
Under Aggressive Expansion, Polymarket Accumulates Multiple Compliance and Security Risks
By Katherine Long, Caitlin Ostroff, Neil Mehta
Translated by Chopper, Foresight News
In February this year, a partner institution processing debit card transactions for Polymarket's US betting platform sent out a warning: a wave of fraudsters flooded onto the platform.
Fraudsters linked stolen debit cards to Polymarket US accounts, placed bets using them, then withdrew the funds to clean bank cards or accounts under their control, attempting to steal at least $10 million.
During the incident, the payment processor flagged over 80% of deposit transactions as fraudulent, a figure far exceeding the ~1% industry benchmark. According to insiders, Polymarket employees promptly reported the risk to CEO Shayne Coplan. The compliance team recalled that Coplan’s response stunned them: just keep expanding; if regulators find issues, worst case we just pay the fine.
Current and former Polymarket employees say this previously unreported remark encapsulates Coplan’s management philosophy for Polymarket—pursuing growth at all costs.
Current, former employees, and investors interviewed by The Wall Street Journal say the now-raging company went all out to attract new users and investors, but in the process encountered repeated compliance loopholes, legal disputes, and software glitches. Insiders stated that after the February attack, although the platform's fraud rate did not return to 80%, it remained stubbornly high for consecutive months. Following the incident, several executives left the company, which launched an internal investigation.
Former regulators from the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), Department of Justice, and Internal Revenue Service say the scale of the attempted fraud and Polymarket’s response are rare in both commodities and gambling industries. Unlike traditional commodity exchanges, Polymarket directly accepts retail funds, making it more susceptible to fraud attacks. Former CFTC enforcement attorney Joe Konizeski stated: “This type of thing doesn’t happen in regulated markets. Professionals manage client funds to ensure both sourcing and disposition comply with regulations.”
A Polymarket spokesperson said the company is committed to maintaining accurate, fair, and transparent markets and actively cooperating with regulators and law enforcement. “Our market integrity mechanisms include processes for detecting, verifying, and handling suspicious activity.”
Polymarket faces increasing lawsuits across multiple fronts. The CFTC has already filed a lawsuit against it, and insiders reveal the company has instructed employees to preserve records related to this fraud attack and other matters. The New York City Council is conducting a broad investigation into Polymarket and other prediction markets, while nearly two dozen traders have filed lawsuits alleging deceptive business practices by Polymarket.
Meanwhile, more than a dozen state-level lawsuits focus on a core question: whether platforms like Polymarket and its competitor Kalshi operate as unlicensed gambling venues. The outcomes of these cases could reshape the entire industry landscape.
Polymarket CEO Shayne Coplan directed employees to maintain the company's rapid growth pace
As legal risks mount, Coplan is pushing forward with a $1 billion funding round, which would valuate the company at approximately $21 billion upon completion. 1789 Capital, the investment fund run by Donald Trump Jr., will participate in this round, having previously invested roughly $200 million in Polymarket.
Polymarket has a data partnership with Dow Jones, parent company of The Wall Street Journal. Currently, the company is reshaping its image for investors and the public, positioning itself as a mature enterprise pursuing steady growth. Operational insiders revealed that starting in May, the company has been steadily hiring experienced risk control personnel, including a former FBI agent, while refining compliance procedures and optimizing product testing.
Insiders say that in late June, Coplan visited co-founder Omeed Malik of 1789 Capital at his Hampton residence to discuss strategies for tightening Polymarket’s internal operations ahead of a potential IPO next year. Malik advised Coplan to hire more seasoned executives. Recently, Polymarket appointed its first Chief Financial Officer, Warren Jenson, who served as Amazon’s CFO in the early 2000s.
After The Wall Street Journal published its investigative report on Polymarket’s social media betting business, the company restructured its marketing team, hiring the founder of e-scooter company Bird as head of growth. Other marketing staff involved in social media campaigns were either laid off or had their responsibilities scaled back.
A company spokesperson stated: “Polymarket is growing rapidly and progressing every day. We are proud of our newly appointed core leadership team and continuously upgraded infrastructure. We have scaled our operations at the forefront of finance, technology, and culture while steadfastly adhering to responsible growth.”
The 28-year-old Coplan is known for his bluntness and aggressive management style, having previously reprimanded staff in the office. Former employees claim widespread overtime and sleepless nights are common, and taking Adderall—a central nervous system stimulant—is rampant internally. Multiple ex-staff members noted that Coplan constantly pushed engineers to iterate through feature request lists amid frequent requirement changes.
