
Don't Rush to Go Short on Ethereum: 5 Reasons Refuting "The Liquidity Moat Has Been Breached"
Author: Jake Koch-Gallup
Translated by: TechFlow
TechFlow Summary: As more people begin to question Ethereum's value capture capability, this article offers a counter-narrative. The author directly addresses the argument that "Ethereum is losing its liquidity moat," refuting it from perspectives including monetary premium, Layer 2 ecosystems, and stablecoin market share. For investors reassessing Ethereum's long-term positioning, this is a worthwhile read for reflection.
If you haven't read Carlos's newsletter from Tuesday, go read it first. His core thesis is that Ethereum is losing its final moat: liquidity. We debated this issue on the 0xResearch podcast (which you can listen to here), and I strongly disagree with his perspective (can you believe it? An analyst at Blockworks actually holds a differing opinion).
His first example is that tokenized stocks on Ethereum have virtually no trading volume, with only $25 million in transaction volume over the past 30 days, accounting for roughly 3% of the supply. However, Ethereum holds the second-largest share in tokenized stock supply. Carlos anticipated this point, but I still maintain that the purpose of tokenized stocks is to broaden global investor access to the U.S. market, not for lending and DeFi applications. On the podcast, his counterargument was: Tokenized stocks sitting on your blockchain are useless because they don't generate revenue, and revenue only comes from trading volume.

Dear readers, this may be where we truly diverge. I do not believe Ethereum necessarily needs to generate revenue. It already enjoys a monetary premium, much like many other L1 chains. Real Economic Value (REV) alone cannot possibly explain the market capitalization of most L1s. ETH currently trades at over 1100 times its trailing twelve-month REV. Given that the market clearly prices Ethereum partly as a reserve asset and collateral asset (via spot ETFs, Treasury bills, and DeFi collateral), dismissing this fact would be tantamount to claiming that ETH and most L1s have been fundamentally overvalued by 99% forever, which is a rather unproductive conclusion.

His second argument is that flagship applications are prioritizing growth elsewhere. He cites that Robinhood Chain accounted for 43% of Uniswap’s trading volume over the past 30 days, whereas Ethereum only accounted for 32%. He also points to Ethena’s growth on Base. Both observations hold some weight, but Robinhood Chain and Base are both Ethereum Layer 2 networks. If we concede that REV is relatively unimportant for L1 valuations, then growth across Ethereum Layer 2s actually constitutes a win for Ethereum. Fairly speaking, Ethena has also indeed expanded to Solana, TRON, and Avalanche, which are not Layer 2s. Ethereum’s share within USDe has declined from 88% to 56%, but it still retains the majority position. Ethena is simply broadening its distribution channels, not abandoning Ethereum.

That said, if you do believe REV is absolutely critical, consider this: In September, Base paid Ethereum roughly $15,000 in data publishing fees. During that same month, it paid the Optimism Collective $711,000. Now imagine a scenario three to five years down the line where Ethereum declares, “You know what, we want a cut of that kind of revenue too,” and increases the minimum fee for data publishing. Base might resent it, but if Layer 2 scale has grown tenfold by then, that translates to a substantial amount of money. Thus, market share remains highly significant, even if it isn't currently translating into heavy REV generation.

His final argument is that Ethereum's stablecoin dominance is gradually eroding, which is undeniably true. However, the stablecoin market is far from a winner-take-all landscape. Even if Ethereum's market share slips from 51% to 30% over the next ten years, the absolute size of the stablecoin market will continue to expand. Should the total stablecoin market cap hit $3 trillion in a decade, Ethereum would hold close to $1 trillion in stablecoins—nearly six times its current holdings of $15.5 billion. For Carlos’s direct response to the counterarguments I’ve laid out here, make sure to listen to the podcast. Setting those debates aside for a moment, let’s examine why Ethereum remains valuable and will continue to hold that position.
Reasons Why Ethereum Still Holds Value

Ethereum commands the largest DeFi Total Value Locked (TVL) by a wide margin, accounting for 65% of the sector total. It has never dipped below 62% in any given week since 2022.
Ethereum continues to offer the deepest liquidity, the most robust security profile, and the highest degree of institutional adoption across all blockchains apart from Bitcoin.
Ethereum hosts the largest on-chain Real World Asset (RWA) management volume (although its share has contracted from 99% in 2022 to 45% today).
Institutional allocations of ETH are treated as a macro asset class rather than for yield generation. Spot ETFs and corporate treasuries currently hold approximately 13% of the total ETH supply.
Both Robinhood and Coinbase had the capacity to launch proprietary L1 chains, yet opted to settle transactions on Ethereum.
The industry’s largest tokenized funds, such as BlackRock’s BUIDL, debuted first on the Ethereum mainnet.
Ethereum has maintained continuous operation for over a decade without a single network-wide halt.
Ethereum and its Layer 2 ecosystem foster the crypto sector’s largest developer community, with the EVM standing as the de facto development toolkit—an architecture even competing L1s are attempting to replicate.
Thirty-six percent of the ETH supply is currently staked, recently reaching a record high and delivering native yields to holders, which institutions can now capture through staking-focused ETFs.
Ethereum functions as the foundational computer of the cryptocurrency ecosystem.
Ultimately, I operate as a fundamental investor. Crypto ventures generally require viable revenue models, with economic value flowing back to token holders. Consequently, relying solely on Ethereum’s monetary premium alongside modest REV to sustain its valuation might just reflect investor wishful thinking. Yet maybe, just maybe, Ethereum deserves to be priced as a world computer.
Daily Highlights

Following a full-year downward trend, Plasma’s stablecoin supply has nearly doubled since July to $1.41 billion, marking its highest reading since mid-February. While it remains considerably below its $5.2 billion peak since inception, competition among stablecoin chains is far from over.















