TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
a16z Advises SEC: Qualified DEXs Do Not Need to Register as Exchanges

a16z Advises SEC: Qualified DEXs Do Not Need to Register as Exchanges

2026.09.23
Share
a16z wants to establish a policy safe harbor for DEXs and DEX applications.

Written by: David Sverdlov, Miles Jennings, Scott Walker, Aiden Slavin

Translated by: Chopper, Foresight News

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) continues to advance "Project Crypto," with grand ambitions to facilitate the on-chain migration of U.S. capital markets.

In April this year, the SEC’s Division of Trading and Markets clarified that certain user interfaces may operate without registering as broker-dealers, provided specific conditions are met. In June, the SEC proposed repealing Rule 611 of Regulation National Market System (Regulation NMS), a move that will clear a major obstacle to the development of the on-chain securities market. Last week, the SEC issued an "Innovation Exemption Rule," exempting certain trading venues—Tokenized Securities Venues (TSVs)—from the definition of "exchange" under the Securities Exchange Act, while also removing some liquidity providers from the "dealer" category. This series of measures indicates that regulators recognize blockchain technology's potential to upgrade the financial system and that on-chain markets should not be forced into ill-fitting regulatory frameworks.

The SEC’s aforementioned actions warrant strong praise. However, clarifying broker-related rules and proposing the repeal of Rule 611 only address some of the regulatory uncertainties facing on-chain markets. The innovation exemption is likewise an important first step, but it provides merely an intermediated path for moving securities on-chain. As Commissioner Peirce stated in her accompanying statement regarding this exemption: “This order is not targeted at decentralized finance. Truly decentralized systems powered by automated software do not generate the core risks that securities regulation seeks to address.” We agree.

We recommend that, as the next step in advancing "Project Crypto," the SEC clarify under what circumstances Decentralized Exchange (DEX) protocols and application developers providing user access portals can be exempt from the exchange registration requirements under the Securities Exchange Act. For this reason, along with the DeFi Education Fund, we propose establishing a safe harbor rule to exempt these relevant parties from exchange registration obligations.

This safe harbor would provide developers with clear standards to determine when DEXs and DEX applications do not need to register, since they neither assume the role of traditional exchanges nor generate the various risks that exchange regulation aims to mitigate. From this perspective, this proposal translates Peirce’s broad viewpoint into the realm of exchange regulation: when automated systems do not generate the core risks that securities regulation fundamentally seeks to prevent, market participants require clearly defined regulatory boundaries rather than mere exemptions. This safe harbor will serve as a complementary extension to the innovation exemption, bringing regulatory clarity to truly permissionless systems.

Meanwhile, a16z has submitted a companion proposal addressing Centralized Trading Platforms (CTPs) that operate in a traditional intermediary capacity. We recommend establishing a customized registration framework modeled after Alternative Trading Systems (ATS), allowing CTPs to trade crypto asset securities, non-security crypto pairs, and hybrid security/non-security pairs.

Together, these two proposals draw clear regulatory red lines: DEXs and DEX applications meeting the safe harbor criteria will be explicitly exempt from exchange registration, while other platforms will have a tailored registration pathway suited to their business models. We also look forward to participating in the comment period for this innovation exemption.

Where Is the Problem?

The rationale behind our broker-safe harbor proposal similarly applies to this current submission. DEX applications are typically embedded within wallets or deployed on web pages; they are software suites that enable users to interact with decentralized blockchain systems. These platforms do not custody assets nor act on behalf of users. Instead, they provide user interfaces that help users execute transactions directly on-chain. This opens up vast possibilities for peer-to-peer trading: users can pay with stablecoins, purchase network tokens on decentralized exchanges, or engage in lending activities, all without relying on any intermediaries.

DEXs are predominantly permissionless smart contract protocols that automatically execute trades based on predefined conditions. The most common type, Automated Market Maker (AMM) DEXs, allows users to trade against liquidity pools without a centralized operator. It is precisely the oversight by centralized operators that generates the risks exchange regulation aims to address, such as conflicts of interest in order matching, the potential for market manipulation by centralized operators, and the necessity of governance and fair access rules when centralized entities hold market power.

