibilities.
Rules permitting public participation and your project already qualifying to raise from the public are two different things. The two exemptions differ markedly in terms of eligible entities, monetary thresholds, and obligation fulfillment methods; these distinctions directly determine whether a project can actually use them and how much preparation is required.
Regarding eligible entities, the distinction from investor geography must come first. Neither current rule uniformly restricts investors to U.S. citizens or residents, nor categorically excludes foreign individuals or institutions; the stricter U.S.-connection requirements discussed below apply to the Fundraising issuer. Foreign participants should therefore understand these rules, but when issuing or investing, they must still comply with applicable local and distribution channel regulations, since RCA addresses U.S. securities registration obligations and does not supersede laws elsewhere.
1. Startup: Small-scale launch, flexible entity requirements
The Startup exemption allows issuers utilizing this path to be entities, individuals, or teams composed of individuals or entities; it does not require prior company formation, nor does it impose the U.S. registration, personnel, asset, and principal management location conditions required for Fundraising. Therefore, even projects without a U.S. company still need to evaluate the applicability of the Startup exemption. Of course, if applying jointly as a team, all members must sign declarations and certifications as required and assume corresponding liabilities.
While entity requirements are relatively flexible, fundraising scales face stricter constraints: this path permits public solicitation and sales to retail investors. The current proposal does not set individual investment caps, but total raised amounts cannot exceed $5 million over any four-year period. This cap is not recalculated annually; issuers and their affiliates cannot repeatedly restart new four-year cycles around the same or substantially similar Tokens.
Moreover, calculating this $5 million threshold involves more than just tracking cash deposited into bank accounts. Non-cash consideration for transactions relying on this exemption must be valued according to regulations; certain Token distributions for development, testing, or network incentives may also count toward it. For projects with multiple Token distribution mechanisms already in place, mapping out all arrangements is necessary to determine if they fall within the limit.
Before commencing with Startup, issuers must file a Form NOR via the SEC’s electronic filing system EDGAR, declaring reliance on this exemption, and make the required information freely available on their website at or before submission. Unlike Fundraising, it does not require prior qualification review for a prospectus, nor does it mandate audited financial statements; however, disclosures must still cover: development plans, team composition and conflicts of interest, project commitments and progress, Token allocation and economic mechanisms, governance, and risks.
These disclosures tie directly into subsequent performance liabilities. In the Form NOR, issuers must certify their intent to complete key management tasks promised to investors within four years, followed by periodic updates as required, and a transition report no later than the expiration of the four-year term. Thus, at the outset of fundraising, teams must be able to articulate what they promise to accomplish, who is responsible, how Tokens are allocated, and how progress will be reported to participants over time. Whitepapers, social media claims, and official filings cannot tell contradictory stories.
2. Fundraising: Is registering a U.S. company enough?
If a project seeks larger-scale capital, it must further consider the Fundraising exemption. This path divides into two tiers: Tier 1 allows up to $20 million in any twelve-month period, while Tier 2 allows up to $75 million. Projects may apply directly or initially use Startup before transitioning, but both paths require meeting distinct conditions, and related issuances must adhere to aggregated calculation rules; quotas cannot be simply added together.
As thresholds increase, entity requirements tighten significantly. Fundraising mandates that the issuer be an entity established under U.S. law, simultaneously satisfying three substantive criteria: a majority of executives or directors must be U.S. citizens or residents, over 50% of assets must be located in the U.S., and principal business management must occur in the U.S. These conditions apply to both Tier 1 and Tier 2, so merely registering a U.S. entity while keeping personnel, assets, and actual operations entirely elsewhere fails to meet requirements. For projects headquartered in other jurisdictions, evaluation may focus on organizational restructuring and operational realignment rather than just administrative registration.
Even if entity criteria are met, business type must fall within permissible scope. Development-stage companies lacking specific business plans or purposes, planning mergers/acquisitions of undetermined targets, as well as prescribed investment companies and business development companies, are ineligible for issuance under this route. Additionally, both Startup and Fundraising remain subject to general applicability conditions and statutory disqualification clauses.
After qualifying for issuance, projects can raise funds from the public, including retail investors. However, unlike Startup’s lack of individual caps, both Fundraising tiers require retail natural persons to limit purchases to no more than 10% of the higher of their annual income or net worth; non-natural persons lacking accredited status calculate this based on 10% of the higher value from their most recent completed fiscal year. Retail participation is allowed, but contribution amounts are strictly capped, and this limit applies across both tiers, not just Tier 2.
Before formal sales commence, issuers must submit a Form 1-CRYPTO prospectus via EDGAR and obtain SEC qualification. Although rules allow preliminary interest solicitation (“testing the waters”) to gauge market reaction, soliciting interest differs fundamentally from accepting payments; submitting documents does not authorize immediate investment collection.
