TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Raoul Pal: The endgame of tokenization isn't stocks on-chain, but "everything can be priced"

Raoul Pal: The endgame of tokenization isn't stocks on-chain, but "everything can be priced"

2026.09.23
Share
Identity, contracts, attention, computing power, energy... everything can be tokenized.

Author: Raoul Pal (Founder of Global Macro Investor, Co-founder of Real Vision)

Compiled by: TechFlow

TechFlow Summary: In 2014, Raoul Pal first heard the concept of using blockchain as an "ownership ledger" at a closed-door seminar in the Cayman Islands, and predicted it would be the greatest technological shift since the internet. Twelve years later, this prophecy has a shorter name: "Everything Will Become a Token." But in his view, the real story is far bigger than merely "trading Apple stock on weekends and settling 7x24 hours": when the most active participants in the economy are no longer humans, but machines, tokens become information carriers that machines can read, verify, price, and trade—identity, contracts, attention, compute power, energy... everything can be tokenized.

The Right Idea, The Wrong Chain

In May 2014, I had just moved to the Cayman Islands and thought the best way to "bless" my new home would be to invite over twenty GMI (Global Macro Investor) members to Great Cayman for what would later become our inaugural "Roundtable." It was two days of intense intellectual exchange, packed with grand ideas. We discussed RMB devaluation, the impending El Niño, and listened to a speech by someone in the gold custody business: he proudly said the system was designed for, and by, "paranoid macro investors." It was quite a weekend.

Later, several long-term members stood up; they had previously invested in a small Bitcoin exchange in Singapore. By the time they sat down, they had completely overturned everyone's understanding in the room, including mine. As we left the venue, I was convinced that what I had just heard was the greatest technological shift since the invention of the internet, and I publicly wrote about it.

I expected them to pitch payments or "digital gold," but instead, they stripped away the monetary shell and explained the essence of blockchain perfectly: a ledger. A ledger where you can write anything you want, held by no one and tamper-proof. I remember sitting there mentally calculating what that meant, and back at my desk, I wrote the following to my subscribers:

"Once you realize that anything can be recorded as long as it's anchored to Bitcoin, you gain a timestamped, decentralized proof of ownership over everything. Imagine a world where every insurance contract, derivatives contract, real estate transaction, property title, purchase receipt, etc., can be stored in a decentralized manner. Bitcoin can tag, record, and verify the ownership of every stock, bond, security, and every derivatives contract."

I called it the "world's ownership ledger" and said it would replace the dark, undercapitalized, repeatedly rehypothecated custodial system I then referred to, which sat at the rotten core of finance (I am qualified to say this, as my entire career was spent inside that system, knowing how decrepit it was). It felt grand and brand new, and at the end of the article, I wrote a phrase that I would cite repeatedly for years afterward: "Bitcoin. I get it. Do you?"

Twelve years later, this thesis got a shorter name: everything will become a token.

Honestly, our logic was right, but we picked the wrong chain. This didn't happen on Bitcoin: Bitcoin ultimately excelled at only one thing (a currency that no one can devalue, and it has stayed in its own lane ever since). The vision of a "ledger for everything" migrated to chains born for programmable contracts, where a single token can simultaneously carry logic and ownership—and that's exactly where the rest of the story unfolds.

But in the years that followed, almost nothing happened.

None of those exciting items on my 2014 list made progress because nobody tokenized real estate, insurance contracts remained buried in filing cabinets, and the few real estate tokens actually issued mostly just sat there quietly.

The first thing to move was precisely what no one bothered to get excited about: the US dollar. A pure digital dollar on-chain, redeemable one-to-one, held by anyone on Earth at any moment and transferred for less than a cent. When I wrote this piece, the on-chain supply of such assets was approximately $300 billion.

Where We Stand Today

After the dollar came the next simplest thing: sovereign debt. And this is where the story stops being just a crypto tale.

As of September 20, the scale of tokenized US Treasury funds was approximately $14.8 billion. Look at who is issuing them: BlackRock, Franklin Templeton, JPMorgan, Fidelity, Invesco, WisdomTree, State Street, VanEck.

