
Global fuel shortage: Why do the top three U.S. refining stocks benefit most from crack spreads?
Author: Steven Cress, Quant Team
Compiled by: TechFlow
Summary: The Seeking Alpha Quant team believes the global fuel supply shock has arrived—diesel futures and retail prices have hit records, with crack spreads surging to new highs; even if crude oil prices retreat, refiners may still profit from product-side premiums. The article highlights three US-listed refining names—Marathon Petroleum (MPC), Valero Energy (VLO), and PBF Energy—stating they rank highest on the Quant screen and are best positioned amid West Coast supply deficits.

The Supply Shock: Diesel Hits Records, Refining Margins Back in the Spotlight
The global fuel crisis is here. In the author's view, US refiners could be among the biggest winners, and this tailwind may persist for some time. The issue isn't just rising crude oil prices. Tight supplies of gasoline and diesel, combined with an increasingly constrained California market, could both push up refining margins. Crucially, even if oil prices retreat—which doesn't appear imminent given current conditions—the opportunity at the refining end could still remain.

Multiple geopolitical conflicts continue to compress refining capacity and disrupt supply chains. US refineries are already running near full capacity while inventories decline. This week, US diesel futures settlement prices set a record, and retail prices also hit an all-time high. Finished product gains outpaced crude, pushing the diesel-crude crack spread to new highs.

(Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit, ECIU)
Meanwhile, the US average gasoline retail price remains above $4.40 per gallon. Goldman Sachs expects diesel prices and margins to keep climbing and sees further upside potential for gasoline—as refineries will prioritize diesel output. On either end, US refiners are on the benefiting side.
Selecting Refining Stocks Amid the Global Fuel Crisis
This global fuel supply shock could particularly present opportunities for three US refiners: each has the capacity to capitalize on widening "crack spreads"—the difference between crude costs and finished product selling prices. The author first used the Seeking Alpha stock screener to identify "Strong Buy" ratings in the refining sector, then narrowed the focus to companies with high exposure to US and global fuel tightness. Each of the three selected tickers brings distinct asset and layout advantages, positioning them to capture globally tight demand, including the growing West Coast deficit.
1. Marathon Petroleum (MPC)
Market Cap: $116.24 Billion
Industry: Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing
Quant Sector Rank (as of 9/17/2026): 3rd out of 226 in the Energy sector
Quant Industry Rank: 3rd out of 17 in the Refining industry
Along with the other two refining stocks, Marathon ranks among the top performers in the Quant Growth & Income portfolio. Since its launch in June, Marathon has posted a total return of +56.82%, Valero Energy (VLO) +56.07%, and Phillips 66 (PSX) +46.85%, all significantly outperforming their sector over the past year.
The author attributes MPC's strength to a constructive macro backdrop: Middle East and Russia-Ukraine conflicts are constraining global refining capacity, while US gasoline inventories remain well below historical averages. Leveraging its West Coast assets and integrated logistics network, MPC is well-positioned to absorb California consumer demand when Asian imports pull back.
Major Refining Stocks: 1-Year Stock Price Return

Following widened crack spreads boosting refining profits, MPC reported adjusted EBITDA of $8.5 billion in Q2 2026, up from $3.2 billion year-over-year. On the Q2 earnings call, the company cited robust domestic and international demand for gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel, forecasting the refining upcycle to carry through the remainder of this year and into 2027.
Beyond soaring profitability and cash flow, MPC's standout growth rating rests on forward EPS growth exceeding 64%, far outpacing the sector's ~8%. Over the past 90 days, EPS estimates have been upgraded 16 times with zero downgrades, reflecting continuously improving earnings outlooks.

MPC boasts a safe and well-covered dividend, having paid out consistently for 14 consecutive years. Strong cash flow and a conservative payout rate support its "A" dividend safety rating, reflecting the company's ability to maintain its current distribution. Despite the recent stock surge capping the yield below 1%, the five-year dividend growth rate stands at 11.51%, with consensus expectations pointing to further increases over the next three years.

