
Backpack VS xStocks: Do Proprietary Market Makers Directly Halve Tokenized US Stock Execution Costs?
By: Jake Koch-Gallup, Sam Schubert
Compiled by: AididiaoJP, Foresight News
This article focuses on the differences in market structure between Backpack and xStocks for tokenized US stocks on Solana, and how these differences directly reflect in execution costs.
Market performance diverged. The Solana ecosystem index rose another 8.0%, but the gain came almost entirely from two tokens, META and PUMP, not a broad rally across the ecosystem.

Yesterday, the Solana ecosystem index continued to lead, rising 8.0%, more than double the second place. Launchpad (+3.2%), Bittensor ecosystem (+2.7%), AI (+2.2%), and perpetual contracts (+2.0%) followed. Traditional US stocks outperformed most crypto assets: Nasdaq 100 rose 3.0%, S&P 500 rose 1.9%, while Bitcoin rose only 0.9%. Crypto mining enterprises performed the worst, down 3.1%; the Ethereum ecosystem and lending sectors both fell 2.0%.

On a weekly chart, sector rotation is extremely fast. Despite yesterday's sharp decline, crypto mining enterprises still rank second weekly, up 15.1%. DEX, which ranked second on Monday, has given back all gains this week and is currently down 1.1%. The lending sector is the worst performer this week, down 10.0%, followed closely by the Ethereum ecosystem, down 9.8%. The public chain sector fell 2.0% on the week, with SOL currently around $73, down about 10% on the month.

The rise in the Solana index is actually very narrow. META has risen 46.6% weekly since listing on Upbit, and PUMP rose 22.9% weekly and accounts for about one-third of the index weight; these two tokens contributed almost all of the 17.8% weekly gain. Seven out of 11 components fell, with BP down 13.7%, BONK down 7.7%, and the median component down 5.4%. Solana rose because of two tokens, not because the entire ecosystem is absorbing capital.

This week, both Solana and Ethereum saw proposals to reduce issuance. Solana's "Double Deflation Proposal" aims to double the annual deflation rate from 15% to 30%, bringing the 1.5% terminal inflation floor forward from 2032 to 2029, resulting in approximately 18.9 million fewer SOL issued over the next six years. Ethereum's EIP-8361 plans to gradually burn more validator rewards, eliminate incentives for staking over 50% of total supply, bring net consensus issuance to zero at that threshold, and roughly halve the current yield to about 1.1%. Both are drafts, and neither coin price has reflected these proposals yet.
Solana Tokenized US Stocks: Backpack vs xStocks
Both Backpack Securities and xStocks have launched overlapping tokenized US stocks on Solana, but the market structures differ significantly. Backpack relies mainly on proprietary market makers (Prop AMM) quoting and trading from market maker inventory, while xStocks' trading volume is highly concentrated in public liquidity pools on Raydium and Orca.
On the surface, trading volumes seem similar: from June 12 to July 30, xStocks traded $2.43 billion, and Backpack traded $2.10 billion. However, SPYx alone contributed $1.70 billion, accounting for 70% of xStocks' total volume, and much of it was circular trading within pools. Excluding SPYx, comparable xStocks volume is only $726 million, far lower than Backpack's $2.10 billion.
Since SPCX launched, 66%–74% of Backpack's weekly volume has been executed via Prop AMM, averaging about 71% over the past four full weeks. In contrast, xStocks' proportion of volume via Prop AMM is only about 33%, and this figure is severely inflated by AlphaQ's single-week volume of $284 million; excluding that week, it is basically below 10%.

Only redeemable and hedgable underlying assets make professional quoting reasonable. This was evident on the first day: within hours of SPCX launching on June 12, market makers began posting two-way quotes of $10,000, rather than waiting weeks to enter.
Intraday data adds two more points. Prop AMM provides continuous quoting: the median for Backpack's 30-minute intervals on weekdays shows 69% of volume going through Prop AMM (the middle 80% of intervals range between 62%–84%), and the weekend median is still 64%; market makers simply widen spreads and bias quotes when US stocks are closed, rather than canceling orders. The remaining pool and order book traffic accounts for about one-fifth to one-third of most intervals; pool volume jumps significantly around US market open and close, consistent with characteristics of arbitraging and hedging underlying assets, so gross pool volume likely overestimates capital truly choosing pools actively.

The traffic itself is mostly pass-through capital. In Solana tokenized stock trading, about 68% is circular trading: 31% enters and exits within minutes (including atomic completion within a single transaction), 34.5% enters and exits within the day, truly directional positions held for longer periods account for only 7.1%, and about one-quarter we cannot classify.
Meanwhile, the number of holders continues to rise—increasing from 129,000 in early May to 211,000 by the end of July, and by the end of July there was still $164 million of buy flow that had not matched with sells for at least one week.

In terms of matched order size, Backpack's SPCX execution costs are consistently lower than xStocks. We compared trades in the $100–$500 range from June 12 to July 20, against NBBO during regular trading hours and overnight Blue Ocean quotes. The analysis uses actual executions by different traders within the same time window, rather than routing the same order twice. During regular hours, xStocks is approximately 2.4–2.5 basis points more expensive, and 2.8–2.9 basis points more expensive overnight. Out of 25 eligible regular trading days, Backpack was cheaper on 22 days; all 17 overnight sessions were cheaper. This is consistent with the logic of Prop AMM competing for traffic around real-time reference prices.