A recording reviewed by The Wall Street Journal shows that in July last year, while discussing how to settle betting outcome disputes, Coplan bluntly remarked: “Dude, this is completely stupid! You’re complaining about this nonsense nonstop, which is absurd.”
After reaching a settlement with federal regulators in 2022, Polymarket was barred from offering its international platform to U.S.-based users. In 2024, as Polymarket’s profile rose, two federal agencies launched an investigation to determine if the company violated the settlement agreement by allowing U.S. traders to access the platform.
Roughly around the same time, a prankster employee at the office placed a life-sized cardboard cutout of incarcerated crypto fraudster Sam Bankman-Fried. The joke partly stemmed from the fact that Coplan, another crypto billionaire, bears a superficial resemblance to SBF.
After being barred from offering its international platform to U.S. users, Coplan told employees to prepare for a return to the domestic market
Coplan tasked the team with preparing for a domestic U.S. market return. To pave the way for the U.S. app, Polymarket negotiated with regulators to seek closure on the relevant investigations. Last summer, the company spent $112 million to acquire a licensed exchange, which was then rebranded as Polymarket US.
Polymarket US opened to early users in December. Insiders say a flood of traders joined the platform, with total account deposits exceeding $500 million.
As one anti-money laundering safeguard, Polymarket US adopted a standard rule used by financial exchanges: funds deposited via one payment channel must be withdrawn back through the exact same channel. Without this rule, fraudsters could use stolen debit cards to fund accounts, complete trades, and then withdraw profits to clean bank cards.
Federal regulations do not mandate prediction markets to enforce this rule. Other brokers and betting apps, including DraftKings and FanDuel, comply with it. Polymarket’s main competitor, Kalshi, does not implement this rule, but insiders note that Kalshi monitors cross-channel withdrawals and freezes suspicious payouts.
Fraud Warning
In January this year, trading volume on Polymarket’s U.S. app accounted for only a tiny fraction compared to its massive international platform: wagering size was under $300 million, while the international platform exceeded $7.6 billion.
Although the app was still in beta testing and open to a limited user base, Coplan wanted to eliminate friction in the user experience as much as possible. One of his top demands: ensuring fast user withdrawals. By February, Polymarket users’ Discord communities were flooded with complaints about slow withdrawals. Staff explained that funds were being processed, but compliance reviews could delay withdrawals for days or even weeks. Engineering glitches with the U.S. app further compounded withdrawal issues.
Polymarket ads appeared on New York streets ahead of the November 2025 mayoral election
In February this year, payment service provider Checkout.com notified Polymarket that fraudsters initiated an attack linking stolen debit cards to thousands of new accounts. Insiders say most deposit attempts failed, with the attack largely driven by seven users, one of whom attempted roughly 4,000 deposits. Checkout.com remains a partner to Polymarket and declined to comment on the incident or their ongoing collaboration.
The attack overwhelmed the compliance team, worsening the backlog of withdrawals. Insiders say to accelerate user fund payouts, management decided to scrap the same-channel withdrawal rule, despite warnings from some staff that it would open a loophole for money laundering. Executives, however, believed existing safeguards were sufficient to mitigate the risk.
Former federal prosecutors note that failing to adequately control money laundering activities could violate federal anti-money laundering, illegal fund transfer, and even bank fraud laws. Both the CFTC and the DOJ have brought related suits against numerous companies, including several crypto exchanges, with some fines reaching hundreds of millions of dollars. However, the anti-money laundering regulatory requirements applicable to Polymarket are relatively lenient.
Insiders revealed that Andrew Clifford, Chief Compliance Officer for Polymarket US, resigned in April after submitting a lengthy report detailing the fraud issues. Neither Andrew Clifford nor Polymarket commented on his departure.
Around the same time, Polymarket completed a $1 billion funding round, bringing its valuation close to $15 billion, with investors including Donald Trump Jr.’s fund.
Shortly after, Polymarket dismissed American division CEO Justin Hertzberg, followed by the sequential departures of the U.S. region’s regulatory head and anti-money laundering lead. Justin Hertzberg did not respond to requests for comment. Insiders stated that an investigation conducted by law firm Sullivan & Cromwell concluded that the company’s operations complied with regulatory requirements.
An insider said that by May, the platform’s fraud rate had fallen to industry-normal levels through measures such as limiting the number of debit cards tied to a single account and onboarding a new anti-fraud provider, Riskified.
