
All Four Lines of Defense Breached, How Many Trump Cards Does Bitcoin Have Left?
Author: Clow, Baihua Blockchain

On November 15, the Fear and Greed Index stood at 10.
The last time we saw this number was the week Bitcoin fell to $58,500 in June. Five months later, the situation is even grimmer: in five days, it plummeted from $74,000 to $61,900, over 300,000 traders were liquidated within 24 hours, and the total crypto market cap evaporated by over $100 billion in a single day.
A near 50% drawdown from the record high of $126,000 reached last October. The gap to June's intrayear low is now just 6%.
Both the 2018 and 2022 bear markets witnessed a second bottom that sank lower than the first. Can $58,500 hold?
Five Days, From $74,000 to $62,000
The trigger was the CPI data released on November 10.
U.S. October CPI rose 0.4% month-over-month, above expectations of 0.3%, while core CPI remained at 0.3% for a third consecutive month. CME data showed the probability of a December rate hike jumping directly to nearly 90%.
In other words, the scenario of "no rate hike" has already been priced out by the market.
Over the following five days, bad news arrived one after another, as if coordinated.
On the 11th, BlackRock's IBIT recorded a single-day net outflow of $270 million, marking its longest streak of consecutive outflows since its launch. On the same day, MSCI announced it would remove Strategy from its U.S. indices at month-end, with J.P. Morgan estimating this could trigger around $2.8 billion in passive selling.
On the 12th, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang announced his resignation, sending Nvidia's stock price plunging approximately 10% during intraday trading.
On the 13th, Iran's Revolutionary Guard claimed an attack on U.S. military radar in Bahrain, further heating up Middle East tensions.
By the 15th, Bitcoin dipped to a low of approximately $61,900, retreating to mid-July levels. Long liquidations neared $2 billion in a 24-hour window, with long positions accounting for over 80% of them. The Fear and Greed Index slid from 20 early in the week to 13, and finally to 10.
From $74,000 to $61,900: five days, a 16% drop.
Why the Macro Outlook Reversed
The starting point for this round of tightening was September 16.
The Federal Reserve raised rates by 25 basis points to a range of 3.75% to 4.00%, the first hike since July 2023, passed unanimously 12-0. The dot plot revised year-end rate forecasts upward from 3.8% to 4.1%, indicating core inflation would not return to 2% until 2029.
In other words, tightening isn't winding down; it has simply shifted gears and continued.
Then the October CPI added fuel to the fire. Fed Governor Waller bluntly stated that hiking by just 25 basis points "risks our credibility," leaving open the possibility of a full 50-basis-point hike in December. Dallas Fed President Logan said at least two more hikes are needed.
A December hike has become consensus; the only remaining question is how much.
Oil prices are a major driver of inflation. Following the outbreak of conflict with Iran at the end of February, Brent crude once spiked to a four-year high of around $126 per barrel, and gasoline prices still rose 1% month-over-month in October. Vanguard has already revised its year-end core inflation forecast up to 3.2%.
Another ticking bomb lies across the Pacific. The Bank of Japan has already hiked rates to 1.25%, with its policy meeting scheduled for December 17. Among 78 economists surveyed by Reuters, 54 expect another hike. If it happens, it would be the first time in three hikes in a year since 1989.
Do you remember Japan's last rate hike in August 2024? The Nikkei plunged 12.4% in a single day, Bitcoin fell nearly 7% that same day, and global markets briefly panicked. Unwinding of the Yen carry trade is estimated to exceed $1 trillion; if triggered again, it would be a time bomb hanging over the market.
With rate hikes combined with a stronger dollar, holding cash yields nearly a 4% risk-free return. Who would still want to touch highly volatile, non-yielding assets?
However, not all signals point to tighter conditions. The spread between the 2-year U.S. Treasury yield and the policy rate is only 0.75 percentage points, far below the 2.44 percentage points seen in 2022, meaning the degree of tightening priced in by the market is less severe than the last cycle.
Moreover, while the Fed hiked rates continuously from 2022 through July 2023, Bitcoin actually bottomed out in November 2022.
Market bottoms do not necessarily require waiting for policy bottoms.
How Many Lines of Defense Remain?
Looking at Bitcoin's cost basis lines from highest to lowest reveals how bleak the picture is.
ETFs average holding cost is around $81,500 (Glassnode data, Oct 27), the broader market average is roughly $77,500, short-term holders cost about $75,600, and Strategy's average stands at approximately $75,400.
All four lines have been breached. Almost everyone who bought over the past year is currently underwater.
With the current price around $65,000, even Strategy is sitting on an unrealized loss of roughly 14%. Below that lie two more support levels: June's intrayear lows of $57,700 to $58,500, and the network-wide average holding cost of roughly $53,000 to $55,000.
Glassnode's data paints an even clearer picture: approximately 4 million BTC were purchased between $85,000 and $118,000, mainly positions accumulated in 2025, all of which are now underwater. If these holders collectively cut their losses, selling pressure could amplify like an avalanche.