Viewed through the lens of PEG (price-to-earnings ratio divided by long-term growth rate), MPC remains attractive: its forward PEG sits at just 0.24, representing a ~78% discount to the sector. The author then turns to another refining stock in the QG&I portfolio that he views as equally poised for upside.
2. Valero Energy (VLO)
Market Cap: $116.12 Billion
Industry: Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing
Quant Sector Rank (as of 9/17/2026): 2nd out of 226
Quant Industry Rank: 2nd out of 17
The author considers Valero to combine growth with reliable dividend payouts: shareholder total returns exceeded 600% over the past five years, vastly outpacing the broader market and energy sector. It was once an Alpha Picks holding, contributing to portfolio gains during the initial stages of the Russia-Ukraine conflict when tight energy supply met strong demand. Subsequently, the company consistently beat estimates and repeatedly set profit records, capitalizing on geopolitically constrained supply to drive continued stock strength.
VLO vs. S&P 500 & Energy Sector (XLE): 5-Year Total Return

Valero's Q2 2026 profits surged more than 5x year-over-year to $3.72 billion, with refining margins nearly doubling. The company expects refining crack spreads to remain above historical mid-cycle levels, citing resilient demand, a favorable global balance in finished products, and constrained capacity.
Over the past 90 days, EPS estimates have been upgraded 19 times with zero downgrades, underpinning significantly raised FY2026 EPS and revenue forecasts (including the next two quarters). Strong operating leverage bolsters its growth rating: EBIT has climbed rapidly, alongside robust forward EPS and cash flow growth.

VLO has paid dividends for 28 consecutive years, with a forward yield of approximately 1.19%. Its dividend safety rating is A+, backed by excellent coverage, conservative leverage, and sustainable growth.

While several valuation metrics for VLO remain attractive, its overall rating is weighed down by a relatively high price-to-book ratio. Based on forward PEG, it trades at a ~72% discount to the sector. The author believes VLO's safe dividend and solid fundamentals make it a suitable upside play amid a prolonged fuel crisis.
3. PBF Energy (PBF)
Market Cap: $9.07 Billion
Industry: Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing
Quant Sector Rank (as of 9/17/2026): 1st out of 226
Quant Industry Rank: 1st out of 17
Closing out the list is PBF Energy: currently ranked #1 on the Quant screen for the energy sector, and recently added to the Alpha Picks and PRO Quant portfolios. PBF is a leading US independent refiner and motor fuels supplier, with two of its six refineries located in California. With roughly one-third of California's gasoline demand reliant on imports and local markets tight, PBF holds a prime position.
PBF vs. S&P 500 Energy Sector: 1-Year Stock Price Return

In Q2 2026, revenue surged 56% year-over-year to $11.68 billion, with EPS beating estimates by a wide margin. Favorable crack spreads and higher throughput widened refining margins. Simultaneously, the company is deleveraging, reducing net debt by $1.4 billion to ~$900 million in cash at quarter-end.
Growing forward operating cash flow and EBITDA support a high growth rating. Wall Street sentiment regarding FY2026 is increasingly optimistic, with earnings estimates receiving continuous upgrades.

PBF offers a forward dividend yield of ~1.45%, with robust coverage from strong cash flow and a conservative payout rate, earning a solid dividend safety rating. Despite the sharp stock rally, the valuation remains reasonable, trading at a forward P/E of just ~3.7x.
PBF completes the author's curated refining basket within the global fuel crisis narrative: all three tickers simultaneously offer profitable growth and strong momentum.
Conclusion: Riding the Energy Supply Shock on Refining Stocks
US refiners are well-positioned to capitalize on this global fuel crisis that compresses capacity and drives up diesel and gasoline prices. Finished product gains have outpaced crude, with diesel-crude crack spreads hitting all-time highs, directly boosting refining margins. Even if crude retrenches, as long as crack spreads remain elevated, refining opportunities will persist. The author is particularly bullish on these three US refiners capturing structural tailwinds, citing solid fundamentals and ample room for earnings upgrades.