Currently, DEXs and DEX applications still face regulatory uncertainty regarding exchange registration. The SEC has indicated its stance in at least one Wells Notice: if a DEX or DEX application supports the trading of security-like assets, it may be deemed an exchange. This regulatory approach is flawed and stifles innovation in one of the most promising areas of this emerging digital financial ecosystem.

The considerations that drove us to draft the broker-safe harbor proposal equally drive this submission: requiring all DEXs and DEX applications to register as exchanges would force software developers into roles they never intended to assume, acting as gatekeepers and trading intermediaries. This would undermine the inherent advantages of blockchain systems and introduce new risks for users.

Below, we will also discuss our companion proposal for traditional intermediary-style Crypto Asset Trading Platforms (CTPs). The pain points here are glaring: currently, there is no regulated market in the United States where tokenized securities can be traded, whether these securities constitute investment contracts, or involve combinations of Regulation NMS stocks with other tokenized securities or commodities. Concurrently, centralized crypto exchanges are prohibited from facilitating these trading pairs. Our proposal fills this void by creating a registration framework tailored to a crypto market still in its early stages.

What Is the Solution?

We propose establishing a safe harbor that creates a rebuttable presumption: DEXs and DEX applications supporting peer-to-peer trading (including tokenized securities) fall outside the scope of exchange business. While this submission primarily focuses on AMM-based DEXs, the framework is not limited to a specific architecture; we also endorse Commissioner Peirce’s openness to other tokenized securities trading models.

To qualify for this safe harbor, DEXs must meet four objective standards:

  • Custody-free: DEXs never control user funds. All signing and transaction submission operations are initiated by the user.
  • Automated: DEX execution of trades and related operations lacks human intermediation; no individual or group under joint control possesses the authority to unilaterally modify the system’s functionality, operational logic, or rules.
  • Permissionless: DEXs do not restrict access rights, nor do they grant anyone the power to restrict others’ access.
  • Fairness and neutrality: No private privileges, hardcoded special rights, or differential treatment are granted to anyone, preventing the platform from discriminating against specific users or use cases.

DEX applications must also satisfy four objective standards:

  • Custody-free: DEX applications must not control user funds. As above, all signing and transaction submissions are initiated by the user.
  • Objective and verifiable market data: DEX application pricing and market data must be based on pre-disclosed, objective, and independently verifiable parameters; data sources must be public on-chain data or independent third-party data feeds.
  • No discretion: Throughout the operation of DEX applications, no centralized entity, governance body, or developer exercises discretion in trade matching, pricing, order matching, or trade execution to favor specific users, counterparties, or transactions.
  • Limited developer role: DEX application developers are restricted to maintaining the interface, pushing technical and security updates, and applying objective, non-discretionary screening rules to remove digital assets; screening criteria must be public and neutral, free from subjective investment judgments or qualitative assessments of asset value (though identifying fraudulent, malicious, or spam assets does not constitute asset value assessment).

Additionally, the companion proposal for Crypto Asset Trading Platforms stipulates that CTP regulation will reference the Alternative Trading System (ATS) framework, allowing platforms to register with the SEC and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) to support trading in crypto asset securities, non-security pairs, and security/non-security hybrid pairs. When CTP trades involve Regulation NMS equity-category crypto asset securities and trading volume exceeds a threshold, public disclosure under Form ATS-N is required. When trading volume falls below the threshold, the CTP confidentially submits disclosure materials to the SEC and subscribed users (disclosing conflicts of interest, core operational mechanisms, and details regarding fair access), with the corresponding ATS-equivalent form for the CTP kept off-public. Finally, CTPs must comply with recordkeeping requirements similar to those for ATSs, with the allowance for blockchain-based records.

Why Propose Now?

Blockchain technology holds immense value, capable of reducing costs, enabling rapid settlement, and expanding access to financial services, with DEXs and DEX applications being key to realizing these benefits. Centralized markets for tokenized securities also require an adaptive regulatory infrastructure. Much like the mechanism recently implemented by the SEC through the Innovation Exemption Rule, the CTP registration system will enable tokenized securities to be traded within regulated markets.

Congress has already missed its legislative window. Regulators should drive industry growth through guidance, exemptive orders, and standard rulemaking, and must wield these tools decisively. Our proposal offers a clear, viable path to define regulatory boundaries and support the responsible development of decentralized systems and crypto asset trading platforms in the United States.