
Will decentralized applications be more valuable than blockchain base protocols in the future?
Author: Revelo Intel
Compiled by: TechFlow
Appchains
-
Value may accrue closer to the consumer at the appchain layer rather than the fat protocol layer.
-
Appchains enable product-market fit for blockchain technology, allowing entrepreneurs to vertically integrate the entire user experience.
-
Most blockchain applications involve two-sided markets, which can be optimized for value flows between participants.
-
The evolution of the Ethereum ecosystem exemplifies how it began as a fat-protocol-oriented system on which applications could be built.
Theory of Aggregation
-
Successful companies in the internet era such as Facebook and Google optimized around demand ownership—a concept that also partially applies to the cryptocurrency world.
-
Skepticism exists toward the fat protocol thesis, as demand aggregated at L1 is largely temporary and transitional.
-
Real demand aggregation will come from end users who are largely unaware of the underlying blockchain and simply use it as a marketplace or computing service.
-
Long-term user engagement will focus more on applications delivering the services they need.
Are There Moats?
-
There are relatively few applications with moats or competitive advantages strong enough to retain users.
-
Attracting users remains a key challenge for the future success of crypto applications.
-
As cross-chain bridge technology improves, factors that have historically driven demand concentration—such as the availability of stablecoins like USDC—are beginning to erode. Ultimately, applications will play a decisive role in determining crypto’s success, much as seen throughout the history of consumer computing.
-
Building moats in crypto is a long-term and creative process, starting with cultivating a user base and strong brand, and potentially involving the creation of liquidity flywheels.
Is Block Space a Commodity?
-
Block space is not a uniform resource.
-
Ethereum L1 block space holds value due to high transaction volume and extensive integration.
-
This advantage may weaken as alternative systems become easier to use.
-
The future value of Ethereum L1 block space remains an open question; currently, Uniswap and OpenSea are the largest consumers of Ethereum block space.
-
If these systems expand to other chains where Layer 2 transaction costs are far lower than L1 settlement, the value of Ethereum block space could diminish.
Smile Curve
-
The smile curve is a framework used to describe value distribution across a supply chain.
-
In the early personal computer industry, value was created during R&D through patents and technological innovation; manufacturing in the middle phase was commoditized, while marketing, branding, and services in the final stage held the most value.
-
This framework can also apply to cryptocurrency, where R&D is typically open-source with limited intellectual property protection, shifting value toward branding, marketing, and distribution.
-
Layer 2 solutions in crypto may face risks of commoditization.
-
Compared to traditional tech industries, crypto's overall ethos—open-source and decentralized—leads to unique patterns of value distribution.
Will dYdX Validate the Appchain Thesis?
-
dYdX’s successful migration of its high-barrier customer relationships from StarkEx to Cosmos is seen as validation of the appchain thesis.
-
Since dYdX is building a decentralized derivatives exchange, it has the potential to significantly influence perceptions about the viability of appchains.
-
However, a single success case is insufficient to prove the theory.
Controlling the Entire Stack
-
Full-stack appchains offer maximum customization and optimization but require greater resources and expertise.
-
Alternatively, application-specific L2 or L3 rollups may provide lower costs and higher accessibility but could impose limitations on customizability.
-
Applications that may benefit most from full-stack control include privacy-focused apps, where required functionality and integration levels remain challenging even on L2s.
-
In the middle of the spectrum are modular applications like Celestia, offering a compromise between the two extremes—defining boundaries between different utilities while limiting the ability to transcend them.
-
Ultimately, the choice between full-stack appchains, application-specific rollups, or modular architectures will depend on each application’s specific requirements and goals.