Controversial New Markets
Polymarket is also working to fix various issues sparked by hastily rolling out new features. Former employees disclosed that the company frequently pushes untested update versions to users. When engineers raised concerns and suggested prioritizing fixes for existing platform vulnerabilities, Coplan sometimes directed engineers to develop new features directly using AI.
A man from New York said $950 vanished from his account after the platform app crashed in July. A woman in California claimed she couldn't withdraw $1,500 from her account. A 22-year-old user from Massachusetts reported his account was locked; he contacted customer service dozens of times with no response and waited weeks without hearing back from the company.
Insiders say Polymarket has compensated some clients who suffered losses; others worked with their banks to recover unauthorized charges. Additionally, the company recently improved its code review process and hired more engineers.
Coplan pushed the team to launch numerous highly-discussed new prediction markets. Text message logs reviewed by The Wall Street Journal show he once proposed markets like: “How many times Kanye mentions Jews on X this week” or “Who Elon insults again”. These markets never went live. In June, the company filed a trademark application for “Create Your Own Market”. Former employees say this is part of Coplan’s long-term growth strategy aimed at allowing users to freely create prediction markets on any topic.
Rajiv Sethi, an economics professor at Barnard College who has long studied prediction markets, stated that opening up self-service market creation would introduce new risks of market manipulation.
Polymarket has partnered with multiple A-list celebrities and sports superstars, including NBA star LeBron James
Coplan hopes to turn Polymarket into a household brand, spending heavily to sign deals with top-tier celebrities and sports stars, including LeBron James, alongside securing a $300 million partnership with Major League Baseball. Insiders revealed that LeBron James’s team had shared with a rival prediction market platform that Polymarket offered $20 million annually plus $50 million in equity. The final terms of Polymarket’s collaboration remain unverified. Insiders note that LeBron James currently holds no equity in Polymarket.
Last autumn, Polymarket was in talks with musician Drake for a multi-million-dollar partnership. A Polymarket spokesperson and Drake’s team confirmed the deal ultimately fell through. Nevertheless, Drake later referenced Polymarket and Coplan in his album Iceman. Coplan attended Drake’s private album release event held at a castle-like mansion in Toronto.
In late April, Polymarket launched a prediction market betting on whether Drake would say “Polymarket” in his new album. Shortly before the album’s release, an account created specifically for this purpose placed bets solely on album-related markets, ultimately cashing out a profit of $7,800. Data reviewed and insider accounts indicate that hours before the album dropped, Drake’s team previewed it for Polymarket staff; upon hearing the company name mentioned in the track, staff urgently delisted the prediction market due to insider trading risks.
An individual involved in the negotiation called it hard to precisely measure the return on brand partnerships, but Coplan seemingly didn’t care about recouping costs, focusing entirely on closing the deal. When staff questioned the excessively high pricing, Coplan responded: “I don’t care at all.”
Some executives at Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), Polymarket’s largest investor, expressed in interviews their concern that the prediction market company made several strategic missteps. The Wall Street Journal’s June report exposed that Polymarket paid influencers to post fake trading videos and targeted offshore platform ads at U.S. users. This triggered alarms among ICE and other investors, who feared the actions violated federal advertising regulations and the settlement agreement between Polymarket and the CFTC prohibiting offshore platform services for U.S. traders.
In late July, ICE disclosed in its quarterly report that its $1.6 billion stake in Polymarket represents 22% of the company’s outstanding shares.
Another Attack Incident
In late July, nearly 500 Polymarket users fell victim to another fraud attack stemming from engineering flaws. Insiders explain that when attackers registered new accounts using someone else’s personal information (such as stolen Social Security numbers), they could bypass passwords or usernames to directly takeover those traders’ existing Polymarket accounts and linked bank/debit cards. The total amount of stolen funds this time was relatively small.
A female Polymarket spokesperson stated that the company will reimburse users for all lost funds.
Multiple users recounted losing thousands of dollars in interviews and Discord communities, sending countless messages to customer service with no replies for weeks. However, a Polymarket employee stated in Discord in July that the engineering team was fixing issues affecting those users.
26-year-old Dane Collins said he started using Polymarket US to bet on the World Cup in May. Previously, Kalshi was banned by court order from providing sports betting services in Michigan, where he lives. When he logged into his account in July, he found all his bets liquidated and his $5,783.51 profit withdrawn to a debit card not belonging to him.
Without any explanation, Polymarket credited his account with $25. Dane Collins has already filed reports with local police, the FBI, and the CFTC. “Polymarket US hasn’t responded for weeks.” After he submitted identity verification documents twice, the platform froze his account and remained completely silent regarding the missing funds.