Stocks followed soon after. In June 2025, both Robinhood and Kraken launched 24/7 tokenized US equity trading; Robinhood also enabled European clients to hold tokens tracking private companies, including SpaceX and OpenAI. Nine months later, regulators caught up with the market. In March, the SEC approved Nasdaq's rules allowing securities to be traded in tokenized form, with tokens minted by the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC); NYSE's own rules were approved a month later. Nasdaq plans to run 23-hour trading sessions starting December 6. Stripe's incubated proprietary blockchain, Tempo, built specifically for stablecoin settlement, counts Visa, Mastercard, Shopify, Klarna, and UBS among its partners.

This is the real "Real World Assets (RWA) wave," and it deserves the hype. Think about what it means for finance: markets that never close. Settlement shifts from days to seconds. Assets come with embedded rules, so bonds pay coupons automatically and funds rebalance themselves. A twenty-year-old Indian youth who once had no channel to buy Apple stock can now own a fraction with just a smartphone. Every company can reach every saver on Earth, and every saver can access the world's finest companies. For a country (almost all countries) burdened with massive maturing debt, this is strategic.

And this is only the beginning. That $14.8 billion in tokenized Treasuries faces a $31 trillion outstanding national debt stockpile, representing less than five-thousandths. All tokenized assets excluding stablecoins add up to slightly over $30 billion. The largest balance sheets on the planet have already decided that this is the direction of the financial system, and so far they've taken only a step that rounds down to zero.

Your Imagination Is Too Limited...

But most people's imagination stops at the market. Faster settlement, longer trading hours, lower barriers. Treating tokenization as an upgrade to financial pipelines. That's how the industry uses the term, and precisely because of that, the whole thing gets categorized under "Real World Assets," as if the interesting question were merely "what existing asset will be packaged next?"

That mindset is too small. Trading Apple stock on weekends is fine, but it isn't why the "ledger for everything" exists.

What Exactly Is a Token?

Let's go back to what I witnessed in the Caymans. Blockchain records everything, so the key question is what exactly this "everything" entails, which means we must ask what a token truly is.

A token is a piece of information that machines can read, verify, price, and trade without needing to ask a human. It happens to be a great container for dollars or stocks, so dollars and stocks went in first. But it's merely a container; containers don't care what's inside them.

Throughout human history, we have only quantified value across a narrow set of things: money, and our claims on future money: namely, securities. Our systems were built to record and trade these because this is what humans value in forms measurable by other humans. So when a new ledger appeared, we put money and securities on it. Of course we did.

We are now building an economy where the most active participants are not humans. This is the core of my "Age of Exponents" framework, which I've written about here before and will include in my forthcoming book (releasing November 3, now open for pre-order). The world's financial system has a human interface, and these new participants are not human. I expect agents to double the user base of the internet, crypto, and AI itself within five years. Billions of new residents are arriving simultaneously, and they cannot use anything we've built.

An agent won't value money and securities the way you do. What agents need is information: who you are, whether you're permitted to do this, what it costs right now, who owns that thing, and whether it's true. In a machine economy, information is value, and money is just one of thousands of types of information.

Everything Means Everything

It starts with identity, because everything else depends on it. Everyone and every agent in this economy needs a machine-verifiable credential. For humans, the first problem is proving you are human. AI can now browse, buy, swipe, and sign; every business built on the "click equals yourself" assumption is discovering that assumption has failed. The answer is a "Proof of Personhood" you hold as a token, built on zero-knowledge proofs: allowing you to prove something about yourself without revealing the underlying information. Thus, you can prove you're over eighteen without disclosing your birthday, or prove you passed KYC without handing over your passport. It has entered mainstream products: World (whose team was on my podcast last summer) has verified approximately 18 million human users by this spring, integrating with Zoom, DocuSign, and Tinder.

Agents need the exact same thing from their side. Each agent must prove: who is executing this economic action, for whom, and under what authority. Multiply this scale of billions of agents making thousands of calls per hour, and the identity layer alone becomes an staggering magnitude. Identity is the key that unlocks everything that follows, and also one of the least discussed markets I know of.

Then comes contracts: the item on my 2014 list that finally materialized. A ticket is a contract between you and the venue. A booking is a contract with a hotel. An insurance policy, a warranty, a car maintenance log, permission to enter a building or read a file—all are contracts. Each is a commitment attached to an identity, and a token is simply a commitment attached to an identity that a machine can verify in milliseconds. Real estate will eventually land here too, once every registry on Earth agrees on "what exactly constitutes a deed."

