
Bitcoin miners are admitting defeat, but their stocks are surging
Written by: Matt Crosby
Compiled by: BlockBeats
Bitcoin's total network hashrate has been declining for several consecutive months, and miner difficulty has just recorded one of the steepest drops on record. Typically, this story is not complicated: miners start shutting down machines because it is economically unviable. But the exception this time lies in the fact that stocks of listed mining companies are experiencing one of their strongest performances in recent years, while BTC itself has been hit hard. In every previous round of miner capitulation, miner pressure and price pressure often occurred simultaneously; now the two are beginning to diverge, and the market does not seem to have truly priced in what this divergence means for long-term hashrate.
If you are short on time, you can look at these points first:
- The total network hashrate is signaling one of the longest-lasting miner capitulation events in Bitcoin history.
- Miner difficulty has dropped 19.9% from its peak, the third deepest retracement since the widespread adoption of dedicated mining hardware.
- Despite miners selling off thousands of Bitcoins, mining company stocks have still significantly outperformed BTC over the past year.
- Block reward revenue denominated in BTC has just hit the lowest single-day level on record.
- The average daily fee revenue over the past 28 days cannot even cover the subsidy of one block.
Miner Capitulation Is Indeed Happening
In Bitcoin's history, there have been few hashrate retracements lasting longer than this current one. Miner Difficulty (Miner Difficulty) is also declining synchronously, which precisely indicates that the protocol mechanism is functioning as designed: every 2,016 blocks, or approximately every two weeks, the network resets the target difficulty once to ensure blocks continue to be produced on average close to every ten minutes. As fewer machines participate in hash calculation, the target difficulty naturally decreases. Currently, miner difficulty has fallen 19.9% from its peak; since ASIC replaced GPU as the mainstream mining machine, only two retracements have been deeper than this.

Figure 1: Miner difficulty has fallen 19.9% from its historical peak.
The only two comparable cycles also had durations close to this one. The deeper one occurred after China completely cleared out Bitcoin mining; that was almost the easiest type of such event to understand: policy directly shut down mining machines, hashrate collapsed instantly, and any observer could deduce the next step—these machines would seek cheaper electricity and reconnect to the network elsewhere.

Figure 2: Bitcoin's total network hashrate has been declining for 287 consecutive days.
Why Mining Company Stocks Are Rising Instead
Over the past year, BTC has cumulatively fallen about 46%. But several of the largest listed mining companies (Listed Miners) surged significantly during the same period, with the best performer rising even over 430%. This is not the usual way this group of assets behaves. Historically, mining company equity is usually viewed as "leveraged Bitcoin," meaning that when the market falls they often fall harder, and when the market rises they often rise more fiercely. Therefore, a divergence as large as this time is very rare.

Figure 3: Performance of listed mining companies relative to BTC over the past year.
What is truly driving all of this is the AI narrative. For many years, Bitcoin and the largest AI ETF have moved in the same direction, with correlation reaching even 0.8 to 0.9 in certain phases. But now this relationship has reversed: AI continues to rise, while Bitcoin is weakening.
Block Subsidies Are Thinning
Miners recently recorded a historical low in single-day revenue for block rewards (Block Rewards) denominated in BTC. Part of this reason comes from the hashrate decline—before the difficulty adjustment catches up, block production speed will be slower than ten minutes; but the more main reason is actually just the protocol operating according to established rules. Block subsidies halve every four years, and will continue to halve until there are no new coins left to issue.

Figure 4: Miner block reward revenue denominated in BTC has dropped to a new historical low.
Since the first halving, the same counterargument is raised every cycle: the coin price will compensate. That is to say, although fewer coins are produced per block, as long as each coin is worth more, revenue denominated in USD can still be maintained. This logic has indeed held true so far. The Puell Multiple, which measures miner revenue sentiment, is currently around 0.75, meaning miner current revenue is approximately only three-quarters of the average level over the past year. Converted, this roughly equates to current daily revenue of about $30 million, while the longer-term mean is close to $40 million.
Who Will Fill This Gap
The other answer has always been fees, and so it has been from the start. One day, block subsidies will reach zero; by that time, the network security budget must be borne independently by fees, otherwise as subsidies disappear, the security budget will shrink along with them.

Figure 5: Proportion of miner fee revenue to total miner revenue.
But reality is still very far from that step. Miners currently earn about $30 million per day, of which fee contribution is only about $200,000. In other words, the average fee revenue over the past 28 days cannot even cover the subsidy of one block, while the Bitcoin network produces approximately 144 blocks per day. No matter what the fee market eventually evolves into in the future, at least for now, the network security budget it covers is only enough to support about ten minutes.
What This Means
Bitcoin today is certainly far from having security risks, and this article is not directly judging price. But the shape of this capitulation is already clearly different from previous rounds. Miners have simply found a hardware use case more profitable than mining, and while this change is happening, the coin price is falling, block subsidies are shrinking, and fee revenue has hardly improved.
No one wants to hear a new bearish narrative in a bear market, and I know this article reads roughly like that. But looking at it the other way, problems that truly need to be solved are often only seriously faced during bear markets. In the long run, miner incentive mechanisms will either be consciously designed and patched, or will have to continue relying on higher coin prices to temporarily mask the problems.














