
Tether Secures Its Long-Awaited Big Four Audit After a Decade, But That’s Far from Resolved
Written by: Cas Piancey
Translated by: Chopper, Foresight News
Nearly a decade later, Tether has finally delivered the audit report it repeatedly promised, sending shockwaves through the crypto community.
Traders cheered while critics scoffed. While this audit is undoubtedly a step forward, it does not answer all the questions surrounding Tether.
Opportunities, Risks, and Unanswered Questions
To be clear, this formal audit represents a significant step up compared to Tether’s past quarterly attestation reports issued by BDO Italia.
An attestation report is merely a snapshot of the company’s finances at a specific point in time, whereas an audit resembles a continuous recording that captures the entire process.
Notably, this audit was conducted by KPMG US, one of the Big Four accounting firms and the most authoritative division within the KPMG network.
Of course, the Big Four were once part of the Big Eight, which serves as a reminder that even with impeccable industry reputations, large accounting firms can make mistakes—or even collapse because of them.
Many industry insiders have pointed out that KPMG’s current audit covers only Tether International, not its parent company Tether Holdings or iFinex.
iFinex is the parent holding entity that controls both Tether and the crypto exchange Bitfinex. While the public also hopes to see Bitfinex audited, this does not affect the audit conclusions regarding Tether itself.
Historically, Tether’s reserves have been used to cover funding shortfalls at Bitfinex, and the possibility of such events recurring—both currently and in the future—remains.
Tyler Menzer, Assistant Professor of Accounting at Texas Christian University, told Protos: Without access to the complete set of financial working papers submitted to KPMG, the reference value of this audit report is highly limited.
He added, "Since 2000, 99.93% of audit reports on the market have ultimately issued unqualified opinions."
Existing Issues
Even with KPMG’s audit, it does not mean Tether is more transparent than before the audit.
In the eyes of Tether’s management and some crypto industry insiders, this opacity is by design rather than a flaw.
The market still cannot discern the exact composition of its secured loans, what the "other investments" line item in its balance sheet actually entails, or why 13% of its reserves are held in highly volatile assets like precious metals and Bitcoin.
Roughly 25% of Tether’s balance sheet consists of non-cash and non-cash-equivalent assets. It is easy to envision a risk scenario where this stablecoin issuer becomes insolvent and unable to honor user withdrawals in the future.
Worryingly, since the New York Attorney General investigation, Tether’s proportion of cash and cash equivalents has fallen by over 10%.
For money market funds or other dollar-pegged products, such an asset structure would be considered a severe deficiency, making it entirely reasonable for the market to remain cautious about Tether’s reserve status.
Besides this, Tether using this audit as a marketing tool raises concerns. Such practices are rare and usually reserved for high-risk assets like penny stocks.
Before the establishment of the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), banks and quasi-financial institutions frequently relied on audit reports to win customer trust. In other words, the last time banks or shadow banks heavily leveraged audit results for credibility dates back to the 1930s.
Unresolved Doubts
KPMG’s 2025 annual audit report cannot clear up Tether’s past transgressions.
Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino and former General Counsel Stuart Hoegner previously made public commitments to complete audits for every year starting from 2018.
But Menzer stated that retroactively auditing those earlier years is "simply not feasible today."
To conduct historical audits, the audit firm would have needed to be engaged starting in 2018 and obtain complete, clear underlying records—all of which never happened.
Obviously, Tether has no incentive to revive memories of those past times marked by insufficient reserves and frequent crises. Revealing the truth from back then would do nothing to prove its reliability or corporate integrity, nor would it explain how it survived periods of de facto insolvency. Therefore, do not expect to see early audit reports from the company.
Past management claimed the audit could not be completed because the process was "dauntingly cumbersome." Although the reasons behind this shift remain unknown, some public details have emerged: for instance, Ardoino has been widely publicizing that auditors physically counted and verified every single gold bar held by Tether.
Yet this is simply standard procedure for an audit firm to issue an unqualified opinion and hardly constitutes an extra bonus.
A larger question remains: how did the auditors verify Tether’s holdings of Bitcoin and other crypto assets, and how much did this audit cost?
There is also another completely unexplained question: why did it take more than eight months for this audit to be released?
Under normal circumstances, accountants begin work at the end of the fiscal year and deliver the report in early spring of the following year.
While a lengthy timeline does not necessarily imply issues with the audit conclusions, it inevitably sparks speculation about the reasons for the delay.
Meanwhile, the entire industry is pondering a core question: what is the ultimate purpose of Tether going to such lengths to conduct this audit?
Drafting for a public offering requires consecutive full audits over multiple years, yet there are currently no signs that Tether plans an IPO or a reverse listing.
Furthermore, a crucial point: Tether utilized the AICPA (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants) standards for this audit, which cannot be used for corporate listing filings.
Listings must employ PCAOB (Public Company Accounting Oversight Board) standard audits.
Beyond simply pushing back against critics, it is difficult to identify other pragmatic motivations for Tether to go to such great lengths to complete this audit.
Future Outlook
So, what changes in information disclosure can the public expect from Tether in the future? Likely, there will not be many substantial changes.
Tether is no longer legally required to publish quarterly reserve reports, but it continues to release them voluntarily. However, these reserve reports themselves do not equate to high transparency.
Even with a Big Four audit, if the general public cannot access the underlying original documents submitted to KPMG, the report holds limited significance for ordinary individuals and cannot be directly used as a basis for trusting the enterprise.
One possibility is that if management decides to pursue a listing in the future, Tether will switch to PCAOB audit standards and use this AICPA audit as financial documentation for prior fiscal years.
It must be emphasized that until Tether and iFinex achieve information disclosure standards comparable to other mainstream financial institutions, the practical value of their audit reports will remain highly limited, and the public should not rely on them as a basis for trusting the institution.