Then comes attention, where it's entirely no longer about finance. In a world where machines can generate infinite content, human attention is the only remaining scarce resource, meaning it is the only thing that still holds value. Today, you "rent" your audience from platforms; platforms set the rules and take the revenue. Tokens allow creators, musicians, and communities to own the networks they build rather than renting them from platforms. And it goes beyond just creators. What you watch, what you know, the data your body produces: every form of human attention can become a token you own and profit from. People have calculated the math of "splitting ad revenue with users" and concluded the numbers are tiny. This severely underestimates it because they are measuring human attention using old-economy units. In the new economy, when machines take over the work, this is one of the answers to "how do people earn income?"

Then come the raw inputs of the machine economy itself. Every agent consumes energy, compute, and data. Energy feeds compute. Compute yields information and attention. Information and attention are refined into intelligence. Each layer depends on the one below it, and the unit value rises the higher you go. As agents multiply, each layer will be tokenized so machines can buy and sell from one another at machine speed. One kilowatt-hour becomes a token. One second of GPU time becomes a token. One dataset becomes a token: this is the newest market, because until now, there were simply no buyers.

And I want you to notice one thing here: you already live in a tokenized economy. It's just centralized. Salesforce is a token factory: it refines vast amounts of proprietary data into information and sells it back to you. Alphabet and Meta are token factories and markets for attention. ICE, the world's largest exchange group, acts as both a token exchange and a seller of data on the tokens it trades. These companies are worth trillions because they own both the factory and the market, while you own neither. What's changing now is: the factory and the market are going open, built on rails owned by no one, and tokens can be held by anyone—including the producers of that data and attention.

This is the true meaning of the Age of Exponents. Every single bit of information in the world about every object and every person becomes a unit that can be owned, priced, and exchanged. The "ledger for everything" I saw in 2014 is not a ledger for humans to keep better accounts. It is an operating system built for an economy that hasn't been born yet. If you want to dive deeper along any of these threads: identity, attention, compute markets: that's exactly why I built raoulpal.ai. Trained on everything I've written (including this book), it will push back against you and help you think through these concepts.

The Metrics Are Dissolving

Put it all together, and you arrive at a place the financial narrative has never touched.

We are about to have an economy where billions of non-human participants create, trade, and consume value at machine speed, using units never designed for human counting. Most of this activity will occur on a layer we cannot directly see. When an agent buys a second of compute from another agent to verify a credential, so that a third agent can settle a contract, no human gets paid, no product is shipped, and payroll or receipts show no trace. Yet value is created, priced, and exchanged, and the ledger records it all.

Soon, the entire apparatus we spent millennia building to score the "scarce human economy" will no longer describe reality, because the economy it points toward has already become a shrinking fraction of the existing one. This is what I call the "Economic Singularity": the moment the economy accelerates past the point where anthropocentric measurement methods can keep pace. Instruments fail because machines run faster than dials.

This sounds frightening, but the collapse of a system built for scarcity is precisely the prerequisite for the system replacing it to be born. When information itself becomes the most valuable thing in the economy, and every bit of it turns into an ownable token, a new kind of wealth is being born from things that were never assets. Your attention. Your identity. Your data. The compute you can spare, the energy you produce. For the very first time, the raw materials of the economy have become things ordinary people can produce simply by existing, and now there is a way to own it and profit from it, rather than letting platforms harvest it. Those who grasp this early will hold a position in the new economy that has no corresponding equivalent in the old one.

And we have only just begun to imagine it. In 2014, we sat in that room believing that putting property deeds on a ledger was the most exciting part. The truly interesting companies of the next decade will be built on things no one in that room could name, in markets that don't exist yet, priced in units we haven't invented. The entire economy will be rebuilt from the ledger up, and along with it, the way we value, price, and keep books for life itself...

This is precisely the destination pointed to by The Everything Code. This book outlines the entire journey: the "demographic trap" we're in, why debt and currency depreciation flow from it, why exponential technology is the only way out, and why the "economic singularity" at the end warrants optimism rather than fear.

The Everything Code is out now as of November 3 and is open for pre-order (https://lnk.to/everythingcode).