TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Partnership Breaks Down: Why Is It So Hard to Unify Ethereum and Base's Account Abstraction Standard?

Partnership Breaks Down: Why Is It So Hard to Unify Ethereum and Base's Account Abstraction Standard?

2026.09.15
Share
Ethereum aims to be "the best Ethereum," and Base aims to be "the best Base."

Written by: Oluwapelumi Adejumo

Translated by: Saoirse, Foresight News

Ethereum and Coinbase’s Layer 2 network, Base, have abandoned reaching a consensus on operational standards for next-generation crypto wallets.

On September 14, Ethlabs researcher Derek Chiang stated that collaboration between developers of Ethereum's EIP-8141 framed transaction proposal and Base's EIP-8130 proposal has broken down. Both parties attempted to establish a unified account abstraction standard but failed to reconcile the vastly different requirements of their respective chains.

Following the divergence, Ethereum continues to advance framed transactions, while Base implements an independent native account abstraction design. This will likely require wallets to adapt to different transaction architectures across various networks—networks whose past account and transaction experiences were largely consistent.

Both proposals aim to enhance wallet programmability, supporting features such as gas sponsorship, passkeys, and flexible authentication. The core of the conflict lies in how much freedom the protocol should grant accounts, and how many rules and constraints the blockchain should impose on transactions before execution.

Chiang noted:

"Ethereum wants to become the best version of Ethereum, and Base wants to become the best version of Base."

Just a few weeks ago, stakeholders in the project were still attempting to bridge the gap. At the end of August, Ethlabs revealed that even though Ethereum core developers had sent strong signals planning to include EIP-8141 in the Hegotá upgrade, developers still held dedicated discussions around framed transactions and the concepts behind EIP-8130.

Layer 2 Competition Drives Protocol Divergence

This collaborative failure exposes a structural challenge. As Ethereum Layer 2 blockchains gradually mature, developing their own user bases, commercial priorities, and development roadmaps, this issue will become increasingly difficult to manage.

Ethereum core developer Matt Garnett stated that friction between Layer 2 networks is an inevitable outcome. Market competition forces Layer 2 networks to roll out new features at a pace far exceeding that of the Ethereum Layer 1 network.

Garnett added:

"Market pressure forces them to iterate on new features at a pace L1 can't match, causing incompatibility issues to continuously accumulate. Whether this ultimately becomes an advantage or a liability remains to be seen."

This competitive pressure is reflected in two competing account abstraction proposals.

EIP-8141 introduces framed transactions, breaking a single transaction into multiple programmable calls that separately handle verification, execution, and gas payment logic. The proposal aims to decouple accounts from Ethereum's current mainstream elliptic curve key system, support key rotation, and provide a pathway for post-quantum authentication. Its goal is to make accounts into addresses whose behavior is entirely defined by code.

EIP-8130, drafted by Coinbase engineer Chris Hunter, adopts a more rigidly structured design. It requires transactions to explicitly declare their validators, allowing nodes to anticipate the overhead of verification before executing any wallet code. This draft structures the validation logic for predictability, enabling nodes to directly reject unknown validators prior to transaction execution.

Chiang noted that the Ethereum mainnet prioritizes adherence to a principle set known as CROPS: Censorship & Capture Resistance, Open-source Software, Privacy, and Safety.

These principles favor an account model that can scale without requiring chain-party approval, while ensuring transaction designs can accommodate privacy systems and future post-quantum signature algorithms.

However, Layer 2 networks like Base, which pursue high throughput, face different practical pressures. Chiang stated they need an account abstraction system that is both scalable and logically clear enough for the chain itself to define which authentication methods are permitted and which transactions are accepted.

The current EIP-8130 draft reflects this divergence through two separate adaptation configurations: the L1 configuration allows non-standard validator sets within limited scopes, while the Layer 2 configuration enables high-throughput chains to restrict native transaction paths to audited standard validators.

The proposal still aims for cross-chain account portability; networks that do not support the EIP-8130 transaction type can use universal validator sets and ERC-4337 as alternative implementations.

In other words, even if Ethereum and Base adopt two distinct native systems, compatibility will remain, but the heavy lifting required to maintain it will no longer fall on the protocol itself.

Standard Fragmentation Prompts Re-evaluation of Ethereum and Layer 2 Partnerships

As technical differences between Ethereum and Layer 2 networks continue to multiply, this account abstraction dispute also sparks a broader debate: does the growth of Layer 2 networks automatically strengthen Ethereum itself?

Crypto industry lawyer Gabriel Shapiro believes that the rift between EIP-8141 and EIP-8130 will make the argument that "Layer 2 networks are inherently beneficial to Ethereum" harder to sustain. He stated:

"Layer 2 networks are excellent for the crypto industry and for sequencer holders. But for Ethereum, they merely represent being 'not as bad' compared to other competing public chains."

His core argument centers on where value and control will ultimately flow. Networks like Base can attract users, applications, and transaction traffic, capture sequencing-related economic yields, and make product decisions based on their own competitive priorities.

Ethereum continues to provide settlement and security underlying infrastructure, but this partnership does not guarantee that every new feature from a Layer 2 network or each of its commercial successes will directly bolster L1 product capabilities or its economic model.

Shapiro suggests that Ethereum should rely less on the halo effect generated by projects like Base and Robinhood, and more clearly articulate the unique value propositions of the foundational public chain. He links this shift to the censorship resistance, privacy, and safety that Vitalik Buterin has recently emphasized repeatedly. Even as substantial business continues to migrate onto Rollups, Ethereum must highlight these core attributes belonging to L1.

Naturally, Layer 2 networks will still generate settlement demands, consume Ethereum's data availability resources, and help keep applications within the broader Ethereum ecosystem, preventing app migration to competitor blockchains. EIP-8130 also incorporates corresponding mechanisms to ensure accounts can migrate across various EVM chains, indicating that Base is not developing toward an isolated ecosystem.

Even so, this account abstraction dispute remains a vivid case study demonstrating how stakeholder interests tend to diverge.