Bleeding on-chain is underway. The percentage of profitable supply network-wide has dropped from 60.4% to 55.3%, the lowest level since August. Short-term holders are collectively down 7.4% in unrealized value, with only about one-third still in profit. More coins are being sold at a loss than at a gain; fresh money has mostly dried up, while existing capital is cutting positions.
The MVRV (Market Value to Realized Value ratio) has fallen to approximately 1.2. CryptoQuant analyst Darkfost noted this is the third time his model triggered a low-position signal in 2026, previously occurring in February and between June and July.
However, he himself admitted that triggering three times in a bear market does not equate to three distinct bottoms.
In Two Past Bear Markets, the Second Bottom Was Lower
In June 2022, as Celsius froze withdrawals and Three Arrows Capital defaulted, Bitcoin fell to around $17,600. Five months later, when FTX collapsed, it crashed again to roughly $15,500, nearly 12% lower than the first bottom.
Strangely enough, despite the Fed continuing to raise rates for eight months afterward, Bitcoin began to rebound, climbing back above $25,000 within three months and reaching $42,000 by the end of 2023.
2018 was even more extreme. Bitcoin consolidated around $6,000 for most of the year, leading the market to believe that was the bottom. In December, it plummeted to approximately $3,122, nearly 48% lower.
In every cycle, new negative catalysts emerge precisely when the market believes the bottom has been confirmed, driving price to a deeper low.
What does a true "bottom" look like? Galaxy Head of Research Alex Thorn outlined criteria in a June report: bottoms typically emerge 12 to 13 months after cycle highs, MVRV drops below 1, and price falls below realized price.
This cycle hit its peak 13 months ago in November. The timeline matches, but MVRV has only dipped to 1.14 at its lowest, and the price still trades about 20% above realized price. By these standards, there is still a long way to go in terms of depth.
However, Thorn also noted that this cycle's peak MVRV was merely 2.29, far lower than previous cycles. With bubbles being smaller than ever, bottoms do not necessarily need to sink to historically comparable depths. Galaxy presented four scenarios ranging from a shallow bottom of $51,000 to a deep base of $30,000, with a baseline projection between $40,000 and $46,000.
Matt Crosby from LookIntoBitcoin offers another perspective: the magnitude by which price breaks below realized price has been narrowing each cycle. If this trend continues, this cycle might not need to fall to realized price levels before finding a bottom.
Who Is Selling, Who Is Buying?
The lineup of sellers is extensive.
Spot Bitcoin ETFs have posted consecutive net outflows from late October through November 13. Out of 12 trading days, only two saw net inflows, with cumulative outflows exceeding $2.3 billion. The Coinbase Premium Index has remained negative consecutively, signaling weakening domestic buying demand in the U.S.
Stablecoin supply contracted by approximately $14.2 billion over a 30-day period, the fastest pace of shrinkage since June 2022. USDT's price has already dipped slightly below $1.
Capital is flowing out.
Whales are making net deposits of roughly $55 million into exchanges daily, which Glassnode describes as "preparing for potential distribution." Miner MARA sold approximately 13,600 BTC in the third quarter to pay down debt, worth around $1.1 billion, stating in its shareholder letter that sales will continue. Mining difficulty was reduced by 9.13% on November 14, with about 100 EH/s of hash rate coming offline in the previous two weeks, pushing hash rate pricing near historical lows.
But buyers have not completely vanished.
Mid-sized wallets holding between 100 and 10,000 BTC continue to accumulate, and Strategy has also been adding positions during the same period. Spot trading volume increased by 24.5% week-over-week to $8.2 billion, marking the highest level since August. Glassnode pointed out that cumulative ETF net outflows remain relatively shallow compared to the overall fund size.
Some are exiting, others are stepping in.
What to Watch Next
December features three key dates: the Fed's policy meeting with a new dot plot on the 8th and 9th, the Bank of Japan's rate decision on the 17th and 18th, and the massive Deribit year-end options expiration on the 25th. Each has the potential to reprice risk.
Three indicators will determine the direction: whether weekly ETF flows can turn positive, if stablecoin supply can resume growth, and whether MVRV will break below 1.0.
Bullish take: Leverage has been flushed out, the Fear and Greed Index has hit extreme lows, MVRV has touched a low tier for the third time, and most macro headwinds are largely priced in. June's $58,500 marks this cycle's bottom. Markus Thielen, founder of 10x Research, believes that after one more hike in December, the Fed will pivot to caution, setting the stage for a year-end rebound.
Bearish take: Historically, every bear market bottom has required MVRV to fall below 1 and price to break below realized price, neither of which has happened yet. Both 2018 and 2022 saw a lower second bottom. With both central banks hiking in December and fresh money halting its inflow, $58,500 may not hold. Galaxy's baseline scenario points to $40,000 to $46,000; if prices reach there, the current level faces a further drawdown of 30% to 40%.
December will provide some answers.