To complete such filings, both tiers require financial disclosure and accompanying financial statements, typically covering the prior two fiscal years; shorter-lived projects adjust accordingly to their applicable operating duration. A key distinction lies in auditing: Tier 1 does not mandate audits but requires submission of any audit reports obtained per regulatory standards, whereas Tier 2 requires formal audits. Consequently, tier selection depends not only on capital needs but also on whether existing financial documentation supports the chosen level.
Post-collection compliance continues relentlessly. Both tiers demand ongoing annual, semiannual, and ad hoc reports for material events; annual reports generally due within 120 days post-fiscal year-end, semiannual within 90 days post-period-end, and material events reported within four business days of occurrence. Since obligations extend beyond fundraising, projects require dedicated personnel to manage accounts, documentation, and disclosures continuously—this cannot be treated as a one-time administrative checkbox.
3. Secondary Sales and Contractual Exit Mechanisms
Post-fundraising, participants naturally query secondary sale mechanics. Investment contracts issued under either exemption do not classify as “restricted securities” under this federal framework, nor does this exemption uniformly mandate post-purchase lockup periods. However, specific contractual terms and other applicable regulations may still impose restrictions; actual tradability hinges on meeting respective conditions, with no guarantee of exchange listings or liquidity provision.
Beyond post-purchase resale, Fundraising permits incorporating original holders’ sales into issuances, subject to specific caps: During initial offerings and subsequent qualified offerings within one year of initial qualification, original holder sales cannot exceed 30% of that issuance’s total proceeds. Thus, this 30% cap restricts original holders’ proportional participation in that specific issuance cycle, not implying retail investors are perpetually limited to selling only 30% of holdings in secondary markets. Associated holder sales included in such issuances carry additional twelve-month sub-limits: $6 million for Tier 1 and $22.5 million for Tier 2, deducted from respective total quotas.
Regarding post-completion or cessation of originally pledged work, RCA establishes a conditional safe harbor governing the relationship between Tokens and investment contracts. Once all critical management efforts previously committed to are fully completed or permanently ceased, no new related commitments are made or intended, and transition reports are filed, the underlying asset may detach from the investment contract under this safe harbor. Notably, Startup’s maximum four-year transition report deadline does not auto-satisfy these detachment conditions upon expiration.
IV. Optimistic Outlook: Implementation Within Three to Six Months
Taking September 2026 as the baseline, under optimal conditions, RCA could take effect within the next three to six months; even with minor delays, implementation before H1 2027 remains highly probable. By “implementation,” we mean the rule becomes active and relevant fundraising channels open.
This projection stems from observable policy trajectories; the SEC has not yet published an official timeline. Nevertheless, the formal proposal has entered public comment, and this recent transaction exemption demonstrates the SEC’s willingness to act despite congressional gridlock. Together, these factors justify optimism regarding near-term developments. Naturally, post-comment final rules require adoption, effective dating, and implementation logistics, making exact timelines uncertain.
V. Waiting for Rule Enactment to Rush Compliance? Cramming Now?
Based on routine industry engagement and observation, the Chinese-speaking Crypto community’s emphasis on and preparation for RCA are grossly insufficient. Many projects possess only superficial understanding, with very few having adequately structured their fundraising preparations.
Selecting Startup requires teams to clarify existing commitments, Token allocations, and liabilities, confirming capacity for public transparency and continuous updates; choosing Fundraising demands evaluating U.S. entity structures, personnel, assets, management conditions, historical accounting, audit readiness, and ongoing reporting capabilities. These preparations hinge on genuine business operations and daily workflows. Legal counsel can clarify rules and draft filings, but cannot fabricate legitimate management frameworks or comprehensive ledgers overnight. Leaving everything for future “lawyer-led compliance” merely postpones today’s necessary groundwork to tomorrow.
For investors and retail holders alike, hearing “compliant ICO” does not absolve personal due diligence to the SEC. Which exemption a project relies on, which commitments are publicly disclosed, Token allocation mechanics, intended fund utilization, and where progress updates will surface—all dictate actual risk exposure. SEC approval or successful filing guarantees neither product quality nor investment returns. Regulation provides conditional participation frameworks; investors must still independently assess what they are truly funding.
How RCA ultimately gets finalized depends on subsequent developments, yet analyzing prerequisites, organizing documentation, and identifying gaps can begin immediately. If our timeline assessment holds, the preparation window may span merely a few months.
When regulators delay openings, projects can rightly criticize policy inertia. Yet when pathways finally emerge, failing to rigorously study eligibility criteria risks missing historic opportunities.














